6 Best Dehydrator Replacement Trays

That mountain of zucchini on your counter isn’t just a sign of a successful garden; it’s a pile of future chicken treats waiting to happen. Your Excalibur dehydrator is a workhorse for preserving the harvest, but the standard trays aren’t always perfect for every job. Choosing the right replacement or supplemental trays can turn your dehydrator from a good tool into an essential part of your flock-feeding strategy, saving you money and reducing waste.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Dehydrate Treats for Your Backyard Flock?

Preserving your garden’s abundance is the most obvious reason to dehydrate. That glut of summer squash or the bucket of windfall apples can be transformed into nutrient-dense, shelf-stable snacks that your flock will devour in the dead of winter. Dehydration concentrates flavors and nutrients, making a small handful of dried greens or fruit a powerful supplement.

Beyond preserving the harvest, dehydrating is a fantastic way to manage kitchen scraps. Instead of tossing carrot peels, beet tops, or slightly wilted herbs, you can dry them into a "flock confetti" to sprinkle over their feed. This closes a loop on your homestead, turning potential waste into valuable nutrition. You control the ingredients, ensuring your birds get wholesome treats free from the preservatives and mystery additives found in many commercial products.

Kispog Stainless Steel Trays: Built to Last

If you’ve ever had a plastic tray crack after a few years of heavy use, you understand the appeal of stainless steel. These Kispog trays are a "buy it once" upgrade for your Excalibur. They won’t warp from heat, absorb odors from pungent herbs, or become brittle over time.

Think of them as a long-term investment. While the upfront cost is higher than the standard poly-screen, their durability means you won’t be buying replacements down the line. Cleaning is also remarkably straightforward; tough, stuck-on bits of dried fruit can be scrubbed off with a steel pad without fear of scratching or damage. For dehydrating anything from sliced sweet potatoes to whole herbs, stainless steel offers unmatched longevity and peace of mind.

Brightkitchen Silicone Sheets for Messy Treats

Standard mesh trays are great for airflow, but they’re useless for anything wet. This is where silicone sheets, like these from Brightkitchen, become indispensable. They transform your mesh trays into solid surfaces, perfect for making fruit leather from overripe berries or drying blended vegetable scraps.

Imagine you have a bunch of tomato ends and slightly soft peppers. You can blend them into a slurry, spread it on these sheets, and dehydrate it into a brittle "vegetable jerky" for your chickens. The non-stick surface means the finished product peels right off, and cleanup is as simple as a quick wash in the sink. The main tradeoff is slightly reduced airflow, which can extend drying times, but for containing messy treats, they are a must-have accessory.

Excalibur Poly-Screen Trays: The Reliable OEM

Sometimes, the original is exactly what you need. The official Excalibur poly-screen trays are the standard for a reason: they are designed specifically for the machine, ensuring optimal fit and maximum airflow. If you’re primarily dehydrating items that don’t drip, like herbs, leafy greens, or sliced vegetables, these trays perform flawlessly.

Their biggest advantage is their open mesh design, which allows for fast, even drying. They are lightweight, easy to handle, and relatively inexpensive to replace if one gets damaged. However, they are plastic. Over time, they can stain and become brittle, especially with frequent washing and exposure to UV light. For a predictable, no-fuss experience, sticking with the OEM trays is a solid, reliable choice.

ParaFlexx Ultra Sheets: Premium Non-Stick Option

ParaFlexx sheets are Excalibur’s own answer to non-stick liners, and they represent a premium alternative to third-party silicone mats. They are thinner and more flexible than many silicone options, which some users find allows for slightly better heat circulation. These are the go-to for anyone serious about making fruit leathers or drying sticky items like marinated jerky (for you, not the chickens!).

The primary benefit is their superior non-stick quality and durability, designed to withstand years of use. They are perfect for turning leftover applesauce or pumpkin puree into healthy, rollable treats for your flock. The main consideration is cost. ParaFlexx sheets are an investment, but if you frequently dehydrate wet or sticky foods and demand the best performance, they are worth the price.

SENTERN Stainless Steel Racks: Easy Cleaning

Similar to the Kispog trays, the SENTERN stainless steel racks offer a robust and permanent solution to cracked plastic. Where they shine is in their simple, clean design. The grid pattern is often wider than a fine mesh, which makes them exceptionally easy to scrub clean. There are fewer tiny crevices for food particles to get trapped in.

These racks are ideal for larger items where maximum airflow is key but a fine mesh isn’t necessary. Think half-inch thick zucchini rounds, whole chili peppers, or large chunks of pumpkin. They provide the same core benefits as other steel trays—durability, no odor absorption, and heat resistance—but with a focus on hassle-free cleanup. If you’re tired of picking bits of dried food out of a fine plastic mesh, these are a welcome upgrade.

Homdox Silicone Liners: The Budget-Friendly Pick

You don’t have to spend a lot to get the benefits of a non-stick surface. Homdox silicone liners offer a functional and affordable way to handle messy dehydrating projects. They do the same job as their premium counterparts: they contain wet ingredients and make cleanup a breeze.

Are they as thick or as durable as more expensive brands? Maybe not, but for the hobby farmer on a budget, they are a fantastic value. Use them to dry out leftover oatmeal mixed with seeds, spread thin layers of yogurt, or dehydrate blended kale and carrot tops. For occasional use or for someone just starting to experiment with wetter treats, these budget-friendly liners provide immense utility without a hefty price tag.

Choosing Trays for Herbs, Scraps, and Treats

The best setup isn’t about finding one perfect tray, but about building a versatile system. Most flock owners will benefit from a combination of tray types to handle the diverse range of treats you can make. The key is to match the tray to the task at hand.

Here’s a simple framework for making a decision:

• For dry, non-sticky items (herbs, greens, sliced veggies): The standard Excalibur Poly-Screen trays or a full set of Kispog/SENTERN Stainless Steel trays are your best bet. They maximize airflow for the fastest drying times.
• For wet or pureed items (fruit leathers, blended scraps): You absolutely need solid liners. The Brightkitchen or Homdox Silicone Sheets are excellent, affordable options. For the best performance and durability, the ParaFlexx Ultra Sheets are the premium choice.
• For a balanced, all-purpose setup: Start with your existing poly-screen trays. Add two or three stainless steel trays for durability and two or three silicone liners for messy jobs. This mix-and-match approach gives you the flexibility to handle anything from delicate mint leaves to a puree of overripe plums without breaking the budget.

Ultimately, your choice depends on what you dehydrate most often. If your primary goal is drying herbs from the garden, stick with mesh. If you’re constantly turning kitchen scraps into flock treats, investing in a few good liners and durable steel trays will make the entire process more efficient and enjoyable.

Your dehydrator is a powerful tool for creating a healthier, more sustainable feeding program for your flock. By equipping it with the right trays for the job, you can unlock its full potential. You’ll reduce waste, save money on commercial treats, and provide your birds with the very best from your own garden and kitchen.