7 Best Beginner Cheese Press Kits For Beginners For First-Year Success

You’ve mastered fresh mozzarella and your chèvre is the talk of the neighborhood, but now you’re staring at a recipe for a beautiful, aged cheddar. The only thing standing in your way is a cheese press. Choosing the right one is the critical step that separates soft, fresh cheeses from the hard, aged wheels you dream of making. This guide will help you select a press that ensures your first year of hard cheesemaking is a success, not a struggle.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing Your First Home Cheesemaking Press

The leap from soft cheese to hard cheese is all about one thing: effectively removing whey. A press isn’t just for shaping your cheese into a neat wheel; its real job is to apply consistent, measurable pressure. This compacts the curds, expels the remaining whey, and creates the dense, uniform texture necessary for a cheese to age safely and develop complex flavors.

Before you buy, think honestly about what you’ll actually make in your first year. A massive, high-pressure press is impressive, but it’s complete overkill for the two-gallon batches of milk most hobbyists start with. Focus on these key factors:

• Pressure Method: Springs offer a "set it and forget it" convenience, while weights are simple, foolproof, and easy to source.
• Materials: Stainless steel is the champion of sanitation. Wood is traditional and beautiful but requires more diligent care.
• Capacity: Can the press accommodate a 2-pound wheel of cheese? That’s a perfect size for a beginner, yielding a manageable cheese from about two gallons of milk.

Forget the notion that more pressure is always better. Most beginner hard cheeses, like a simple farmhouse cheddar or Colby, only require 10 to 50 pounds of pressure. The crucial element is consistency and the ability to increase pressure incrementally as the recipe dictates. A press that is easy to adjust and measure is far more valuable than one with a massive maximum pressure you will likely never use.

New England Cheesemaking Press: Reliable & Simple

This press is a workhorse for a reason. It uses a straightforward spring-based design that is incredibly easy for a beginner to understand and operate. You simply turn a knob to compress the springs, applying direct and even pressure to your cheese.

The true benefit here is the calibrated system. When a recipe calls for "20 pounds of pressure," you can dial it in without stacking gym weights on a board and hoping for the best. This removes a major variable from a process that already has plenty of them, which is critical for building confidence in your first few attempts. It’s designed to give you repeatable results.

Its construction is a mix of durable plastic and metal parts. While it may lack the rustic charm of a traditional wooden press, it is significantly easier to clean and sanitize. For a beginner focused on mastering the craft and ensuring food safety, this is a major advantage. It prioritizes function over form, which is exactly what you need when you’re starting out.

TSM Products Stainless Steel Press for Durability

If you prioritize sanitation and long-term durability, a stainless steel press is tough to beat. There are no pores for bacteria to hide in, and you can scrub it aggressively without worrying about damaging a finish or introducing contaminants. This is the "buy it once, use it for life" option for the practical homesteader.

This press typically uses a heavy-duty screw mechanism, which can generate immense pressure. However, it lacks the built-in calibration of a spring press. To know how much pressure you’re applying, you’ll need to place a simple bathroom scale under the press. This adds one small step to your process but gives you exceptionally precise control.

The initial investment is higher, no question. But think about the long-term picture: this press will outlast wooden models and will never absorb whey, cleaning solutions, or off-flavors. If you are confident that cheesemaking is a long-term pursuit and you envision making harder, high-pressure cheeses like Parmesan in the future, this is a solid, future-proof choice.

Lehman’s Hardwood Press for Traditional Methods

There’s an undeniable romance to using a traditional wooden press, and the Lehman’s model fully embraces that heritage. Its simple, effective hardwood construction feels connected to the long history of farmstead cheesemaking. It’s a tool that looks as good as it works.

This is a lever-style press. You hang weights from a notched arm to apply pressure, using basic physics to your advantage. The further out you hang the weight, the more the force is multiplied onto the cheese. It’s an elegant, low-tech solution that requires no springs, gauges, or complex machinery.

The primary consideration here is maintenance. Wood is porous and must be carefully cleaned and periodically oiled with a food-safe mineral oil to prevent it from cracking or harboring bacteria. It is more of a commitment than stainless steel, but for those who value traditional tools and aesthetics, the extra care is part of the process. This press is for the purist who enjoys the journey as much as the destination.

The Cheese Maker Basic Kit with Press and Molds

Starting from absolute zero can feel overwhelming, with endless lists of required supplies. A bundled kit, like this one from The Cheese Maker, is designed to solve that problem. It packages a simple press with the essential molds and followers you’ll need, removing the guesswork of pairing components.

The press itself is typically a no-frills design, often made of PVC or a similar easy-to-clean material. It isn’t built for extreme pressure, but it is perfectly adequate for the types of cheeses a beginner will be making in their first year. The real value is getting a matched set of press, follower, and molds that are guaranteed to fit and work together seamlessly.

This is an excellent entry point if you’re on a tight budget or still testing the waters of your cheesemaking hobby. You get everything you need to press your first cheddar or colby without a large upfront investment. You may eventually outgrow the press, but by that point, you’ll have the experience to know exactly what features you need in your next one.

Homesteader’s Supply Dutch Style Cheese Press

The Dutch-style press is a classic for a reason, and the model from Homesteader’s Supply is a great example of this efficient lever design. It uses a long lever arm to multiply the force from a small amount of weight, allowing you to achieve significant, consistent pressure with minimal effort. It is an intelligent and time-tested system.

What truly sets this style apart is its powerful mechanical advantage. A simple 5-pound weight can easily generate 50, 100, or even more pounds of pressure on the cheese, depending on which notch you use on the lever. This makes it incredibly versatile, capable of handling both lightly pressed cheeses and those requiring much more force, all without needing a stack of heavy, cumbersome weights.

Like other wooden presses, it demands diligent cleaning to ensure it stays sanitary. However, its open design often makes it more accessible for cleaning than some other enclosed models. This is a fantastic choice for the hobbyist who appreciates the simple mechanics of traditional tools and wants a beautiful, functional press that can easily grow with their skills.

The Grom Cheese Press: Simple and Compact Design

Not everyone has a dedicated root cellar or pantry for their homesteading projects. The Grom press is designed for the modern kitchen, prioritizing a small footprint and incredibly simple operation. It’s a compact, spring-loaded press that won’t take over your entire countertop.

Its greatest strength is its simplicity. The all-in-one design integrates the mold and the press mechanism into a single, self-contained unit. You load the curds, place the follower on top, and tighten the knobs to apply pressure via internal springs. It is about as straightforward as a cheese press can get.

The main trade-off is its limited capacity and pressure range. It’s designed for smaller cheeses, typically in the 1- to 2-pound range, and the pressure it generates is best suited for semi-hard cheeses. For a beginner making small, experimental batches to learn the process, this is an ideal, low-stress tool. It’s a low-barrier-to-entry option that gets you from curds to a pressed wheel in no time.

Roaring Brook Dairy’s Basic Wooden Press Kit

This type of press often appeals to the DIY-minded homesteader who values function above all else. It’s a simple, rugged wooden press that gets the job done without any unnecessary frills. Think of it as a tool, not a showpiece.

The design is typically a straightforward screw-press, constructed from unfinished hardwood. This gives you the opportunity to finish it yourself with a food-grade oil, creating a personal connection to your tool. It’s a weight-based system, meaning you’ll need to supply your own weights—jars of water, bricks from the garden path, or a few hand weights all work perfectly well.

This is one of the most budget-friendly ways to get into a traditional wooden press. It demands a bit more from the user in terms of setup and pressure calculation, but in doing so, it teaches the fundamentals of the process. If you’re comfortable with a more hands-on approach and want the feel of wood without the higher price tag of a Dutch-style press, this is a solid and practical starting point.

Ultimately, the best beginner cheese press is the one that fits your space, your budget, and your cheesemaking ambitions. Don’t overbuy or get intimidated by complexity. Start simple, master the process with a reliable and easy-to-clean tool, and your first year of making hard cheese will be a deeply rewarding success.