7 Best Vermeer 504 Small Square Balers For Reducing Waste That Just Work

There’s nothing more frustrating than looking back at a freshly baled field and seeing a trail of broken, busted bales. That’s not just wasted hay; it’s wasted time, fuel, and twine. For those of us working on a smaller scale, every bit of that waste cuts deep. This is where a reliable small square baler isn’t a luxury—it’s the core of a successful haying operation, and the Vermeer 504 series has long been a go-to for farmers who just need something that works.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Vermeer 504N: For Clean, Wide Pickups

The first thing you’ll notice about the 504N is its wide pickup. This isn’t just about grabbing more hay at once; it’s about minimizing leaf shatter and loss, especially in delicate crops like alfalfa or clover. A wider pickup means you don’t have to weave back and forth to catch the edges of a windrow, resulting in a cleaner field and more nutrients packed into every bale.

Think about those tight turns at the end of an irregularly shaped field. A standard-width pickup often leaves a wad of hay behind, forcing you to rake it by hand or make another pass. The 504N’s design helps gather that hay on the first go. This directly reduces the waste of leaving valuable forage in the field.

The trade-off, of course, is maneuverability. While not a massive machine, the wider head requires a bit more care when navigating narrow gates or storing it in a packed shed. But if your primary goal is getting every last bit of hay off the ground efficiently, the clean sweep of the 504N is hard to beat. It saves you follow-up work and puts more of your hard-grown crop in the barn.

Vermeer 504M: Hydraulic Density Control

Adjusting bale density on older balers often involves stopping, getting out the wrenches, and cranking down on tension springs. The 504M changes that with hydraulic density control, and it’s a bigger deal than it sounds. It lets you change bale weight and tightness on the fly, right from the tractor seat.

Imagine you’re baling in the late afternoon as the humidity starts to rise. The hay gets a little tougher, and you need to back off the tension to avoid making "bricks" that might mold. With the 504M, it’s a simple lever adjustment. The next day, you’re baling dry, fluffy straw and want dense, stackable bales. Just add more pressure.

This feature is a powerful tool for reducing waste. Inconsistent bales don’t stack well, leading to collapsed stacks and spoilage from exposure to the elements. Bales that are too loose fall apart during handling. By allowing you to create consistently perfect bales for your specific crop conditions, the 504M ensures more of your hay remains usable. It’s about adapting to the reality of the day, not forcing one setting to work for everything.

Vermeer 504K: The Reliable TwinePro Knotter

The knotter is the heart of a square baler, and it’s also the number one source of headaches. The 504K’s main claim to fame is the TwinePro knotter system, which was a significant step forward in reliability. It ties a loop knot that provides incredible strength while putting less stress on the twine itself.

What does this mean for you in the field? Fewer missed ties. Fewer broken knots. You spend your time driving forward, not walking back to re-tie a busted bale by hand. This system is also less finicky about twine quality and condition, giving you more flexibility.

This isn’t just about convenience; it’s a direct assault on waste. Every failed knot creates a loose pile of hay that has to be dealt with—either gathered for re-baling or left to rot. The confidence that comes from a reliable knotter is immense. It lets you push your baling window a little later in the day, knowing you won’t be stuck in the field fixing problems as the dew falls.

Vermeer 504C: Compact Frame for Tight Fields

Not all of us have wide-open, 40-acre rectangles to hay. Many hobby farms are carved out of old homesteads with tight gates, mature trees, and winding lanes. The Vermeer 504C, with its more compact design, is built for exactly these situations.

Its narrower footprint makes it significantly easier to navigate challenging terrain. If you’re haying an old apple orchard or a small pasture tucked behind the barn, the 504C can get in and out without the stress of potentially clipping a fence post or a valuable tree. It’s about fitting the machine to your property, not the other way around.

The compromise is usually a slightly narrower pickup and perhaps a bit less overall capacity than its larger siblings. But this is a smart trade-off. Forcing a large baler into a small space is a recipe for damaged equipment and property. The 504C minimizes this risk, ensuring you can actually harvest those hard-to-reach patches of forage that might otherwise go to waste.

Vermeer 504R: Rugged Build for Heavy Crops

The "R" in the 504R stands for "rugged," and it earns the name. This model is designed for farmers who are consistently dealing with heavy, dense crops. Think first-cutting alfalfa with thick stems or baling damp, heavy rye straw for bedding.

Where a lighter-duty baler might struggle or even break under the strain, the 504R is built with heavier components in key areas like the plunger and bale case. This robust construction ensures it can form tight, consistent bales without faltering, even when the conditions are tough. It prevents the kind of long-term wear and tear that leads to catastrophic—and expensive—failures mid-season.

This is a different kind of waste reduction. It’s not just about saving hay in the field; it’s about saving yourself from the wasted time and money of major repairs. If you know your crops are demanding, investing in a machine built to handle them is the smartest move you can make. The 504R is for those who would rather overbuild than risk a breakdown during a critical weather window.

Vermeer 504I: Legacy Model for Simple Repairs

Sometimes, the best technology is the simplest. The 504I represents an older generation of Vermeer balers, but its enduring popularity comes from one key feature: simplicity. With fewer hydraulic lines and no complex electronics, nearly every part of this baler is accessible with a standard set of tools.

For the hobby farmer who does their own maintenance, this is a massive advantage. When something goes wrong—and on any piece of farm equipment, it will—you can often diagnose and fix it yourself with a service manual and an afternoon. There’s no waiting for a dealer technician or a proprietary electronic part.

This approach combats the waste of both time and money. Being down for a week waiting for a service call can mean losing an entire cutting of hay to rain. The 504I puts the power back in your hands. While it lacks the fancy features of newer models, its straightforward, mechanical nature makes it a reliable workhorse that won’t leave you stranded.

Vermeer 504X: The High-Capacity Option

If you have a bit more ground to cover and the weather forecast is looking grim, speed is everything. The 504X is Vermeer’s answer for the operator who needs higher capacity to get the job done fast. It’s designed to process more hay per hour than its smaller counterparts.

This is achieved through a combination of features, often including a faster plunger speed and a more aggressive feeding system. It allows you to maintain a higher ground speed without choking the baler or creating poorly formed bales. When you have 15 acres down and thunderstorms are predicted for the evening, that extra productivity is invaluable.

The primary way the 504X reduces waste is by protecting your crop from the weather. Hay left in the field during a rainstorm loses nutritional value and can begin to mold. By enabling you to bale your entire crop in a shorter window, the 504X acts as an insurance policy against weather-related losses. It’s for the operator whose biggest risk isn’t a missed knot, but a missed opportunity.

Comparing 504 Knotter Systems for Reliability

At the end of the day, a baler is only as good as its knotter. Across the 504 series, you’ll generally find two main types of systems: the modern TwinePro knotter (on models like the 504K) and the classic, time-tested double-knot systems found on older models like the 504I.

The TwinePro is like a modern fuel-injected engine. It’s more efficient, more forgiving of different twine types, and generally requires less fiddling to run smoothly. The loop knot it creates is exceptionally strong. For someone who dreads knotter issues and wants maximum uptime, this is the system to get. It minimizes bale breakage and the associated waste.

The older double-knot systems are like a well-tuned carburetor. They are mechanically simple and, when properly adjusted and maintained, are incredibly reliable. However, they can be more sensitive to changes in twine, humidity, and hay conditions. If you’re mechanically inclined and don’t mind learning the art of knotter adjustment, these systems are fantastic and can be kept running for decades.

Your choice comes down to a trade-off:

• TwinePro: Higher initial cost, less adjustment, "just works" reliability.
• Double-Knot: Lower initial cost, requires more user knowledge, but is simple to repair.

Both are excellent at preventing waste when running correctly. The decision hinges on whether you prefer to invest money for modern convenience or invest time to master a classic, mechanical system.

Ultimately, the "best" Vermeer 504 isn’t a specific letter, but the model that aligns with your land, your crops, and your personal approach to farming. Whether you need the clean pickup of the N, the simple serviceability of the I, or the modern reliability of the K’s TwinePro knotter, there’s a 504 that fits. More important than any single feature, however, is the condition of the machine in front of you—a well-cared-for older model will always serve you better than a newer, neglected one.