6 Best Artisanal Cheese Presses For Hobby Farmers On a Homestead Budget

You’ve carefully warmed the milk, added the culture, and cut the curds just right. Now comes the moment of truth: pressing. If you’ve been balancing cast iron skillets or encyclopedias on your cheese mold, you know the frustration of an uneven, crumbly wheel. A dedicated cheese press isn’t a luxury; it’s the tool that transforms your hard work from a hobby into a craft.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why a Dedicated Press Improves Your Farmstead Cheese

A good cheese press is about one thing: consistency. Makeshift setups with bricks or jugs of water apply uneven pressure, creating a cheese with a dense side and a crumbly side. This inconsistency traps pockets of whey, leading to a sour taste and poor aging potential.

A dedicated press, whether it’s a simple screw-style or a lever-action design, applies even, sustained force across the entire surface of the follower. This methodical pressure is crucial for knitting the curds together into a uniform mass. It expels just the right amount of whey at the right speed, which is the secret to a firm texture and a smooth, closed rind that protects the cheese as it ages.

Furthermore, a purpose-built press is designed for food safety and easy cleanup. Stainless steel and properly sealed wood won’t harbor bacteria the way a stack of old books might. A stable, dedicated press also eliminates the risk of a wobbly, heavy weight toppling over in your kitchen, which is a real concern when you’re dealing with a gallon or two of precious milk.

TSM Stainless Steel Press: A Durable, Simple Choice

This press is a pure workhorse. It’s a straightforward screw press made entirely of stainless steel, meaning it will likely outlast your cheesemaking career. There are no springs to wear out or wooden parts to maintain.

Its beauty lies in its simplicity. You place your filled mold on the base, put the follower on top, and turn the handle to apply pressure. The all-metal construction makes sanitation a breeze; you can scrub it down without worrying about damaging any components. It’s a fantastic choice if you prioritize durability and hygiene above all else.

The main tradeoff is that you have to develop a "feel" for the pressure you’re applying. Some cheesemakers place a bathroom scale under the press initially to learn what 20, 30, or 50 pounds of pressure feels like. It’s not a "set it and forget it" system, but for the homesteader who values rugged, no-nonsense tools, it’s hard to beat.

NECS Dutch Style Press: Classic Lever-Action Design

The Dutch-style press uses the timeless principle of leverage to achieve consistent pressure. A long wooden arm multiplies the force of a small weight, applying it steadily to your curds. This design is a classic for a reason—it’s effective, reliable, and visually satisfying to use.

One of the biggest advantages is how easy it is to calculate and adjust pressure. The notches on the lever arm correspond to specific pressure multipliers (e.g., a 5-pound weight in the third notch might apply 25 pounds of pressure). This takes the guesswork out of following recipes that call for precise, incremental pressing schedules, which is critical for many aged hard cheeses.

The downside is primarily related to the material and footprint. Being made of wood, it requires more care than a stainless steel model; you’ll need to keep it clean and dry, and occasionally treat it with a food-safe oil to prevent cracking. It also takes up more counter space than a compact screw press, so you’ll need a dedicated spot for it during pressing.

The Ultimate Cheese Press: Versatile and Compact

This small, spring-loaded press is a popular entry point for many new cheesemakers. Its compact frame, often made of food-grade plastic or coated metal, uses calibrated springs to apply pressure. You simply tighten the knobs until the indicator reaches the desired pressure level.

The primary benefit is its user-friendliness and small size. There are no heavy weights to haul around, and the whole unit can be easily stored in a cabinet. This is perhaps the easiest press for a beginner to get consistent results with right away, as the guesswork of pressure is completely removed.

However, its limitations become apparent as you advance. The springs can lose tension over time, requiring recalibration or replacement. Most models are also limited in the amount of pressure they can apply, often maxing out around 50 pounds, which isn’t enough for very hard, dry cheeses like Parmesan. It’s a fantastic tool for cheddars, goudas, and jacks, but might hold you back if your ambitions grow.

Roaring Fork Wooden Press: Traditional Craftsmanship

For the homesteader who appreciates heritage tools, a press from a maker like Roaring Fork is as much a piece of functional art as it is a cheesemaking tool. These are typically screw-style presses crafted from beautiful hardwoods like maple or cherry, built with visible joinery and a food-safe finish. They connect you to the long history of farmstead cheesemaking.

The functional advantage of a well-made wooden press is its heft and stability. The thick, solid wood construction provides a sturdy platform that won’t flex under pressure. The tactile experience of turning a smooth wooden handle to press your own cheese is deeply rewarding and feels right at home in a homestead kitchen.

The commitment here is to maintenance and cost. These presses represent a significant investment and require care to protect the wood from moisture and bacteria. They must be cleaned promptly and oiled periodically. This isn’t a tool for someone who wants to "use it and abuse it," but for the artisan who finds value in caring for high-quality, traditional equipment.

Lehman’s Stainless Press: Built for Heavy Use

Lehman’s caters to the serious homesteader, and their stainless steel press reflects that. It’s often larger, heavier, and more robustly constructed than other screw presses on the market. This is the kind of tool you buy once and pass down to the next generation.

This press is designed for volume and high pressure. If you’re working with milk from a family cow and making large, 4- to 5-pound wheels of cheese destined for a year in the cheese cave, this is the tool for the job. It can easily generate the high pressures needed for styles like Parmesan or Romano without flexing or failing. Its all-stainless build is the gold standard for sanitation.

The only real drawback is that it can be overkill for a beginner or small-batch cheesemaker. Its cost and size are considerable, and its capabilities might go unused if you’re only making small, lightly pressed cheeses. But if you know you’re in this for the long haul and plan to scale up, investing in a press like this from the start can be a wise decision.

Cheese & Yogurt Making Spring Press: Easy for Beginners

This type of press is one of the most budget-friendly and straightforward options available. Typically made of durable plastic, it features a simple frame with springs that you tighten down. It’s small, lightweight, and incredibly easy to understand.

The key advantage is its low barrier to entry. For a very modest investment, you get a tool that provides measurable, consistent pressure without needing any extra weights or scales. The springs are often marked, so a recipe that says "press at 20 pounds" is as simple as tightening the knobs to the "20" mark. It’s a perfect choice for someone who is still deciding if cheesemaking is a long-term passion.

Be aware of the limitations. The all-plastic construction, while easy to clean, is less durable than wood or steel. More importantly, these presses have a very limited pressure range and are only suitable for soft- and medium-hard cheeses. You won’t be making a dry, aged Parmesan with this, but it will turn out a beautiful farmhouse cheddar or colby.

Calibrating Weight and Pressure for Perfect Curds

Understanding pressure is more important than the press itself. Too little pressure leaves you with a wet, acidic cheese. Too much, too soon, seals the outside of the cheese, trapping whey inside and creating a brittle, flawed texture. The goal is a slow, steady removal of whey.

How you measure that pressure depends on your press:

• Lever Press: Use a simple bathroom scale. Place it under the mold (with the press disengaged) to see what your baseline is. Then, engage the press with a weight on the arm and see the new reading. The difference is the pressure being applied.
• Screw Press: This is the trickiest to calibrate. The best method is to place a scale under the mold and tighten the screw until you reach your target weight. Do this a few times, and you’ll develop a muscle memory for how much of a turn equals a certain amount of pressure.
• Spring Press: These are pre-calibrated. Trust the markings, but check them once a year by pressing down on a bathroom scale to ensure the springs haven’t weakened significantly.

Remember that most recipes call for incremental pressing. You might start at 10 pounds for 30 minutes to gently settle the curds, then increase to 30 pounds for an hour, and finish at 50 pounds for 12 hours. Following this schedule is what develops the proper texture and rind, so learning to measure your pressure accurately is a skill that pays dividends in every wheel of cheese you make.

Ultimately, the best cheese press is the one that matches your goals and your budget. Whether it’s a simple spring press for occasional cheesemaking or a robust stainless steel model for a family milk cow, moving to a dedicated press is an investment in consistency. It’s the step that takes your cheese from a rustic experiment to a reliable, delicious staple of your homestead pantry.