6 Best Cold Smoke Generators For Cheese That Ensure Consistent Smoke

You’ve spent weeks, maybe months, carefully aging a beautiful wheel of cheddar or gouda. The texture is perfect, the flavor is sharp, and now you want to add that final, magical touch: a deep, smoky finish. But a few hours later, you pull it out of the smoker, and it’s covered in a bitter, sooty film. The secret to avoiding that disaster isn’t just making smoke; it’s making the right kind of smoke, consistently, for hours on end.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Consistent Smoke is Key for Perfect Cheese

Inconsistent smoke is the fastest way to ruin good cheese. When a fire smolders poorly, sputtering and flaring up, it produces creosote. That’s the bitter, acrid compound that leaves a greasy black film and a flavor you can’t wash off.

The goal is a thin, continuous stream of clean, bluish smoke. This "sweet smoke" gently deposits flavor without overwhelming the cheese’s delicate character. It should kiss the surface, not assault it. You want to build layers of flavor slowly, allowing the smoke to penetrate just enough to create a beautiful mahogany rind and a balanced taste.

This is where a dedicated cold smoke generator becomes essential. It’s a tool designed for one job: producing a steady, low-temperature smolder for hours without intervention. It removes the guesswork and inconsistency of trying to manage a pan of smoldering chips in a grill, ensuring your cheese gets the gentle, even treatment it deserves.

A-MAZE-N Pellet Smoker: Simple, Reliable Maze

The A-MAZE-N Pellet Smoker is the workhorse of the cold smoking world. It’s a simple, stainless steel tray bent into a maze pattern. There are no wires, no moving parts, and it works in almost any enclosed space, from a dedicated smokehouse to a simple kettle grill.

You fill the channels with hardwood pellets, light one end with a small torch, and let it smolder. The flame extinguishes, and the pellets burn like a slow-fuse, producing a steady stream of smoke for up to 10-12 hours, depending on the model. Its beauty is in its simplicity. As long as the pellets are dry and it has a little airflow, it just works.

The main tradeoff is its manual nature. You have to light it properly, and in very damp conditions, it can sometimes struggle to stay lit without adequate ventilation. However, for its low cost and rock-solid reliability, the A-MAZE-N is often the first and last cold smoke generator many people ever need to buy. It’s the perfect starting point for anyone serious about smoking cheese.

ProQ Cold Smoke Generator for Fine Sawdust

Think of the ProQ as the more refined cousin to the pellet maze. This generator, typically a spiral or square of fine metal mesh, is designed specifically to burn fine wood dust, not pellets. This seemingly small difference has a significant impact on the smoke it produces.

Because the fuel particles are so small, wood dust smolders even more slowly and at a lower temperature than pellets. The result is an exceptionally light and delicate smoke. This is ideal for softer, milder cheeses like fresh mozzarella, brie, or goat cheese, where a heavy pellet smoke could easily be overpowering. The ProQ gives you a level of nuance that’s hard to achieve with other methods.

The catch is that it’s more finicky. The sawdust must be bone dry, or it simply won’t stay lit. It’s also more sensitive to drafts. But for the cheesemaker who wants ultimate control over a subtle, aromatic smoke profile, the ProQ is an outstanding tool that rewards careful use with superior results.

Smoke Daddy Big Kahuna: High-Volume Smoking

When you move from smoking a few blocks of cheese to doing entire racks at once, you need more smoke than a simple maze can provide. The Smoke Daddy Big Kahuna is an external smoke generator that meets this demand. It’s a metal canister that you fill with wood chips or pellets, paired with an adjustable air pump.

The pump pushes air through the canister, stoking the embers and forcing a large volume of smoke through a pipe into your smokehouse or grill. The key advantage here is active control. You can use the pump’s dial to increase or decrease the smoke output on the fly, tailoring it to the size of your chamber and the amount of food inside. This makes it incredibly versatile for smoking everything from a single wheel of provolone to a whole batch of cheddar.

This is a more involved piece of equipment. It requires an electrical outlet for the pump and a bit of setup to mount it to your smoker. It also produces a much denser smoke, so you run a higher risk of over-smoking if you’re not careful. But for the serious hobbyist who needs consistent, high-volume smoke for large batches, the Big Kahuna offers unparalleled power and control.

Smokehouse Smoke Chief: Automated Smoke Flow

The Smoke Chief takes the external generator concept and adds a layer of automation. Instead of just an air pump, it uses an internal heating element and an auger system to deliver a constant, hands-off supply of smoke. You fill the hopper with pellets, plug it in, and turn it on. That’s it.

The unit automatically feeds pellets onto the heating element, ignites them, and pipes the cool smoke into your chamber. It can run for hours with zero tending, making it perfect for long, low-and-slow smoking sessions. If you want to smoke cheese overnight or while you’re out doing other chores, this is the tool for the job. The consistency is exceptional because it’s managed by a machine, not a passive smolder.

The downside is its complexity and reliance on electricity. More moving parts mean more potential points of failure, and you’re out of luck during a power outage. It’s a trade of simplicity for convenience. For those who value a "set it and forget it" process and want perfectly repeatable results every time, the Smoke Chief is a fantastic, automated solution.

Masterbuilt Cold Smoker Kit for Electric Units

Many people get their start with a Masterbuilt electric smoker, a fantastic tool for hot smoking ribs or brisket. The Masterbuilt Cold Smoker Kit is a clever accessory that transforms that same unit into a true cold smoking machine. It’s not a standalone generator but an add-on for a specific ecosystem.

The kit is an external metal box that attaches to the side of the smoker. It has its own low-wattage heating element designed only to smolder wood chips, not to generate cooking heat. It pipes this smoke into the main chamber, allowing you to fill it with cheese while the primary heating element in the smoker stays completely off. This keeps the internal temperature safely in the cold-smoking zone (below 90°F / 32°C).

If you already own a compatible Masterbuilt smoker, this is an incredibly efficient and cost-effective choice. It integrates perfectly with your existing gear. However, it is a proprietary solution; it won’t work with other brands. It’s a prime example of how choosing the right accessory can double the utility of a tool you already have.

Bradley Cold Smoke Adapter for Your Smoker

Similar to the Masterbuilt kit, the Bradley Cold Smoke Adapter is a proprietary solution for users of Bradley smokers. Bradley systems are famous for their automated "bisquette" feeding technology, which provides a very clean and consistent smoke. This adapter lets you leverage that system for cold smoking.

The adapter is a simple but brilliant device: a flexible metal duct that connects the smoker’s smoke generator to the cooking cabinet. This extra length—about four feet—gives the smoke time to cool down significantly before it ever reaches the cheese. The smoke generator works as it always does, but the heat dissipates along the duct, creating a true cold smoke environment inside the cabinet.

The biggest pro is the seamless integration if you’re already a Bradley owner. The bisquettes are incredibly consistent, though you are locked into buying their specific fuel. For those invested in the Bradley system, this adapter is the most direct and reliable path to perfect cold-smoked cheese.

Choosing Your Fuel: Pellets, Dust, or Chips

The generator is only half the equation; the fuel you burn is just as critical. The form of the wood—pellet, dust, or chip—determines how it burns and the character of the smoke it produces. Your choice of generator will often lock you into a specific fuel type.

Here’s the breakdown of what to consider:

• Pellets: The all-around champion for consistency and ease of use. They are compressed, uniform, and smolder predictably for hours in maze-style smokers (A-MAZE-N) or feed reliably in automated units (Smoke Chief, Smoke Daddy). They produce a good, balanced smoke suitable for most cheeses.
• Dust: The choice for connoisseurs seeking subtlety. Used in generators like the ProQ, fine sawdust burns cooler and slower than anything else, creating a delicate smoke that won’t overwhelm mild cheeses. Its main drawback is its sensitivity to moisture.
• Chips: Best suited for external, powered generators like the Masterbuilt kit. Wood chips ignite easily and produce a lot of smoke quickly, but they also burn out fast. They work best in systems that can automatically feed a fresh supply to maintain a consistent flow.

Ultimately, the fuel choice is tied to your generator and your goal. For robust flavor and simplicity, pellets are king. For delicate, artisanal results, dust is unmatched. For automated, high-output systems, chips are a reliable option. Always use fuel designed for smoking, as lumberyard scraps can contain binders or chemicals you don’t want on your food.

Choosing the right cold smoke generator comes down to your scale, your budget, and how hands-on you want to be. Whether it’s a simple maze you light with a torch or an automated unit you can set and forget, the goal is the same: a gentle, consistent wisp of clean smoke. Get that right, and you’ll be pulling perfectly golden, deeply flavorful smoked cheese out of your smoker every single time.