6 Best Pull-Behind Swathers For 5 Acres On a Homestead Budget

Making your own hay on a small homestead is one of the most satisfying steps toward self-sufficiency. But staring out at five acres of tall grass can feel overwhelming without the right equipment. Choosing a pull-behind swather that fits your budget and your land is the critical first step to turning that field into winter feed for your animals.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing a Swather for Your Small-Scale Hay Needs

The term "swather" on a homestead scale often means something different than it does in commercial agriculture. We’re not talking about massive, self-propelled machines. For us, it’s about a reliable mower that can be pulled by an ATV, UTV, or small tractor to cut hay and lay it down neatly for drying. The goal is a clean cut that preserves the nutritional value of the forage.

The three main types you’ll encounter are sickle bar mowers, drum mowers, and flail mowers. Each comes with significant tradeoffs. A sickle bar offers a pristine, scissor-like cut that’s ideal for delicate legumes like alfalfa, but it can be slow and prone to clogging in thick, tangled grass. A drum mower is a brute—fast and nearly impossible to clog—but can be rougher on the hay.

A flail mower is the jack-of-all-trades. It can mow pastures, chew up light brush, and cut hay, making it a versatile one-implement solution for a tight budget. However, it conditions the hay more aggressively by design, which can lead to more leaf shatter and nutrient loss if you’re not careful. Your choice depends entirely on your priorities: cut quality, speed, or versatility.

Kunz AcrEase H800: A Reliable Sickle Bar Mower

If your primary goal is high-quality hay, a sickle bar mower is the traditional gold standard. The Kunz AcrEase H800 is a modern, well-built example that’s designed to be pulled by an ATV. It features its own engine, so your tow vehicle just needs to pull it along. This setup avoids the need for a tractor with a Power Take-Off (PTO).

The key advantage here is the gentle, clean cut. The H800 uses a double-action sickle bar that slices through hay stalks without shredding the leaves, which is crucial for preserving protein in crops like clover and alfalfa. It lays the hay down in a fluffy windrow that allows for excellent air circulation and faster drying times.

The tradeoff is patience. Sickle bars work best at slower speeds and can get gummed up by damp, dense undergrowth or gopher mounds. You have to keep the blades sharp and properly adjusted, and hitting a rock can mean stopping to replace a section. This mower rewards a meticulous operator who values hay quality over raw speed.

I&J Mini Drum Mower for Faster, Clog-Free Cutting

For the homesteader who needs to get the hay down now between rain showers, a drum mower is the answer. The I&J Mini Drum Mower is a compact, ground-driven unit that is simple, tough, and incredibly effective. Instead of a complex cutter bar, it uses two or more large, spinning drums with swinging blades at the bottom.

The genius of the drum mower is its momentum. The heavy drums power through thick, wet, or tangled grass that would instantly clog a sickle bar. There are far fewer moving parts, which translates to less maintenance and greater durability. You can operate at a much higher speed, cutting your mowing time significantly.

This speed comes at a price. The cutting action is more of a blunt chop than a clean slice, which can be harder on the hay and may slow drying slightly. They also require more horsepower to run than a sickle bar of a similar width. But if your fields are rough and your weather windows are tight, the reliability and speed of a drum mower are often worth the compromise in cut finesse.

The Haban Sickle-Pro: A Top Used Market Find

Sometimes the best tool for a homestead budget isn’t a new one. The Haban Sickle-Pro is a legendary pull-behind sickle bar mower that was made for decades and can often be found on the used market for a fraction of the cost of a new machine. These were built to last, with heavy-duty steel and simple, repairable components.

Finding a good Haban requires some searching and a bit of mechanical know-how. Look for units that have been stored indoors and show minimal rust on the cutter bar. Check that the drive belts aren’t cracked and that the pitman arm—the part that drives the blade back and forth—is in good shape. Parts are still available, but you’ll be the one doing the repairs.

This path is perfect for the hands-on homesteader who is willing to trade money for time. A well-maintained Haban can deliver a cut that’s just as good as a new mower. It’s a testament to older, overbuilt engineering and a fantastic way to get into making your own hay without a huge initial investment.

WoodMaxx FM-62H: A Versatile Flail Mower Option

What if you need one machine to mow your pasture, clear overgrown fence lines, and cut hay? This is where a flail mower shines. The WoodMaxx FM-62H is a self-powered pull-behind flail mower that can handle a wide variety of tasks, making it an excellent value for a small farm.

A flail mower uses dozens of small "flail" knives (typically Y-shaped or T-shaped) that spin on a horizontal rotor. For haying, you use a "scoop" or "finish cut" style flail that lifts and cuts the grass. The cutting action chops the material more than a sickle or drum mower, which can speed up drying but also risks shattering valuable leaves. Adjusting the rotor speed and cutting height is key to minimizing this effect.

The real benefit is that this isn’t just a haying tool. After you’re done with your hay, the same machine can be used to top your pastures, preventing weeds from going to seed. It can also mulch up light brush and brambles. If you can only afford one pull-behind implement, a flail mower offers the most bang for your buck across the entire homestead.

AcrEase Pro60V Flail Mower for Multi-Purpose Use

Similar to the WoodMaxx, the Kunz AcrEase Pro60V is another top-tier, self-powered flail mower that brings versatility to the forefront. It’s known for its robust construction and thoughtful design, such as the ability to easily adjust the cutting height. This is critical when switching from pasture topping to hay cutting.

The Pro60V often features a wider range of blade options, allowing you to fine-tune the machine for specific tasks. For haying, you’d opt for smooth-edged finish-cut flails to minimize shredding. For clearing rougher areas, you could switch to heavier-duty blades. This adaptability makes it a powerful tool for managing a diverse 5-acre property.

Like all flail mowers, it’s a compromise for hay making. The cut won’t be as clean as a sickle bar or as fast as a drum mower. But for the homesteader managing varied terrain—from a smooth hayfield to a bumpy back pasture—the ability to handle it all with one machine is a massive advantage in terms of cost, storage space, and maintenance.

DR Pro-44 Field Mower: A Practical Haying Tool

While often marketed as a field and brush mower, the DR Pro-44 pull-behind model is a surprisingly capable haying tool for a few acres. It’s lighter and more maneuverable than some of the dedicated hay mowers, making it a great fit for towing with a larger ATV or small utility vehicle. Its simple, robust design is easy to maintain.

The DR mower uses a single, heavy-duty spinning blade, similar to a very beefy lawn mower. It’s not a precision haying instrument, but it’s incredibly effective at cutting through thick field grass. It lays the grass down in a decent windrow, and its ability to handle uneven ground without complaint is a major plus for typical homestead fields that aren’t perfectly level.

This is an excellent entry-level choice. It bridges the gap between a walk-behind mower and more specialized hay equipment. If you’re just starting to make hay on a portion of your five acres and also need a machine to keep trails clear, the DR offers a practical and affordable solution. It gets the job done without the complexity or cost of more specialized gear.

Key Features for Your Homestead Pull-Behind Swather

When you’re ready to buy, don’t just look at the brand name. Focus on the features that will make or break your haying season on a small scale. The right machine for your neighbor might be the wrong one for you.

First, consider the power source. A self-powered unit with its own engine can be pulled by almost any ATV or UTV. A ground-driven or PTO-driven unit requires a heavier, more powerful tow vehicle. Match the mower to the tractor or ATV you already have. Second, look at the cutting width. A wider cut means fewer passes and less time in the field, but it also requires more power and a higher price tag. For five acres, something in the 44- to 60-inch range is a good sweet spot.

Finally, think about your land and your mechanical aptitude.

• Rough, uneven ground? A drum or flail mower will be more forgiving than a sickle bar.
• Hate maintenance? A drum mower has the fewest moving parts to break.
• Love tinkering? A used sickle bar can be a rewarding, budget-friendly project.

Ultimately, the best swather is the one that aligns with your budget, your land, and your goals. Be honest about your priorities—whether that’s pristine alfalfa for your dairy goats or just getting the grass cut and baled before the next rain.

The right pull-behind swather transforms haying from an intimidating chore into a manageable and rewarding part of your homestead’s rhythm, securing quality feed for your animals and bringing you one step closer to your self-sufficiency goals.