6 Best John Deere Mx6 Rotary Cutters For 5 Acres Old Farmers Swear By

You’ve got the tractor, and now you’re staring at a field that’s gotten away from you. The grass is knee-high, young saplings are creeping in from the fenceline, and you need a tool that can handle it all without fuss. Choosing the right rotary cutter feels like a major commitment, because it is—it’s the implement you’ll rely on season after season to keep your land in check. For a small farm of around five acres, making the right choice upfront saves countless hours of frustration down the road.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why John Deere Rotary Cutters Dominate Small Farms

When you see a green rotary cutter on a small farm, it’s not just about brand loyalty. It’s about practicality. John Deere and its Frontier line have built a reputation on reliability and, more importantly, parts availability.

When a shear bolt breaks or a blade needs replacing on a Saturday afternoon, you can usually find what you need at the local dealer. This network of support is a lifeline for hobby farmers who can’t afford days of downtime waiting for a part to be shipped. You’re not just buying a piece of steel; you’re buying into a system designed to keep you running.

This reliability means less time tinkering and more time working. The build quality is consistently solid, designed to handle the unexpected rocks and stumps that are a fact of life on unmanicured land. For someone balancing a day job with farm chores, that peace of mind is worth its weight in gold.

The John Deere MX6: A Reliable Pasture Workhorse

The MX6 is the quintessential 6-foot cutter for a reason. It hits the sweet spot for a compact utility tractor in the 30-50 horsepower range, making it a perfect match for the machines most people use on 5 to 20 acres. It’s wide enough to make quick work of an open pasture but not so wide that it’s clumsy.

This isn’t a light-duty "finish mower." The MX6 is built to tackle thick grass, tough weeds, and even saplings up to two inches in diameter. Its double-deck design adds rigidity and prevents rust from the top down, a common failure point on cheaper, single-deck mowers that collect wet debris.

Think of the MX6 as your go-to for maintaining established fields. It’s the implement you hook up to keep pastures from turning into brush patches. While it can handle some rough stuff, its primary job is consistent, reliable mowing, and it does that job exceptionally well.

MX6 with Chain Guards for Debris Management

When you buy a rotary cutter, you’ll often see options for guards, typically rubber or chain. Always opt for the chain guards. While rubber flaps might seem sufficient, they become brittle over time and can be torn off by thick brush, rendering them useless.

Chain guards provide superior protection without impeding the flow of material. They effectively knock down rocks, sticks, and other debris that the blades can launch at dangerous speeds. This is non-negotiable if you’re mowing anywhere near buildings, vehicles, or a gravel driveway. A single thrown rock can shatter a window or dent a truck door.

The safety aspect can’t be overstated. The chains create a flexible but formidable barrier that contains projectiles, protecting both you on the tractor and anyone or anything in the vicinity. It’s a small upfront cost that prevents expensive—and potentially tragic—accidents.

John Deere MX5: Compact Power for Tight Spaces

Sometimes, six feet is too much. The John Deere MX5 is the 5-foot version of its bigger sibling, and it shines in specific situations. If you’re running a smaller compact tractor (under 35 PTO horsepower), the MX5 is a much better match, preventing you from bogging down in heavy growth.

Its narrower footprint is a huge advantage for properties with obstacles. Mowing between rows in a young orchard, navigating tight corners along a creek bed, or clearing trails through the woods are all jobs where the MX5 excels. What you lose in mowing efficiency per pass, you gain in precision and maneuverability.

Don’t mistake its smaller size for lesser quality. The MX5 shares the same heavy-duty construction as the MX6. It’s the right tool when your five acres aren’t a simple, open rectangle but a landscape with character and challenges.

The Frontier RC2072 for Heavier Brush Clearing

While the MX series is for maintenance, the Frontier RC20 series is for reclamation. The RC2072 is a 6-foot (72-inch) cutter built to handle rougher, more demanding work. If you’re faced with a field that hasn’t been touched in years, this is the tool for the job.

The key difference is its cutting capacity. The RC2072 is typically rated for material up to three inches in diameter, a significant step up from the MX6. This makes it a true "brush hog," capable of chewing through thick briars, overgrown shrubs, and large saplings that would stop a standard-duty cutter in its tracks.

Frontier equipment is made by other manufacturers for John Deere, offering a balance of performance and value. The RC2072 provides a heavier-duty option that still comes with the convenience of dealer support, making it a smart choice for tackling the initial clearing of a property before transitioning to a maintenance mower like the MX6.

Frontier RC2060: A Budget-Friendly 5-Foot Option

If your needs are straightforward pasture mowing and your budget is a primary concern, the Frontier RC2060 is a fantastic choice. As a 5-foot (60-inch) cutter, it’s a direct competitor to the MX5 but often comes in at a more accessible price point. It’s a workhorse for general-purpose mowing.

This cutter is ideal for someone who primarily deals with grass and weeds, not heavy brush. It’s a reliable tool for keeping a few acres tidy without the overbuilt features (and cost) of a heavy-duty brush hog. For a smaller tractor, it’s a perfectly balanced implement for routine work.

The tradeoff is usually in the finer details of construction compared to the premium MX line. The deck might be a slightly lighter gauge of steel, or the gearbox might have a lower horsepower rating. However, for standard pasture maintenance, the RC2060 delivers excellent performance and value.

Slip-Clutch Drivelines: Protecting Your Tractor

Rotary cutters connect to your tractor’s PTO shaft, and you need a way to protect the drivetrain from sudden impacts. You have two options: a shear bolt or a slip clutch. A shear bolt is a soft bolt designed to break when you hit something solid, like a large rock or stump. It’s cheap to replace, but it’s a major hassle to do so in the middle of a field.

A slip clutch, on the other hand, is a series of friction plates that "slip" under high torque, absorbing the shock without breaking anything. It makes a loud chattering noise to let you know it’s working, and you simply back off the obstacle and continue mowing. No getting off the tractor, no tools required.

While a slip clutch adds to the initial cost of the cutter, it is an essential investment. It protects your tractor’s expensive PTO components from shock loads that can cause catastrophic failure. Consider a slip clutch mandatory, not optional. It will pay for itself the first time you hit a hidden stump.

Matching Cutter Gearbox HP to Your Tractor’s PTO

This is one of the most critical and overlooked aspects of buying a cutter. Every rotary cutter has a gearbox with a maximum horsepower rating. This rating must be higher than your tractor’s PTO horsepower output. Mismatching these can destroy the cutter’s gearbox in short order.

Don’t confuse your tractor’s engine horsepower with its PTO horsepower; the PTO figure is always lower and is the one that matters here. For example, putting a cutter rated for a 40 HP gearbox on a tractor with 50 PTO horsepower is a recipe for disaster. The tractor’s power will overwhelm and shred the gears inside the cutter.

Always check the specs. A good rule of thumb is to have a gearbox rated at least 10-20% above your tractor’s PTO horsepower to provide a safe margin. This ensures the implement can handle the full power of your machine, especially when you hit a tough patch of brush and the load spikes.

Ultimately, the best rotary cutter isn’t a specific model number, but the one that fits your tractor, your property, and your specific tasks. Whether it’s the all-around capability of an MX6 for pasture maintenance or the brute force of an RC2072 for clearing new ground, the right choice comes from an honest assessment of your needs. By focusing on the right size, duty rating, and protective features like a slip clutch, you’re not just buying an implement—you’re investing in a reliable partner for managing your land for years to come.