6 Best Premium Cheese Presses For Serious Cheesemakers That Preserve Traditions

You’ve probably stacked bricks, jugs of water, or even free weights on a cheese mold, hoping for the best. That works for a while, but for consistent, dense, and properly aged hard cheeses, guesswork isn’t a strategy. Investing in a dedicated cheese press is the single biggest step you can take to elevate your cheesemaking from a hopeful hobby to a reliable craft. It’s the bridge between soft, fresh cheeses and the beautiful, aged wheels that define traditional dairying.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing a Press for Consistent, Quality Curds

A cheese press does more than just squeeze water out of curds. Its real job is to knit the curds together under consistent, measurable pressure, forming a solid mass that can develop a protective rind and age gracefully. Without it, you get uneven texture, trapped pockets of whey that lead to spoilage, and a cheese that never quite reaches its full potential.

Moving from a DIY weight system to a purpose-built press is a game-changer. A dedicated press allows you to apply specific, repeatable pounds of pressure, a critical factor for recipes like Cheddar or Parmesan. It ensures the pressure is even across the entire surface of the cheese, which is nearly impossible to achieve with a stack of books. This isn’t about buying fancy gear; it’s about controlling the variables that make or break a good hard cheese.

Homesteader’s Supply: A Durable Dutch-Style Press

The Dutch-style press is a classic for a reason. It uses a simple, long lever arm to multiply the force of a small weight, delivering significant and consistent pressure onto your cheese. The design is elegant, effective, and has been trusted by cheesemakers for centuries.

Homesteader’s Supply offers a robust version of this traditional press, often crafted from durable hardwood. It’s a workhorse, perfectly suited for the hobby farmer making regular batches of Gouda, Edam, or farmstead cheddar. There are no complex springs or gauges to fail—just gravity and leverage. This is the press for someone who values reliability and time-tested design over modern complexity. It gets the job done, batch after batch.

TSM Stainless Steel Press for Precision & Hygiene

If you prioritize sanitation and precise, measurable pressure, a stainless steel press is your best bet. Unlike wood, non-porous stainless steel won’t absorb whey, bacteria, or cleaning solutions, making it incredibly easy to keep sterile. This is a major consideration if you ever plan to sell your cheese or simply want to maintain the highest standards of food safety.

The TSM (The Sausage Maker) press is a popular example, typically using a screw mechanism rather than a lever. This allows for fine-tuned, incremental pressure adjustments. Many models can be fitted with a pressure gauge, taking the guesswork out of hitting that "50 pounds of pressure" mark in your recipe. It might lack the rustic charm of a wooden press, but it offers unmatched precision and peace of mind.

Lehman’s Hardwood Press: Traditional Craftsmanship

Lehman’s has built its reputation on providing non-electric, traditional tools that last a lifetime, and their cheese presses are no exception. A hardwood press from Lehman’s is more than just a tool; it’s a nod to a simpler, more deliberate way of doing things. These presses are built with solid craftsmanship, meant to be used, cared for, and passed down.

Often made from maple or other hardwoods, these presses embody the spirit of traditional cheesemaking. They are sturdy, functional, and beautiful to look at. For the cheesemaker who finds joy in the process itself—the feel of the wood, the quiet work of the press—this type of press connects you directly to the long history of the craft. It’s an investment in both your cheesemaking and your homestead’s ethos.

The Ultimate Cheese Press: For Serious Production

At some point, your cheesemaking might outgrow a single-mold press. When you’re processing five or ten gallons of milk at a time and want to make multiple wheels, you need a press built for volume. "The Ultimate Cheese Press" is a well-regarded brand that offers just that—heavy-duty, often stainless steel presses that can handle larger molds or even press multiple cheeses at once.

These presses are designed for efficiency and power. They often feature robust acme-threaded screws for applying immense pressure with minimal effort and may include integrated pressure gauges. This is the right choice for the serious homesteader, the small farmstead dairy, or anyone looking to turn their passion into a small-scale business. It’s a significant step up in both capacity and cost, but it pays for itself in time saved and product consistency.

Hoegger Supply Co. Press for Farmstead Dairies

Hoegger Supply Co. is a name trusted by goat keepers and small dairy farmers everywhere. Their equipment is designed with the practical needs of a working farm in mind. A cheese press from Hoegger is built to be a reliable piece of farm equipment, not a delicate kitchen gadget. It’s sturdy, no-nonsense, and ready for heavy use.

These presses are often a hybrid of practical materials, combining durable wood frames with stainless steel components where hygiene is most critical. They are designed to handle the larger volumes of milk a small herd can produce. Choosing a Hoegger press is a practical decision for the farmstead cheesemaker who needs equipment that can keep up with their milk supply. It’s less about aesthetic and more about pure, dependable function.

Artisan Oak Presses: Heirloom-Quality Cheesemaking

For some, cheesemaking is as much an art as it is a science. An artisan-made oak press speaks directly to that sentiment. These are often handcrafted by individual woodworkers, built from beautiful hardwoods like oak and finished with food-safe oils. They are functional sculptures, designed to be the centerpiece of a traditional kitchen or cheese cave.

An artisan press is an heirloom-quality tool. It’s for the cheesemaker who appreciates the story behind their tools and wants to feel a connection to the entire process. While perfectly functional, the primary appeal is its beauty and the tradition it represents. This isn’t the most practical choice for high-volume production, but for creating small, special batches of cheese with intention, it is unmatched.

Key Features: Pressure Gauges, Materials & Molds

When you’re ready to buy, the details matter. Don’t just look at the overall press; consider the components that determine its performance and how it will fit into your workflow.

• Pressure Application: Lever-style presses (Dutch) are simple and reliable, using weights to apply force. Screw-style presses offer more granular control and can often apply higher pressure, which is essential for very hard, dry cheeses. Some high-end presses even use pneumatic or hydraulic systems, but that’s beyond the scope of most hobby farms.

• Gauges and Measurement: Knowing you’re applying 40 pounds of pressure versus about 40 pounds makes a huge difference in repeatability. Some presses have built-in gauges. For those that don’t, you’ll need to do some simple math (especially with lever presses) to calculate the pressure based on the weight you add. Precision here is what separates good cheese from great cheese.

• Materials: The choice between wood and stainless steel comes down to tradition versus hygiene. Wood is classic and functional but requires careful cleaning and oiling to prevent cracking and bacterial growth. Stainless steel is sterile, easy to clean, and will last forever, but it lacks the warmth and character of a wooden press.

• Molds and Followers: Your press is only as good as the mold you put in it. Ensure the press you choose can accommodate the size and shape of the cheese molds you plan to use. The follower—the disc that sits on top of the curds inside the mold—must fit properly to distribute the pressure evenly.

Ultimately, the best cheese press is the one that matches your goals, your volume, and your philosophy. Whether it’s a simple wooden lever press that honors tradition or a precise stainless steel model built for sanitation, the right press is a partner in your craft. It’s an investment that pays you back with every consistent, delicious, and beautifully aged wheel of cheese you pull from your cave.