6 Best Hog Manure Scrapers For 5 Acres Old Farmers Swear By

There’s a moment every hog owner knows. It’s that feeling when you look at a pen, see the muck has built up more than you’d like, and realize the difference between a quick 15-minute scrape-down and an hour of back-breaking labor comes down to the tool in your hand. Choosing the right manure scraper isn’t about spending the most money; it’s about matching the tool to the job, the floor, and your own body. A good scraper saves your back, saves you time, and keeps your animals healthier on clean, dry ground.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Little Giant DuraFork: Top Pick for Durability

Don’t let the "fork" in the name fool you; for pens with deep bedding, this is often the best first-pass tool you can own. The tines are made from a tough polycarbonate that has just enough flex to flick away soiled straw without snapping in the cold. It’s incredibly resilient. You can run it over with a tractor tire, and it will likely survive.

The real advantage is how it separates material. Instead of pushing a solid, heavy wall of wet manure and bedding, the DuraFork lets you lift and sift. This allows you to remove the worst of the solids while leaving the drier, usable bedding behind, saving you material and money. It’s not a scraper in the traditional sense. It will not work on packed clay or bare concrete. But for managing deep litter systems, it’s an absolute game-changer that does the job of a scraper and a bedding fork in one motion.

Behlen Country 36-Inch Scraper for Maximum Reach

When you have a long alley or a large finishing pen to clear, width is your best friend. The Behlen 36-inch scraper is all about efficiency. Every pass you make covers a significant amount of ground, drastically cutting down the number of trips you have to take from one end of the barn to the other. This is pure physics—less walking, less time, less fatigue.

This scraper is a heavy, all-steel unit, and that weight is a feature, not a bug. It means you don’t have to put as much downward pressure on the handle to get the blade to bite into moderately packed manure. The tool does the work for you. The trade-off, of course, is maneuverability. Trying to use a 36-inch blade to clean out a tight farrowing crate or a small corner is an exercise in frustration. This is the right tool for open spaces, not tight quarters.

Miller Mfg Tuf-E-Nuf Poly Blade for Wood Floors

Scraping a wood floor presents a unique challenge. A steel blade, especially one with a nicked or worn edge, will inevitably gouge and splinter the wood over time. Those little imperfections become perfect pockets for bacteria to hide and thrive, and a splintered floor is a hoof injury waiting to happen. This is where a poly blade scraper shines.

The Tuf-E-Nuf’s plastic blade is rigid enough to move manure effectively but soft enough that it won’t damage your wooden surfaces. It’s also significantly lighter than its steel counterparts, making it a pleasure to use for daily cleanings. Be realistic about its limits, though. It lacks the heft and sharp edge to tackle manure that’s frozen solid to the floor or compacted into a hard, dry layer. For routine maintenance on wood, it’s ideal; for heavy-duty cleanup, you’ll need to reach for something else.

Erie Tools Heavy-Duty Scraper for Packed Manure

There are clean-outs, and then there are clean-outs. When you’re facing manure that has been compacted by hoof traffic for weeks or is frozen solid to a concrete pad, a lightweight scraper won’t even make a dent. You need a tool built for brute force, and the Erie Tools Heavy-Duty Scraper is exactly that.

This is less of a scraper and more of a demolition tool. It typically features a thick, welded steel blade, a reinforced neck where the handle meets the head, and enough weight to feel like a weapon. The blade is often angled more aggressively, allowing you to get underneath packed material and pry it up. Using it is a workout, no question. But when you need to break up what feels like a solid sheet of ice and muck, this is the only type of tool that will get the job done. It’s not for everyday use, but it’s indispensable when you need it.

Bully Tools 92630 Barn Scraper for All-Day Use

Some tools are specialists, and some are reliable workhorses. The Bully Tools scraper falls squarely into the workhorse category. It’s designed for the person who has to use it every single day and can’t afford to be worn out by their equipment. The magic is in its balance and thoughtful construction.

It often features a fiberglass handle, which is a huge upgrade over wood. It’s lighter, it won’t rot or splinter if left out in the rain, and it absorbs vibration better, saving your hands and wrists. The blade is typically a good, thick-gauge steel that’s tough enough for packed spots but not so heavy that it becomes a burden. This is the scraper you leave by the barn door because it can handle 90% of the jobs you throw at it without making you regret the chore.

Ames True Temper Aluminum Scraper for Lighter Jobs

Weight matters, especially if you’re not as strong as you used to be or if you’re facing a long session of cleaning. An aluminum scraper, like those from Ames, is incredibly lightweight. This makes it perfect for tasks that require more finesse than force. Pushing thin slurry, scraping up fresh droppings, or cleaning wet concrete floors becomes much less of a chore.

The aluminum construction also means it will never rust, which is a serious advantage in a constantly wet and acidic environment like a hog pen. However, you must respect its limitations. Aluminum is a soft metal. If you try to use it as a pry bar or to chip away at frozen manure, you will bend the blade or dent the edge, rendering it useless. Think of it as a squeegee for solids—perfect for its intended purpose, but completely wrong for heavy-duty work.

Red Brand Galvanized Steel Scraper for Versatility

If you could only own one scraper, a classic galvanized steel model would be a strong contender. Galvanization is a process of coating steel with zinc, providing excellent protection against rust and corrosion without adding excessive weight or cost. This makes for a durable, long-lasting tool that can live in the barn for years.

A good galvanized scraper strikes a perfect balance. It’s heavier and more rigid than aluminum, so it can handle moderately packed manure and a bit of chopping. Yet it’s generally lighter and more manageable than the super heavy-duty models designed for prying up frozen ground. It works well on concrete, wood, and hard-packed dirt, making it a true jack-of-all-trades for a small farm with varied surfaces.

Flexrake Hula-Ho: A Multi-Purpose Scraper Option

Sometimes the best tool for the job isn’t the one that was designed for it. The Hula-Ho, or scuffle hoe, is a weeding tool, but its design is brilliant for cleaning manure off of dirt or gravel lots. Unlike a traditional scraper that only works on the push stroke, the Hula-Ho has an oscillating, sharpened blade that cuts on both the push and pull.

This action allows you to slice underneath dried, caked-on manure and break it free from the ground with minimal effort. It’s not for moving large volumes of wet slop; you’d still want a wide pusher for that. But for that specific, frustrating job of cleaning a dry-lot where manure has been baked on by the sun, it works wonders. It’s a perfect example of how old-timers found clever solutions using the tools they already had.

In the end, the perfect scraper is a myth. The reality for most small farms is that a system of two or three tools is the answer. A lightweight scraper for daily touch-ups, a heavy-duty monster for the tough jobs, and maybe a specialist tool like a DuraFork for bedded pens will cover all your bases, save your back, and make one of farming’s least glamorous chores just a little bit easier.