6 Best Livestock Water Heaters For Winter Old Farmers Swear By
Prevent frozen water with the 6 best, farmer-tested livestock heaters. We cover reliable submersible de-icers, drain plug models, and more for a safe winter.
The first freeze of the year always brings a familiar sound: the dull thud of an axe against a sheet of ice in a water trough. For a new farmer, it’s a frustrating chore; for a seasoned one, it’s a signal that winter work has truly begun. But constantly breaking ice isn’t just a drain on your time—it’s a risk to your animals’ health.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Why Ice-Free Water is Critical for Winter Herds
Dehydration is just as dangerous in winter as it is in the summer heat, maybe even more so. Livestock need ample water to digest dry winter forage like hay. Without it, you risk serious health issues like impaction colic in horses or decreased milk production in goats and cattle.
Animals simply won’t—or can’t—drink enough if they have to break through a layer of ice or sip frigid water. They might take a few tentative licks, but they won’t consume the gallons they need to stay healthy and maintain body temperature. Providing a source of constantly available, ice-free water isn’t a luxury; it’s a fundamental part of responsible animal husbandry.
Ultimately, investing in a good water heater is about more than just animal welfare. It’s about your own sanity and efficiency. Swapping a twice-daily, back-breaking chore for a reliable, automated solution frees up your limited time for other critical winter tasks. It’s one of the best investments you can make for a smoother, safer winter on the farm.
Farm Innovators H-419: The Classic Submersible
When you think of a stock tank heater, this is probably what comes to mind. The submersible de-icer is the workhorse of countless farms for a reason: it’s simple, effective, and relatively inexpensive. You just drop it in the tank, plug it in, and it gets to work.
These units, typically 1000 or 1500 watts, are powerful enough to keep a 100-gallon steel or structural foam tank completely ice-free even in punishingly cold weather. A built-in thermostat kicks the heating element on only when the water temperature drops near freezing, which helps manage electricity costs. The heavy-duty, anti-chew cord cover provides a decent layer of protection against curious animals.
The main tradeoff is that both the heater and the cord are in the tank with the animals. While the cord is tough, a particularly bored horse or goat can still do damage. It’s crucial to position the tank so the cord is as short and protected as possible, and always plug it into a GFCI-protected outlet. For a straightforward solution that works in almost any tank, this is the go-to choice.
Allied Precision Drain Plug De-Icer for Tanks
The drain plug de-icer solves the biggest problem of submersible heaters: animal interference. Instead of dropping a unit in from the top, this clever device screws directly into your tank’s drain hole. The heating element sits inside the tank, while the cord connection is safely on the outside.
This design is a game-changer for safety and durability. With no cord in the water, there’s nothing for livestock to chew on, pull, or get tangled in. It’s a clean, set-it-and-forget-it installation for the entire winter. Because it sits at the bottom of the tank, it heats the water efficiently from the ground up.
The only real limitation is that your tank must have a standard 1-inch drain plug opening, which is common on most metal and structural foam stock tanks but not on all plastic models. Installation requires you to empty the tank once to screw it in, but the peace of mind it provides for the rest of the season is well worth the minimal effort. If you have a compatible tank, this is one of the safest and most reliable options available.
Farm Innovators 5-Gallon Heated Flat-Back Bucket
Sometimes, a massive stock tank is overkill. For animals in individual stalls, for a small flock of chickens, or for isolating a new or sick animal, the heated bucket is an incredibly convenient solution. This isn’t just a heater you put in a bucket; the heating element is built right into the bucket’s molding.
The design is brilliant in its simplicity. The flat-back side lets it hang flush against a wall or fence, preventing tipping. The cord is hidden underneath, offering excellent protection. With a low power draw (around 60 watts), it’s energy-efficient and designed to keep the water just above freezing, not warm it up.
Of course, its 5-gallon capacity is its biggest strength and its biggest weakness. It’s perfect for one or two goats, a horse’s stall, or a chicken coop, but it’s not a solution for a herd. You also need a safe, GFCI-protected outlet within reach of every bucket. For targeted applications, however, its convenience and safety are unmatched.
K&H Thermo-Pond 3.0: A Reliable Floating Unit
Don’t let the name fool you; this floating de-icer is a fantastic tool for livestock troughs, especially plastic ones. Unlike powerful submersible units that can sometimes warp or damage plastic tanks, floating heaters are specifically designed to be safe for all materials. They are also incredibly energy-efficient.
Most floating units operate at a much lower wattage (often just 100 watts) than their submersible cousins. Their goal isn’t to heat the entire tank, but simply to maintain a 12- to 18-inch hole of open water at the surface. That’s all your animals need to get a drink. This low power draw can lead to significant savings on your electric bill over a long winter.
The main consideration is that a floating object can be a toy for a curious animal. While they are rugged, a determined horse might still try to lift it out of the tank. The key is to run the cord through a fence or secure it in a way that doesn’t give the animal leverage to pull on it. For a low-cost, energy-saving option in moderately cold climates, a floater is hard to beat.
The Pirit Heated Hose for Filling Troughs Easily
This isn’t a tank heater, but it solves one of winter’s most universal problems: frozen hoses. A heated hose is one of those tools that seems like an extravagance until you use one. Then you can’t imagine how you ever managed without it. It allows you to use your outdoor spigot to fill troughs all winter long, just like you do in the summer.
The Pirit hose has a self-regulating heating element that runs its entire length, keeping water flowing in sub-zero temperatures. You simply plug it in a few minutes before you need it, and you have a flexible, functional hose. No more hauling dozens of heavy buckets from the house or trying to thaw a rock-solid hose with a heat gun.
This is a complementary tool, not a replacement for a de-icer in the trough. But by automating the filling process, it saves an incredible amount of time and physical labor. The upfront cost is higher than a standard hose, but the daily frustration it eliminates makes it one of the best quality-of-life investments a small farmer can make for winter chores.
Ritchie OmniFount: The Energy-Free Waterer
For those looking for a permanent, ultra-reliable solution, the automatic waterer is the ultimate goal. The Ritchie OmniFount is a classic example of an insulated, ground-heated system that requires little to no electricity. It’s an infrastructure upgrade, not just a piece of seasonal equipment.
These units work by harnessing geothermal energy. The water line is buried deep below the frost line, so the groundwater that enters the fountain is naturally around 40-50°F. The heavily insulated body of the waterer traps that heat, and the constant replenishment of water as animals drink is usually enough to prevent freezing in all but the most extreme arctic conditions. For those climates, a small, optional electric heater can be added for backup.
The tradeoff is obvious: cost and installation. This is not a cheap or simple solution. It requires excavation to bury the water line and a concrete pad for mounting. However, once installed, it provides clean, fresh water on demand, 24/7, with virtually no labor and minimal running costs. For a long-term farm plan, it’s the most resilient and efficient watering system you can own.
Choosing Your Heater: Power, Safety, and Tank Size
With so many options, picking the right one comes down to your specific situation. There is no single "best" heater, only the best one for your farm. Focus on three key factors to make a smart decision.
First, consider power and climate. A 1500-watt submersible heater is necessary for a 150-gallon tank in a Minnesota winter, but it’s expensive overkill for a 50-gallon trough in Tennessee where a 250-watt floating unit would do. Matching the wattage to your tank size and typical low temperatures will save you money and ensure reliable performance.
Second, prioritize safety. Any electrical device near water and animals demands respect.
- GFCI outlets are not optional. They are your primary safety device.
- Protect the cord. If you can’t use a drain plug model, run the cord through a PVC pipe or position the tank to minimize exposure.
- Match heater to tank. Don’t use a high-wattage heater designed for metal tanks in a cheap plastic one, as it can cause damage over time.
Finally, think about your animals and routine. Do you have a known chewer that makes a drain plug de-icer a necessity? Are your animals in separate stalls, making heated buckets the logical choice? Answering these practical questions will guide you to the right solution far better than a simple spec sheet ever could.
Keeping water liquid through the winter is a non-negotiable part of caring for livestock. The right tool for the job not only protects your animals’ health but also preserves your own energy and time. By matching the heater to your climate, tank, and animals, you can turn one of winter’s biggest chores into a problem you no longer have to think about.
