6 Best Lever Cheese Presses For Beginners That Prevent Common Issues

You’ve followed the recipe perfectly, your curds are cut, and now comes the moment of truth: pressing. Stacking encyclopedias or rigging up a system of clamps and weights feels clever, until you end up with a lopsided, crumbly wheel of cheese. A dedicated lever press isn’t just a piece of equipment; it’s your key to consistent, repeatable results that turn good effort into great cheese.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Lever Presses Beat DIY Setups for New Makers

Let’s be honest, the temptation to rig a DIY press is strong. It seems simple enough to stack some weights on a follower and call it a day. The problem is that this method delivers uneven and unreliable pressure, leading to the most common beginner frustrations.

A stack of weights can easily tilt, pressing one side of the cheese more than the other. This creates pockets of trapped whey, which can lead to off-flavors and poor texture. A lever press, by contrast, uses mechanical advantage to apply consistent, even force directly down onto the follower. You know exactly how much pressure you’re applying, and you can adjust it precisely.

This control is what separates beginners from consistent cheesemakers. Proper pressing expels the right amount of whey, knits the curds together into a solid mass, and forms the foundation for a proper rind. A lever press is a tool for consistency, and consistency is the goal.

The Ultimate Cheese Press for Sturdy, Reliable Use

When you’re ready to move beyond casual experimenting and into making hard, aged cheeses, you need a press that won’t flinch. The "Ultimate Cheese Press" is a workhorse, typically built from thick hardwood or stainless steel, designed for maximum stability and pressure. Its long lever arm provides significant mechanical advantage, allowing you to easily apply the heavy, sustained pressure needed for cheeses like Parmesan or aged Cheddar.

The defining feature of this style of press is its robust, no-flex frame. Cheaper or smaller presses can bow under the high pressure required for very hard cheeses, but this one is built to handle it. The design is simple, with few moving parts to fail, making it a true "buy it for life" tool.

Think of this as an investment in your cheesemaking future. It eliminates equipment failure as a variable, so you can focus entirely on your recipe and technique. If you know you want to make large, long-aging wheels of cheese, starting with a press like this will save you from having to upgrade later.

NECS Dutch Style Press: Classic, Effective Design

The Dutch style press is a classic for a reason. Its design, which uses a simple lever and fulcrum system, has been trusted by cheesemakers for centuries. The version from New England Cheesemaking Supply (NECS) is a perfect example of this timeless tool, offering an excellent balance of functionality and traditional aesthetics.

Typically crafted from durable hardwood, the Dutch press is intuitive to use. You place your weighted jug or container on the end of the lever, and the press multiplies that force onto your cheese mold. The notches along the lever arm allow for easy and repeatable pressure adjustments, taking the guesswork out of your pressing schedule.

This press hits the sweet spot for most hobby farmers. It can generate enough pressure for most semi-hard and hard cheeses you’d want to make, from Gouda to Colby. It’s a significant step up from any DIY setup without being overly complicated or expensive, making it a fantastic choice for a beginner’s first serious press.

TSM Stainless Steel Press for Easy Sanitation

In cheesemaking, cleanliness is everything. While traditional wooden presses are beautiful, their porous nature can be a challenge to keep perfectly sanitized. The TSM Stainless Steel Press solves this problem completely, making it an outstanding choice for beginners who want to minimize food safety risks.

Made entirely of stainless steel, this press can be washed and sanitized as easily as a stockpot. There are no cracks or pores for whey to seep into, which drastically reduces the risk of unwanted bacteria or mold contaminating your workspace and future cheeses. This peace of mind is invaluable when you’re just starting out.

The tradeoff is purely aesthetic; you lose the warm, traditional look of wood. But for many, the practical advantage of effortless sanitation is a clear winner. If your primary concern is food safety and ease of cleanup, a stainless steel press is the most logical choice.

Cheese&Yo Press: A Compact Choice for Small Kitchens

Not everyone has a dedicated "cheese cave" or even a large pantry. For many hobbyists, cheesemaking happens right on the kitchen counter, where space is a premium. The Cheese&Yo press is designed specifically for this reality, offering a compact, effective solution that won’t take over your workspace.

Often constructed from food-grade plastic and stainless steel components, this press is small, lightweight, and easy to store in a cabinet when not in use. Its design is typically a screw-style or a small lever system, perfect for applying the light-to-medium pressure needed for smaller 1- to 2-pound cheeses like paneer, queso fresco, or small farmhouse cheddars.

This press is the ideal entry point for someone making cheese from just one or two gallons of milk at a time. It provides the consistent pressure you need without the footprint or cost of a larger, heavy-duty model. It’s a practical tool for the modern homesteader with a small kitchen.

Artisan Oak Lever Press for Precise Pressure

For the cheesemaker who appreciates craftsmanship, an artisan oak lever press is as much a joy to use as it is a functional tool. These presses are often handmade from beautiful, sturdy hardwoods like oak, combining functionality with an aesthetic that honors the tradition of cheesemaking. They are built not just to work, but to be admired.

The key advantage of a well-made artisan press is precision. The lever arms are often carefully marked with notches, allowing for incredibly specific and repeatable weight placements. This lets you follow complex pressing schedules with confidence, knowing you’re applying the exact pressure required at each stage.

This is the press for someone who views cheesemaking as a craft. It’s for the person who wants to fine-tune their process for aged, complex cheeses and who values the tactile experience of working with high-quality, natural materials. It’s a functional piece of art for your home dairy.

NECS Basic Beginner Kit with Dutch Style Press

One of the biggest hurdles for a new cheesemaker isn’t the process itself, but gathering all the right supplies. The NECS Basic Beginner Kit with their Dutch Style Press brilliantly solves this problem. It bundles the essential tools together, removing the guesswork and ensuring you have what you need to get started successfully.

A typical kit includes the press itself, a properly sized mold (hoop) and follower, and cheesecloth. Some kits go further, including starter cultures, rennet, and cheese salt. This all-in-one approach means you won’t find yourself halfway through a recipe only to realize you’re missing a critical component.

Starting with a kit is one of the smartest things a beginner can do. It lowers the barrier to entry and builds confidence by providing a proven set of tools that are designed to work together. You can always upgrade individual pieces later, but a kit guarantees your first few attempts are focused on learning the craft, not chasing down supplies.

Choosing Your Press: Material and Capacity Guide

Selecting the right press comes down to three key factors: material, capacity, and your long-term cheesemaking goals. There’s no single "best" press, only the one that’s best for you.

First, consider the material.

• Wood: Offers a classic, traditional feel and is very sturdy. It requires more careful cleaning and oiling to prevent it from drying out or absorbing whey.
• Stainless Steel: The champion of sanitation. It’s incredibly easy to clean and sterilize, removing a major source of potential contamination.
• Food-Grade Plastic: Often found on smaller, more compact models. It’s lightweight, easy to clean, and affordable, but may not handle the high pressure needed for very hard, aged cheeses.

Next, think about capacity and pressure. Are you planning to make small, 2-pound wheels from a couple of gallons of milk, or are you aiming for larger 5- or 10-pound wheels for long-term aging? Ensure the press can accommodate the diameter and height of your desired cheese mold. More importantly, confirm it can generate the necessary pressure—hard cheeses like Parmesan can require 50 pounds of weight or more, which is then multiplied by the lever.

Finally, be realistic about your ambitions. If you’re just exploring cheesemaking, a compact, affordable press is a fantastic way to learn. But if you’re already dreaming of stocking a cheese cave with long-aged hard cheeses, investing in a sturdy, high-pressure press from the start will prevent frustration and save you money in the long run.

Your cheese press is the bridge between a pot of curds and a beautiful, well-formed wheel of cheese. Choosing a reliable lever press that fits your kitchen and your ambitions eliminates one of the biggest variables in the process. Get the pressing right, and you’re well on your way to crafting delicious cheese you can be proud of.