6 Best Static Compost Bins For Goats On a Homestead Budget

You’ve just mucked out the goat stall, and now a mountain of soiled straw and manure sits in your wheelbarrow. This isn’t waste; it’s the beginning of black gold for your garden. But getting it from a messy pile to finished compost requires the right system, especially on a tight homestead budget.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing a Bin for High-Carbon Goat Bedding

Goat bedding isn’t like kitchen scraps. It’s a dense, carbon-heavy mix of straw or wood shavings, packed with nitrogen-rich manure and urine. This unique composition demands a compost system that can handle bulk and promote airflow.

Without enough oxygen, a deep pile of goat bedding will compact into a slimy, stinking, anaerobic mess. The goal of a good bin is to provide structure that prevents this compaction. It needs to be large enough to hold several weeks’ worth of muck-out and strong enough not to bulge under the weight.

Forget the small, tumbling composters designed for vegetable peels. They simply can’t handle the volume or the material. You need a static system—one where the pile sits and breaks down over time—that is sized appropriately and prioritizes aeration above all else.

GEOBIN Compost Bin: Expandable for Herd Growth

The GEOBIN is a simple, effective solution for a growing homestead. It’s essentially a large sheet of perforated plastic that you curl into a circle and secure with keys. Its greatest strength is its flexibility.

You can set it up with a three-foot diameter when you only have a couple of Nigerian Dwarfs. If you add a few more goats next season, you can easily expand it to its maximum diameter of nearly four feet, almost doubling its capacity without buying a new system. This adaptability is invaluable when your future needs are uncertain.

The tradeoff is its lightweight construction. A full, heavy load of wet bedding can cause it to bulge, and a strong wind can potentially move an empty one. For best results, drive a T-post or a sturdy wooden stake through the middle to anchor it securely to the ground.

Redmon Green Culture Bin for Odor Containment

If your compost area is close to your house or a neighbor’s property, an enclosed bin like the Redmon is a smart choice. This sturdy, lidded plastic bin excels at trapping odors and keeping the pile neatly contained. The lid also prevents heavy rains from turning your compost into a soggy swamp.

The solid sides, however, are both a pro and a con. While they contain the contents, they also restrict passive airflow, which is critical for breaking down goat bedding. To succeed with this type of bin, you must be more intentional about layering.

Actively mix in bulky materials like sticks, corn stalks, or un-chopped leaves to create air pockets within the pile. Without this, the dense bedding will compact, and you’ll be fighting an uphill battle against anaerobic decomposition. It’s a great bin, but it requires a bit more management than an open-air design.

DIY Wood Pallet Bin: The Ultimate Budget Option

For the homesteader who values resourcefulness over retail, nothing beats a compost bin made from wood pallets. By sourcing four untreated, heat-stamped (look for the "HT" mark) pallets, you can build a massive, sturdy compost bin for the cost of a few screws or some baling wire. The result is a bin that’s roughly a cubic yard—a perfect size for a small herd of goats.

The slatted design of the pallets provides excellent airflow, which is exactly what dense goat bedding needs to break down aerobically. You can easily create a multi-bay system by adding more pallets, allowing you to have one pile "cooking" while you start filling the next. This is the most cost-effective way to scale your composting operation.

The main considerations are sourcing the right pallets and the system’s permanence. Avoid chemically treated (often marked "MB") or painted pallets. Once built, these bins are heavy and difficult to move, so choose your location wisely. For easier access, consider hinging the front pallet so it can swing open like a gate.

Bosmere Wire Mesh Composter for Maximum Airflow

Sometimes the simplest solution is the best. The Bosmere Wire Composter is little more than a roll of PVC-coated wire mesh with clips to hold it in a circle. Its single greatest advantage is unparalleled airflow, which makes it almost foolproof for high-carbon materials.

This bin is ideal for a passive, "set it and forget it" composting style. You can pile the goat bedding high, and the open mesh ensures oxygen can penetrate from all sides, dramatically reducing the risk of the pile going anaerobic. It’s simple, cheap, and highly effective for the specific challenge of composting mucked-out stalls.

The open design does have its drawbacks. The pile can dry out very quickly in sunny or windy conditions, so you may need to water it occasionally to maintain the necessary moisture. It also offers no protection from rodents and does nothing to contain odors, making it best suited for a more remote corner of your property.

Algreen Soil Saver: A Durable, Long-Lasting Pick

The Algreen Soil Saver is a step up in terms of price and durability. Made from thick, recycled plastic, this bin is built to withstand years of sun, snow, and heavy use. It’s a "buy it once" option for homesteaders who want a permanent, tidy-looking solution.

Its dark color is a functional feature, absorbing solar radiation to heat the pile and speed up decomposition, which is a significant advantage in cooler climates. The locking lid is secure against raccoons and other pests, and the sliding doors at the bottom allow you to harvest finished compost without disturbing the entire pile.

Like other enclosed bins, its weakness is limited passive aeration. To successfully compost bulky goat bedding in a Soil Saver, you must be diligent about layering with coarser materials to create internal air channels. While it’s a fantastic, durable product, it works best for a homesteader who is actively managing their pile.

T-Post & Hardware Cloth Bin for Custom Sizing

If no pre-made bin fits your space or volume needs, a DIY bin made from T-posts and hardware cloth is the perfect answer. This approach gives you complete control over the dimensions. You can build a long, narrow bin along a fence line or a large square system with multiple bays.

The process is straightforward: drive metal T-posts into the ground to create a frame, then wrap the frame with hardware cloth or welded wire fencing, securing it with wire. The open mesh provides the excellent airflow that goat bedding requires, similar to a wire mesh composter but with far greater structural integrity and customizability.

This method requires a bit of upfront labor and the cost of materials, but it often proves cheaper than buying multiple large plastic bins. It’s the ideal solution for building a robust, high-capacity system tailored precisely to your property and the size of your herd.

Key Factors in Sizing Your Goat Compost System

Choosing the right bin is less about the brand and more about the volume. An undersized system is a constant source of frustration, leading to messy overflows and incomplete decomposition. Before you buy or build, map out your needs.

Three key factors determine the right size for your operation:

• Number of Goats: The math is simple. More goats produce more soiled bedding. A system that works for two mini-goats will be overwhelmed by a herd of six full-sized dairy goats.
• Bedding Method: The deep litter method, where bedding accumulates for months, will generate a massive volume all at once. Daily or weekly muck-outs produce a smaller, more consistent flow. Your management style dictates your bin’s minimum capacity.
• Composting Speed: A single pile is the simplest method, but a three-bin system is far more efficient. This setup—one bin for active filling, one for "cooking," and one for curing—requires three times the space but yields a continuous supply of finished compost.

Ultimately, it’s always better to build or buy a system that is slightly too large than one that is too small. For a small herd of two to four goats, a minimum capacity of one cubic yard (about 3’x3’x3′) is a good starting point for a single pile. A three-bin system of that size is a robust setup that will serve a small homestead for years.

Managing goat manure isn’t a chore to be avoided; it’s a vital part of a closed-loop homestead system. By matching the right bin to your herd size, budget, and property, you turn a daily task into a productive investment in your soil’s future. The best system is the one that you’ll actually use, turning waste into a resource that nourishes your garden season after season.