6 Best Rubber Barn Mats For Small Farms That Old Farmers Swear By

You can tell a lot about a farm by how it handles mud and manure. After years of mucking out stalls with uneven dirt floors that turn to soup in the spring, you realize some problems can’t be solved with a shovel alone. Investing in good rubber barn mats feels like a huge expense at first, but the old-timers know it’s one of the smartest long-term decisions you can make for your animals and your back.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Old-Timers Invest in Quality Rubber Matting

Talk to any farmer who’s been at it for a few decades, and they’ll tell you that stall mats aren’t a luxury; they’re infrastructure. The initial cost is quickly offset by savings in bedding. A matted stall requires significantly less straw or shavings to stay dry and comfortable, which means you’re buying, storing, and hauling out less material every single week.

The real return on investment, however, is in animal health. A quality rubber mat provides a layer of insulation from the cold, damp ground of a concrete or packed-earth floor. This is crucial for older animals with stiff joints and for young livestock that are more susceptible to chills. The forgiving surface also reduces strain on legs and tendons, and a good non-slip texture can prevent costly injuries.

From a pure labor standpoint, mats are a game-changer. They create a perfectly flat, non-porous surface that is incredibly easy to scrape or sweep clean. You’re no longer fighting ruts and holes that your animals have dug, which means mucking out is faster and more efficient. This saves you precious time and energy—two resources that are always in short supply on a small farm.

TSC’s 4×6 ft. Rubber Stall Mat: The Workhorse

If there’s a standard, no-frills option in the barn mat world, this is it. The 4×6 foot, 3/4-inch thick black rubber mat from Tractor Supply Co. is the definition of a workhorse. It’s heavy, dense, and built to withstand years of abuse from hooves, equipment, and whatever else you can throw at it.

The main appeal is its straightforward value and availability. You can walk into almost any farm store and load a few into your truck. They are made from vulcanized rubber, which means they are extremely durable and won’t curl or crack easily under temperature changes. For a basic, permanent stall floor, they get the job done without any fancy features.

The biggest drawback is the sheer weight, often close to 100 pounds per mat. Installing them is a two-person job, and cutting them to size requires a sharp utility knife, a straight edge, and a lot of patience. Because they are straight-edged, the seams can shift over time, allowing urine and debris to work its way underneath, which can become a real problem if not installed tightly.

Humane Loktuff Mats: Premium Interlocking Design

The interlocking mat is the logical evolution of the basic flat-edged mat. Humane’s Loktuff mats are a prime example of this design, featuring puzzle-piece-like tabs along the edges. This simple feature solves the biggest problem with standard mats: seam separation.

Once locked together, these mats form a stable, virtually seamless floor. This prevents them from shifting apart, which in turn stops bedding and manure from getting trapped in the cracks and urine from seeping underneath. The result is a cleaner, drier, and more hygienic stall floor that is far easier to maintain in the long run. You’ll spend less time pulling up mats to clean underneath them.

The tradeoff for this superior design is cost and installation complexity. Interlocking mats are more expensive per square foot than their straight-edged counterparts. You also have to plan your layout more carefully, ensuring you have the right combination of center, border, and corner pieces. Cutting them to fit an irregularly shaped space requires more precision.

RB Rubber Stall Mats: Top Recycled Rubber Choice

When you want uncompromising durability, mats made from 100% recycled vulcanized rubber are the answer. RB Rubber is a leader in this category, producing incredibly dense and heavy mats that are non-porous. This is a key feature that many cheaper mats lack.

A non-porous surface means the mat won’t absorb moisture or urine. This dramatically reduces the potential for bacteria growth and odor, contributing to better air quality in the barn and healthier animals. The vulcanization process also makes them resistant to tearing, cracking, or curling, ensuring they lie flat and stay put for years.

Like other high-density mats, they are heavy and can be difficult to handle. However, their weight is also an advantage, as it helps keep them in place even without an interlocking system. They provide excellent shock absorption and are tough enough to handle shod horses or even light vehicle traffic in a workshop area.

Greatmats Straight Edge Mat: Best for Portability

Not every mat needs to be a permanent, 100-pound fixture. Greatmats offers a range of lighter-weight options that are perfect for situations where portability is key. These mats are often thinner (e.g., 1/2-inch instead of 3/4-inch) and easier for a single person to lift and move.

Think about temporary uses: a mat for the farrier to work on, a floor for a temporary pen, or a removable surface for a wash bay that you want to deep-clean regularly. Their lower weight makes them ideal for these flexible applications. They provide a clean, cushioned surface without the commitment of a permanent installation.

The compromise here is durability and stability. A lighter mat is more likely to shift or bunch up under a heavy, active animal. They may not offer the same level of insulation or joint support as a thicker, denser mat. They are a fantastic tool for specific jobs but might not be the best choice for a permanent stall for a large animal.

Equi-Mat Stall Flooring: Superior Cushion for Joints

Standard rubber mats are hard. Equi-Mat and similar products address this by focusing on cushion and ergonomic support. These systems are often engineered with a slightly softer composite or a multi-layered design to provide more "give" underfoot.

This added cushion is a massive benefit for performance horses, aging animals with arthritis, or any livestock recovering from a leg injury. The shock-absorbing surface reduces stress on joints, ligaments, and tendons, promoting comfort and soundness. For foaling stalls, the softer surface provides a safer landing for a newborn.

This specialized flooring comes at a premium price. The softer material may also be more susceptible to damage from sharp hooves, pawing, or studs on horseshoes. It’s an investment in therapeutic-level comfort, making it an excellent choice where animal joint health is the absolute top priority.

Horsemen’s Pride Stall Mat: Excellent Non-Slip Grip

While all rubber mats offer more traction than bare concrete, some are specifically designed for maximum grip. Horsemen’s Pride mats often feature an aggressive texture, like a raised button or "pebble top" surface, that provides excellent footing even when wet.

This feature is a critical safety consideration in high-moisture areas. In a wash stall, grooming bay, or veterinary area, a non-slip surface can prevent a catastrophic fall. It’s also invaluable for animals that are unsteady on their feet, whether due to age, injury, or inexperience. The confidence a secure footing provides can significantly reduce animal stress.

The only minor downside to a heavily textured surface is that it can be slightly more difficult to sweep perfectly clean. Fine dust and shavings can get caught in the texture, requiring a stiff brush or a good hosing down. It’s a small price to pay for the significant increase in safety.

Key Factors: Mat Thickness, Texture, and Seams

When you’re comparing mats, three things matter most: thickness, texture, and how the seams are handled. For thickness, 3/4-inch is the gold standard for large livestock. It provides the necessary durability and support to withstand hundreds of pounds of pressure day after day. A 1/2-inch mat might be fine for goats, sheep, or a workshop floor, but it won’t hold up as well in a horse stall.

Texture serves two purposes: grip on top and drainage on the bottom. The top surface should have some texture—like a pebble or diamond plate finish—to prevent slipping. The underside often has grooves or channels designed to allow moisture to drain away if it ever gets underneath. A flat bottom can trap moisture against the floor, leading to mold and rot.

Finally, consider the seams. Straight-edge mats are simple and affordable but risk shifting. You have to pack them in wall-to-wall very tightly to minimize this. Interlocking mats are the superior solution for creating a stable, unified floor that keeps waste on the surface where it belongs. Your choice comes down to balancing your budget against your tolerance for long-term maintenance.

Ultimately, the best rubber mat is the one that fits your specific needs and budget. Don’t just look at the price tag; think about the time you’ll save on mucking, the money you’ll save on bedding, and the peace of mind that comes from knowing your animals are safe and comfortable. A good set of mats is an investment that pays you back every single day.