6 Best Cow Milk Cheese Presses For Small Farms Old Farmers Swear By

You’ve finally done it. After mastering soft cheeses like chevre and farmer’s cheese, you’re ready to tackle a hard, aged cheddar or a creamy gouda. But as you look at the bucket of beautiful, warm curds from your family cow, you realize your makeshift press of bricks and cutting boards just won’t cut it for the consistent, heavy pressure needed. A real cheese press isn’t a luxury for making hard cheese; it’s the central piece of equipment that determines your success.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why a Good Press is Key for Farmstead Cheese

A cheese press does more than just squeeze water out of curds. Its primary job is to apply steady, even pressure, knitting the individual curds into a solid, uniform mass. This process is what creates the dense, smooth texture of a proper hard cheese and eliminates the air pockets where unwanted mold can grow.

Without a good press, you get an inconsistent wheel. The outside might be overly dry and crumbly while the inside remains too moist, leading to problems during aging. A dedicated press allows you to control the pressure precisely, starting low and gradually increasing it over hours or days. This methodical approach is crucial for developing a proper rind, which acts as a natural barrier protecting the cheese as it ages.

Think of it this way: the press is what transforms a loose collection of curds into a stable wheel capable of aging for months or even years. Makeshift setups with weights are prone to tipping and applying uneven pressure, risking a failed cheese after all your hard work. A purpose-built press provides the stability and control you need to get reliable, delicious results every single time.

New England Cheesemaking Supply Dutch Press

The Dutch-style lever press is a classic for a reason. It uses a simple lever and hanging weights to apply a significant, calculated amount of pressure to your cheese. The New England Cheesemaking Supply version is a beautiful, functional example of this timeless design.

This press shines in its precision. The long lever arm multiplies the force of your weights, so a few pounds of weight can exert hundreds of pounds of pressure on the cheese. You know exactly how much pressure you’re applying based on the weight and its position on the lever, which is perfect for following traditional recipes that specify pressures in PSI. It’s a very hands-on, satisfying process.

The main tradeoff is its size; the lever arm requires a good bit of counter space. But for the small farmer who appreciates traditional methods and wants repeatable, accurate results without relying on springs, this style of press is hard to beat. It’s a workhorse that connects you directly to the craft of cheesemaking.

The Homesteader’s Ultimate Cheese Press

This press is designed for practicality and efficiency on a busy farm. It typically features a more compact, vertical design, often using a large screw mechanism or a spring system to apply pressure. It’s built for the person who needs a reliable tool that doesn’t demand a lot of fuss.

The beauty of this style is its simplicity and smaller footprint. You can often fit it into a corner of the kitchen or milk room without it getting in the way. Many models are made from durable hardwood or food-grade plastics, making them relatively easy to clean and maintain. They are often sold as complete kits, which is a huge bonus.

This is the press for someone making cheese in between other chores. You don’t need to calculate lever ratios; you just turn the screw or set the spring tension. While it might lack the old-world charm of a Dutch press, its straightforward functionality makes it a favorite for homesteaders who value results and efficiency above all else.

TSM Stainless Steel Press for Durability

When your top priority is sanitation and longevity, a stainless steel press is the answer. The TSM press is a prime example of a tool built to last a lifetime and meet the highest standards of cleanliness. There’s no wood to oil or worry about absorbing whey or bacteria.

Cleaning is incredibly simple. After pressing, you can wash it thoroughly with hot, soapy water and sanitize it just like your other dairy equipment. This peace of mind is invaluable, especially if you ever plan to sell your cheese. The non-porous surface ensures that no off-flavors will transfer to your next batch.

This isn’t the most traditional-looking press, and it can be more expensive upfront. But it’s an investment in food safety and durability. For a small dairy operation where cleanliness is paramount, the rugged, easy-to-sanitize nature of a stainless steel press like the TSM makes it a top contender. It’s a piece of professional-grade equipment scaled for the small farm.

Lehman’s Own Classic Wooden Cheese Press

Lehman’s has built its reputation on providing non-electric, traditional tools for homesteaders, and their cheese press is no exception. This press is all about embracing the heritage of farmstead cheesemaking. It’s typically made of solid hardwood and has a simple, robust design that feels like it came straight out of your great-grandmother’s kitchen.

Using a press like this is a tactile experience. The feel of the oiled wood and the simple mechanics connect you to the history of the craft. It’s a beautiful tool that you’ll be proud to have in your kitchen. It functions perfectly well, using a screw mechanism to apply direct, even pressure.

Of course, wood requires care. You’ll need to keep it clean and dry, and periodically treat it with a food-safe oil to prevent it from cracking or absorbing moisture. For many, this maintenance is part of the appeal—it’s about caring for your tools. This press is for the farmer who sees cheesemaking not just as food production, but as an art form.

The Fromagex Spring-Loaded Cheese Press

The biggest advantage of a spring-loaded press is its ability to provide continuous pressure. As whey is expelled, the cheese curds shrink and the volume in the mold decreases. A weight-based or simple screw press will lose pressure as this happens, requiring you to come back and tighten it periodically.

Spring-loaded presses, like those from Fromagex, solve this problem. The calibrated springs continue to push down with a consistent force as the cheese settles. This "set it and forget it" feature is a game-changer for a busy farmer. You can set the pressure, walk away to do evening chores, and trust that the press is doing its job perfectly.

These presses are often more compact and made with a combination of stainless steel and durable plastics for easy cleaning. They offer a modern, efficient approach to a traditional craft. If you value consistency and have limited time to babysit your cheese as it presses, a spring-loaded model is an excellent choice.

Hoegger Supply Company Hard Cheese Press Kit

For the farmer just getting into hard cheeses, starting with a complete kit can remove a lot of the guesswork. Hoegger Supply, a trusted name in homesteading supplies, offers a hard cheese press kit that bundles the essentials together. This is the perfect entry point.

These kits typically include a simple, effective press—often a sturdy PVC or wooden frame with a screw mechanism—along with a food-grade mold (the "hoop") and a follower. Some kits even throw in cheesecloth and a basic recipe to get you started. It’s a one-stop shop for your first aged cheddar.

While the press itself might be simpler than some of the more specialized models, it’s more than capable of producing excellent cheese. The real value is in its accessibility. It takes the intimidation out of sourcing all the individual components and lets you focus on learning the process. You can always upgrade later, but a Hoegger kit is a fantastic and reliable way to begin your hard cheesemaking journey.

Choosing the Right Press for Your Farm’s Needs

There is no single "best" cheese press; there is only the best press for your farm and your goals. Making the right choice comes down to honestly assessing your priorities.

Start by considering these key factors:

• Batch Size and Frequency: Are you making small, two-gallon batches occasionally, or five-gallon batches every week? Make sure the press can accommodate the size of cheese wheel you plan to make.
• Material and Maintenance: A stainless steel press offers the ultimate in sanitation and durability with minimal fuss. A wooden press is traditional and beautiful but requires regular oiling and careful cleaning to prevent contamination.
• Pressure System: Do you prefer the hands-on, precise nature of a Dutch lever press? Or does the "set it and forget it" convenience of a spring-loaded press appeal more to your busy schedule? A simple screw press offers a great balance of control and simplicity.
• Your Budget: Prices can range significantly. A simple kit will be the most affordable entry point, while a large stainless steel or traditional Dutch press is a bigger investment. Don’t forget to factor in the cost of molds if they aren’t included.

Ultimately, the right press is one you’ll actually use. If you dread cleaning a wooden press, get the stainless steel one. If you love the idea of calculating lever mechanics, the Dutch press will bring you joy. Match the tool to your workflow, and you’ll be on your way to crafting beautiful, aged farmstead cheese.

Investing in a quality cheese press is a commitment to your craft. It’s the tool that bridges the gap between fresh curds and a wheel of cheese you can be proud of. Choose wisely, and it will serve you for decades, turning the rich milk from your cows into a delicious, shelf-stable food that truly represents the bounty of your farm.