6 Best Grain Cleaners For Market Gardens Old Farmers Swear By

You’ve spent months tending your stand of ‘Turkey Red’ wheat or ‘Floriani’ flint corn, and the harvest is finally in. But now comes the real work: separating the valuable grain from the mountain of chaff, dirt, and weed seeds. For a market gardener, clean grain isn’t just a matter of pride; it’s the difference between high-quality seed for next year, a sellable product for local chefs, and a moldy, useless pile in the barn.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Selecting the Right Grain Cleaner for Your Scale

Choosing a grain cleaner isn’t about finding the biggest or fastest machine. It’s about matching the tool to the job. A farmer saving a few pounds of precious tomato seed has vastly different needs than one cleaning a hundred pounds of buckwheat for the farmers market. Your scale, crop type, and end goal dictate the right choice.

Think about your primary use. Are you aiming for 99.9% purity for seed sales, or just "clean enough" for chicken feed? The former requires precision screens and fine-tuned airflow, while the latter can be accomplished with a simpler, faster setup. Don’t overbuy. A complex machine is a headache if all you need is a quick way to blow the chaff off your pinto beans.

Consider your workflow, too. A hand-cranked fanning mill is a beautiful, off-grid tool, but it becomes a serious bottleneck if you’re trying to clean 500 pounds of oats in an afternoon. Conversely, a motorized cleaner might be overkill—and take up valuable barn space—if you only process small batches a few times a year. Be honest about your time, your space, and how much grain you really harvest.

The Clipper Office Tester for Small Batch Purity

The Clipper Office Tester is the gold standard for anyone serious about seed saving. This isn’t a high-volume machine; its name says it all. It’s a small, precise tool designed to give you an exceptionally clean sample, just like the old seed offices used to test for quality.

It works using a combination of a small vibrating screen (a riddle) and a precisely controlled column of air. The grain is fed into the top, where the air blows off the lightest chaff and dust. Then it falls onto the screen, which separates the good seed from larger debris, smaller weed seeds, and broken kernels. The result is a remarkably pure product.

This is the machine you want for high-value, small-volume seeds. Think heirloom tomatoes, rare peppers, or specialty flower seeds where every single seed counts. It’s overkill for cleaning a bushel of wheat for your chickens, but for ensuring your saved seed stock is pristine and free of contaminants, nothing in its class beats it for precision.

Hance Fanning Mill: The Time-Tested Workhorse

If you walk into an old barn, there’s a good chance you’ll find a dusty Hance fanning mill tucked in a corner. There’s a reason for that: they were built to last, and they just plain work. These hand-cranked machines are the definition of a time-tested workhorse for small-scale grain processing.

The principle is simple and effective. Turning the crank powers a fan that creates a steady stream of air. As grain is fed from a hopper, it falls through this airstream and across a series of sloped, vibrating screens. The air blows away the light chaff, while the screens sort the grain by size—good seed falls through one screen, while larger debris and smaller weed seeds are separated out.

A Hance is perfect for the farmer who has graduated from bucket-and-fan winnowing but isn’t ready for a motorized setup. It can handle bushels of wheat, oats, or beans in a reasonable amount of time. Its beauty lies in its simplicity. With no motor to fail and a solid wood-and-metal construction, a well-cared-for Hance will likely outlast you.

The Winnow Wizard for Fast and Easy Chaff Removal

Sometimes, your biggest problem isn’t weed seeds or dirt—it’s just a massive amount of light, fluffy chaff. This is especially true for crops like beans, peas, and some grains after threshing. The Winnow Wizard is a specialized tool designed to solve this one problem with incredible efficiency.

Unlike a fanning mill, the Winnow Wizard doesn’t use screens. It’s purely an air separation device. You pour your threshed crop into the top, and a clever system of baffles and an adjustable airflow allows the heavy grain or beans to fall straight down while the lighter chaff is blown out the side into a separate container. It’s incredibly fast.

This isn’t a finishing tool for seed purity. It won’t remove stones or weed seeds that are the same weight as your grain. But as a first-pass machine, it’s a game-changer. It can reduce a huge, messy pile of threshed material into a manageable amount of clean grain in minutes, saving you hours of tedious work.

Agriculex CS-1: A Compact Motorized Option

When you’ve hit the limits of hand-cranking, a compact motorized cleaner like the Agriculex CS-1 is the logical next step. This machine takes the principles of a traditional fanning mill—air and screens—and puts them into a modern, efficient, and surprisingly small package. It’s built for the serious market gardener who needs to process hundreds of pounds of grain without dedicating an entire day to the task.

The CS-1 uses a fan and two vibrating screens to provide a three-way separation. Chaff is blown off, good seed is collected in the middle, and debris is separated out. The key benefit is consistency and speed. The electric motor ensures the fan speed and screen vibration are constant, giving you a more uniform product than you can achieve by hand.

This is the right tool when your grain and seed operation becomes a meaningful part of your business. Cleaning a 50-pound batch of rye berries goes from a workout to a simple task. The trade-off is the cost and reliance on power, but the labor savings for a growing operation are undeniable.

Mater Seed Cleaner: Gentle on Delicate Seeds

Not all seeds are created equal. Hardy grains like wheat and corn can handle a rough-and-tumble cleaning process. But delicate seeds, like lettuce, dill, or many flowers, can be easily damaged by aggressive vibration or tumbling, which reduces their germination rate. The Mater Seed Cleaner is designed specifically for this challenge.

The Mater uses a system of slow-moving, soft-bristled brushes and screens combined with gentle airflow. This action carefully coaxes the seeds through the screens rather than violently shaking them. It’s a slower, more methodical process, but the payoff is significantly higher seed viability for fragile varieties.

This is a niche machine, but an essential one for any farmer who specializes in selling high-quality vegetable or flower seed. If you’ve ever struggled with cleaning light, fluffy seeds like carrots or dill that tend to get blown away in a traditional fanning mill, the Mater’s gentle and precise approach is the solution. It prioritizes seed quality over raw speed.

Farmex MT-PRO: A Portable, No-Frills Cleaner

Sometimes, you just need to get the job done right where you are. The Farmex MT-PRO is a portable, no-frills cleaner that excels in simplicity and mobility. It’s not designed for achieving lab-grade purity; it’s designed to be thrown in the back of a truck, set up in the field, and run a harvest through it quickly.

This machine is essentially a motorized, vibrating screen box. It’s fantastic for scalping—removing the biggest trash like straw, stalks, and stones—or for basic cleaning of feed grains. You can swap out screens to suit different crops, from large corn and beans to smaller grains like millet.

Think of the MT-PRO as a primary filter for your harvest. It’s the tool you use to pre-clean a crop before it goes into storage or before a more detailed final cleaning. For farmers who grow cover crop seed or grains for animal feed, this level of cleaning is often all that’s needed. Its portability makes it invaluable for shared use or for farms with multiple fields.

Final Considerations: Screens, Airflow, and Size

No matter which cleaner you choose, its performance hinges on a few key elements. Getting these details right is just as important as picking the right brand or model. The machine is only half the equation; the setup is the other half.

First and foremost are the screens. A grain cleaner is useless without the correct set of screens for your specific crop. Screens are sized by holes—either round or slotted—measured in fractions of an inch. You’ll typically need a top screen with holes slightly larger than your seed to let it fall through while scalping off bigger debris, and a bottom screen with holes slightly smaller than your seed to let dust and tiny weed seeds fall through. Having a good variety of screens is a crucial, and often overlooked, investment.

Next is airflow. The ability to adjust the fan speed is a critical feature. Too little air, and you leave chaff behind; too much, and you start blowing your good seed out with it. Lighter seeds like oats require a gentle breeze, while heavy beans can handle a strong blast. A machine with an adjustable air gate gives you the control to dial in the perfect setting for each crop.

Finally, consider the physical footprint and workflow. Where will you put this machine? You’ll need space for the unprocessed crop, the cleaner itself, and separate containers for clean grain, chaff, and waste. A cleaner that seems compact on its own can quickly dominate a small space once you’re actually using it. Plan your cleaning station before you buy.

• Screens: The single most important factor for good separation. Buy a comprehensive set.
• Airflow: Adjustable air is non-negotiable for anyone growing more than one type of crop.
• Size: Think about the entire workflow, not just the machine’s dimensions.

Ultimately, the best grain cleaner is the one that fits the unique scale and goals of your market garden. From the precision of a Clipper to the raw speed of a Winnow Wizard, each tool offers a different set of trade-offs. By honestly assessing your needs for purity, volume, and seed type, you can invest in a machine that will save you countless hours and improve the quality of your harvest for years to come.