6 Best Cheese Strainers for Home Cheesemaking

You’ve done the hard work of milking your goats, and now a pot of warm, fragrant curds and whey sits on your stove. The next step—separating the two—seems simple, but it’s the moment that defines the texture and yield of your final cheese. Using the wrong strainer can turn your cheesemaking dreams into a frustrating mess of lost curds down the drain. Choosing the right tool for the job is one of the most important, yet overlooked, skills in the homestead creamery.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Strainer Weave Matters for Goat Cheese Curds

The single most important factor in a cheese strainer is the tightness of its weave. Think of it this way: a loose weave is like a chain-link fence, while a tight weave is like a screen door. Both are barriers, but they stop very different things. When you’re working with goat milk, this distinction is critical.

Goat milk proteins form smaller, more delicate curds compared to cow’s milk. A standard kitchen colander or a cheap, low-grade cheesecloth (like Grade 10 or 20) has a weave that’s far too open. Your precious, fragile curds will slip right through with the whey, drastically reducing your yield. You’re literally pouring your time and your goat’s effort down the sink.

A finer weave, on the other hand, captures these delicate solids while allowing the watery whey to drain away slowly and completely. This is what gives you a creamy, dense chevre instead of a gritty, watery disappointment. For homesteaders on a budget, maximizing yield from every gallon of milk is non-negotiable, and it all starts with the right weave.

Plymouth Pantry Grade 90: The Versatile Classic

There’s a reason Grade 90 cheesecloth is the standard for home cheesemakers. The "90" refers to the thread count per inch, creating a tight, durable weave that’s nearly perfect for goat cheese. It’s fine enough to capture even the smallest curds but still porous enough to allow whey to drain efficiently.

This isn’t the flimsy gauze you find in the grocery store’s baking aisle. Grade 90 is a reusable, washable workhorse. You can cut it to fit any size pot or bowl, making it adaptable whether you’re processing a half-gallon or three gallons of milk. After use, a thorough rinse in cold water, followed by a hot wash with unscented soap and a boil to sanitize, gets it ready for the next batch.

Its versatility is its greatest strength. A single layer is perfect for draining chevre. If you need an even finer strain for something like goat milk ricotta, you can simply fold it into a double layer. For a homesteader who values multi-purpose tools, a yard or two of Grade 90 cheesecloth is one of the best investments you can make.

The Amazing Nut Milk Bag for No-Fuss Chevre

If you value convenience and speed, the nut milk bag is your best friend. These are essentially pre-sewn bags made from fine-mesh nylon, complete with a drawstring closure. They take all the guesswork and fuss out of lining a colander and gathering up the corners of a cheesecloth square.

The process couldn’t be simpler. You just place the bag in a colander, pour your curds and whey in, pull the drawstring tight, and hang it from a cabinet knob to drain. The nylon material is incredibly durable, rinses clean in seconds, and dries almost instantly, which helps prevent the musty odors that can plague improperly dried cotton cloths.

While not as adaptable in size as a sheet of cheesecloth, most nut milk bags are perfectly sized for one- to two-gallon batches of goat cheese. Their biggest advantage is time. For the busy homesteader trying to fit cheesemaking in between other chores, the minutes saved by not having to fold, tie, and wrangle a piece of cloth are invaluable. It’s a modern, efficient tool that delivers excellent results with minimal effort.

Euro Cuisine Yogurt Strainer for Drier Cheeses

Sometimes, consistency is more important than volume. The Euro Cuisine Yogurt Strainer is a purpose-built tool designed for one job: creating a thick, dense, and perfectly consistent soft cheese or yogurt. It consists of a plastic outer container and a fine stainless steel mesh basket that sits inside.

This is the ultimate "set it and forget it" method. You pour your curds (or yogurt) into the mesh basket, put the lid on, and place the whole unit in the refrigerator. The whey slowly drips into the outer container, and because it’s in the fridge, the draining happens slowly and safely over 12 to 24 hours. There’s no hanging, no mess, and the result is a firm, spreadable cheese with a texture that’s hard to replicate by hanging.

The main tradeoff is batch size. Most models can only handle about two quarts of milk at a time, so it’s not ideal for processing a huge flush of spring milk. But for making a consistently dry, almost cream cheese-like product from a gallon or less, its ease of use and reliable results are unmatched.

A Stainless Steel Colander for Pre-Draining Curds

A standard metal colander, on its own, is a disaster for goat cheese. The holes are far too large, and you’ll watch in horror as half your curds wash away. However, it plays a crucial role as a support tool for bigger batches. Its true value is in the initial separation of curds and whey.

When you have two or three gallons of milk worth of curds floating in whey, ladling it all into a cheesecloth-lined bowl is slow and cumbersome. Instead, you can pour the entire pot through a colander to instantly remove 80% of the whey. The curds will be caught, and you can then immediately transfer the wet mass of curds into your final, fine-mesh strainer (like cheesecloth or a nut milk bag).

This two-step process dramatically speeds up draining time. It gets the bulk of the liquid out of the way so the finer cloth doesn’t get waterlogged. Think of the colander not as a strainer, but as a de-watering tool. Nearly every homesteader already has one, making it a free and effective way to streamline your cheesemaking day.

Cultures for Health Butter Muslin: A Finer Weave

If you’ve ever felt that even Grade 90 cheesecloth was letting a few too many fines escape, butter muslin is the next step up. It has an even tighter weave, designed specifically for retaining the smallest milk solids and butterfats. It feels less like gauze and more like a high-quality cotton handkerchief.

This finer weave is ideal for a few specific situations. It’s excellent for very delicate cheeses where the curd is barely set, ensuring you capture every last bit. It’s also the go-to for making cultured butter or catching the fines from a batch of ricotta. The resulting cheese will often be slightly creamier because more of the milk fats are retained.

The tradeoff for this precision is speed. Draining through butter muslin is noticeably slower than with Grade 90 cheesecloth. You may need to gently scrape the sides of the cloth partway through to prevent the pores from clogging and stalling the draining process. It’s a specialty tool for when you’re chasing maximum yield and the creamiest possible texture, and you have a little extra time to achieve it.

Flour Sack Towels: The Ultra-Budget Homestead Hack

Before there were specialized cheesecloth grades and nylon bags, there were simple cotton towels. A clean, 100% cotton flour sack towel is a surprisingly effective and completely free (if you already own them) tool for straining goat cheese.

The key is to use a towel with a tight, lint-free weave. Make sure it has been washed many times in unscented detergent and has never been touched by fabric softener, which can leave a residue that ruins your cheese. Simply sanitize it by boiling it for a few minutes before use, and it functions almost identically to butter muslin.

This is the ultimate homesteader’s solution. It requires no special purchases and uses an item you likely have in a drawer. The main downsides are that they can wear out faster than dedicated cheesecloth and can be prone to holding onto odors if not washed and dried meticulously. But for the new cheesemaker or anyone in a pinch, a humble flour sack towel works beautifully.

Choosing a Strainer Based on Batch Size and Time

The best strainer isn’t a single product; it’s the one that matches your specific needs on cheesemaking day. Your decision should come down to a simple assessment of how much milk you’re processing and how much time you can dedicate to the process.

Here’s a simple framework:

• For Versatility and Large Batches (1-4 gallons): Grade 90 Cheesecloth is your best bet. It’s adaptable, reusable, and effective.
• For Speed and Convenience (1-2 gallons): A Nut Milk Bag will save you time and cleanup with no loss in quality.
• For Ultimate Consistency and Small Batches (under 1 gallon): The Euro Cuisine Yogurt Strainer provides hands-off, reliable results for a drier cheese.
• For the Absolute Tightest Budget: A well-washed Flour Sack Towel will get the job done with surprising efficiency.

Many experienced homesteaders use a combination approach. They might use a Stainless Steel Colander for the initial bulk draining of a three-gallon batch, then transfer the curds to a Nut Milk Bag for the final hang. Don’t feel locked into one method. The goal is to create a system that is efficient, affordable, and produces the goat cheese your family loves.

Ultimately, the right straining tool is the one that removes friction from your cheesemaking process and helps you consistently create a product you’re proud of. Experiment with what you have, invest where it makes sense for your goals, and focus on the simple joy of turning your goats’ fresh milk into delicious cheese. The perfect system for your homestead is the one you’ll actually use.