6 Best Frame Honey Extractors For Beekeepers For Your First Harvest

Your first honey harvest is a moment of pure magic, the culmination of a season spent nurturing your bees. Once you pull those heavy, wax-capped frames from the hive, the next big step is getting that liquid gold into a jar. This is where a honey extractor becomes your most important tool, and choosing the right one can make the difference between a joyful afternoon and a sticky, frustrating mess.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing Your First Honey Extractor: Key Factors

The right extractor for you depends entirely on the scale of your operation, both now and in the near future. If you have one or two hives, a small two-frame manual extractor is a perfectly sensible starting point. But if you dream of a dozen hives dotting your property within a few years, investing in a slightly larger model now will save you money and a major headache later.

Think about three things: capacity, material, and power. Capacity is how many frames it holds. Material is almost always a choice between plastic and stainless steel—always choose food-grade stainless steel. It’s durable, won’t leach chemicals, and is far easier to clean and sanitize. Power is the classic debate: the simplicity of a hand crank versus the convenience of an electric motor.

Finally, consider the type of extraction. Tangential extractors hold frames like spokes in a wheel, extracting one side at a time, so you have to flip them manually. Radial extractors hold frames with the top bar facing out, extracting both sides at once using centrifugal force. For a beginner, a tangential model is often more affordable and works perfectly well for a small number of frames.

VIVO BEE-V002 Two Frame Manual Honey Extractor

This is the quintessential beginner’s extractor. The VIVO two-frame model is an affordable, no-frills machine that gets the job done for a beekeeper with one to three hives. Its stainless steel construction is a major plus at this price point, ensuring your honey remains pure and the unit is easy to clean.

Operation is straightforward. You uncap two frames, place them inside, and turn the crank. Because it’s a tangential extractor, you’ll spin out the honey from one side, flip the frames, and then spin out the other. It’s a hands-on process that connects you directly to the harvest, but it can be tiring if you have more than a few hives to process.

The clear plexiglass lid lets you watch the honey fly out, which is one of the great joys of extraction day. Its compact size makes it easy to store in a garage or shed, a key consideration when you’re not using it for 11 months of the year. For the price and simplicity, it’s a solid first choice.

Goodland Bee Supply Two Frame Stainless Extractor

Similar in function to the VIVO, the Goodland Bee Supply extractor is another excellent entry-level option, often praised for its slightly more robust build. The gears on the hand crank are enclosed, which can protect them from getting gummed up with honey and wax. This small design detail can make a big difference in cleanup and long-term durability.

This two-frame tangential extractor is built for the small-scale hobbyist. It handles deep, medium, or shallow frames, though you can only do two at a time. The workflow is identical to other manual two-frame models: uncap, load, spin, flip, and spin again. It’s a rhythm you’ll quickly master.

What sets models like this apart is often the small details in manufacturing—smoother welds, a better-fitting lid, or a more stable leg design. While functionally similar to its competitors, it’s a reliable workhorse that provides great value for beekeepers managing a small backyard apiary.

VEVOR 3-Frame Extractor for Small Apiaries

Moving up to a three-frame model like this one from VEVOR is a smart move if you’re managing two to five hives. That one extra frame slot might not sound like much, but it significantly speeds up your workflow. It reduces the number of cycles you have to run, saving you time and arm-soreness on extraction day.

This manual, tangential extractor is typically made of food-grade stainless steel and functions just like its two-frame cousins, but with a bit more capacity. The larger drum size also provides more stability. When an extractor is spinning, an unbalanced load can cause it to wobble or "walk" across the floor; a slightly larger, heavier unit helps mitigate this.

The VEVOR 3-frame hits a sweet spot. It’s still small enough to be easily managed and stored by one person, but it provides enough of a capacity boost to make a noticeable difference. It’s an excellent compromise between the bare-bones starter models and the much larger, more expensive units.

Mann Lake HH170 4/8-Frame Tangential Extractor

When you know beekeeping is a long-term passion, investing in a brand like Mann Lake pays dividends. This extractor represents a significant step up in both capacity and quality, designed for the hobbyist who is serious about growing their apiary. It’s the kind of tool you buy once and use for decades.

The "4/8" designation is key. It can hold four deep or medium frames tangentially, or it can be fitted with baskets to hold eight shallow frames radially. This versatility is its greatest strength, allowing you to adapt your extraction method to the type of frames you’re harvesting. Extracting eight shallow frames at once is a massive time-saver.

While it is a manual hand-crank model, its high-quality gearing and bearings make for a surprisingly smooth and efficient operation. This isn’t just a bigger version of the entry-level extractors; it’s a better-built machine designed for higher volume and frequent use. It’s an investment, but one that will keep up as your apiary expands from four hives to ten or more.

Dadant 6/3 Frame Hand-Crank Extractor Durability

Dadant is one of the oldest and most respected names in beekeeping, and their equipment is built to last a lifetime. This extractor is for the beekeeper who values heritage quality and uncompromising durability over bells and whistles. You are not just buying an extractor; you are buying a piece of equipment that could be passed down to the next generation.

This model’s capacity is listed as 6/3, meaning it can hold six shallow or medium frames or three deep frames. This is a substantial capacity for a hand-crank unit, making it highly efficient for someone managing five to fifteen hives without wanting to jump to an electric model. The build quality is exceptional, from the heavy-gauge stainless steel to the robust crank mechanism.

Choosing a Dadant is a "buy once, cry once" decision. The initial cost is higher than many other manual extractors, but its longevity and reliable performance provide immense long-term value. It’s a tool for beekeepers who see their apiary as a permanent fixture of their homestead.

BestEquip Electric 4-Frame for Easier Harvesting

For beekeepers with more than a handful of hives or those with physical limitations, an electric extractor changes the game entirely. The BestEquip 4-Frame is a popular entry into electric models, offering the convenience of motorized extraction without the price tag of a commercial-grade machine. You load the frames, close the lid, and flip a switch.

The biggest advantage is the reduction in physical labor. Hand-cranking for hours is tiring, but an electric motor does the work for you. Most models, including this one, have a variable speed control. This is crucial because you need to start slowly to avoid blowing out the delicate wax foundation and then ramp up the speed to get all the honey out.

While the convenience is undeniable, there are tradeoffs. Electric models are more expensive, heavier, and have more parts that can potentially fail. You also need a power source nearby. However, if you’re harvesting from eight hives, the time and energy saved make an electric extractor like this one an incredibly worthwhile investment.

Manual vs. Electric: Which Extractor Is for You?

The choice between manual and electric really boils down to three factors: the number of hives you manage, your budget, and your physical ability. There is no single right answer, only the right answer for your specific situation.

A manual extractor is perfect for a beekeeper with 1-5 hives.

• Pros: Lower cost, simple mechanics with fewer failure points, no need for electricity, and a quiet, hands-on experience.
• Cons: It’s a physical workout. Extracting honey from 20+ frames with a hand crank is a long, tiring process.

An electric extractor becomes a near-necessity for those with 5 or more hives, or for anyone who wants to minimize physical strain.

• Pros: Saves an immense amount of time and labor, provides consistent speed, and makes large harvests manageable.
• Cons: Higher initial cost, requires a power source, and is more complex to maintain and repair.

Think about your five-year plan. If you’re happy with a couple of hives in the backyard, a manual crank will serve you well indefinitely. But if you plan to expand and sell honey at the local market, investing in an electric model early will feel like a brilliant decision on your first big harvest day.

Ultimately, your first extractor is a bridge between the hard work in the bee yard and the sweet reward in the jar. Whether you choose a simple two-frame manual or a more capable electric model, select the one that fits your apiary’s current size and future ambitions. The right tool makes the harvest a celebration, not a chore.