6 Best Hand Crank Winches For Garden Carts Old Farmers Swear By

Ever found yourself staring at a heavy load of firewood at the bottom of a steep hill, your garden cart right beside you, and your back already aching just thinking about it? We’ve all been there. A simple hand crank winch bolted to that cart can turn a day of grunt work into a manageable task. This isn’t about fancy equipment; it’s about using a time-tested tool to work smarter, not harder, on your land.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing a Hand Winch for Your Farm Cart

Selecting the right winch isn’t just about the maximum weight it can pull. The gear ratio is your best friend here. A higher ratio, like 5:1, means more cranking for less cable travel, but it gives you immense mechanical advantage for heavy loads. A lower ratio, like 3:1, is faster for lighter tasks like pulling a hose or moving empty containers.

You also need to choose between a steel cable and a synthetic strap. Steel cable is tough and abrasion-resistant, great for dragging logs or rocks. But it can kink, develop sharp burrs, and rust. A strap is lighter, won’t rust, and is safer if it snaps, but it can be damaged by sharp edges and degrade in the sun over time.

Finally, look for a winch with a reliable braking system or a ratcheting pawl. This mechanism prevents the handle from spinning backward under load if you let go. A winch without a solid locking mechanism is a hazard, especially when you’re pulling a heavy cart up an incline. It’s the difference between controlled work and a runaway disaster.

Dutton-Lainson DL600A: The Classic Farmhand

There’s a reason you see winches that look like this on old farm equipment. The Dutton-Lainson DL600A is a straightforward, no-nonsense tool built for work. Its 600-pound capacity is more than enough for most garden cart tasks, from hauling compost bags up a ramp to pulling felled saplings out of a ditch.

The build quality is what sets it apart. The gears are solid, not laminated, which means they can handle the torque without stripping. The zinc-plated finish holds up reasonably well to moisture, though a little grease on the moving parts at the start of the season goes a long way. It typically comes with a strap, which is perfect for general-purpose use around the homestead.

This is the winch for someone who values reliability over features. It doesn’t have multiple speeds or fancy coatings, but it does its one job exceptionally well. If you need to pull a few hundred pounds consistently without fuss, this is the old-timer’s choice.

Fulton T903 Single Speed: Simple & Reliable

The Fulton T903 is another classic single-speed winch that has earned its keep on countless small farms. With a 900-pound capacity, it offers a bit more muscle than the DL600A for those who might be moving denser materials like wet soil or fieldstones. Its design is clean and efficient, focusing on strength and ease of use.

Like the Dutton-Lainson, the Fulton is built with a zinc finish to fight off corrosion. The handle is comfortable enough for extended use, and the ratcheting mechanism is solid and dependable. You get a positive "click" with each turn, giving you confidence that your load is secure. It’s the kind of tool you bolt on and forget about until you need it.

Choosing between the Fulton and the Dutton-Lainson often comes down to availability and minor price differences. Both are workhorses. The Fulton’s slightly higher capacity might be the deciding factor if you regularly push the limits of your garden cart on hilly terrain.

Reese Towpower 74329 for Heavier Garden Loads

Sometimes, you need to move more than just mulch. The Reese Towpower 74329, often rated around 1,500 pounds, steps up for those bigger jobs. This is the winch you want for skidding small logs to your woodshed, pulling a heavily loaded cart out of thick mud, or tensioning a small fence line.

With greater capacity comes a higher gear ratio. This means you’ll be cranking more, but each turn will feel easier when wrestling a truly heavy object. It’s a trade-off: speed for power. For daily light-duty tasks, it might feel a bit slow, but when you need that extra grunt, you’ll be glad you have it.

This winch is overkill for just moving bags of feed. But if your property has challenging slopes or you find yourself using the cart for light forestry or construction tasks, the added power provides a significant margin of safety and capability. Don’t buy more winch than you need, but don’t underestimate your heaviest task.

TR Industrial 1200 lb Winch: Portable Power

This one is a bit different from the others. The TR Industrial winch is often sold as a portable "power puller" rather than a bolt-on unit. It consists of a ratcheting lever mechanism and two hooks. You anchor one hook to a tree or post and the other to your cart. Instead of cranking, you work a lever back and forth.

The main advantage here is versatility. You aren’t just limited to your cart. You can use it to stretch fencing, pull shrubs, or any other task where you need a straight-line pull. It’s a multi-tool for applying force around the homestead.

The downside is the setup time. For quick cart tasks, a permanently mounted crank winch is faster. The power puller also requires a solid anchor point, which might not always be convenient. It’s an excellent choice if you need a puller for many different jobs, but less ideal if you only need a winch for your cart.

Camco 50000 Winch with Corrosion Resistance

If you live in a wet climate or store your cart outside, rust is your enemy. The Camco 50000 winch, often rated around 2,000 pounds, is notable for its superior corrosion-resistant coating. While most winches have a basic zinc finish, models like this often feature a more robust powder coating or galvanization process designed for marine environments.

This extra protection is a practical concern. A rusty winch isn’t just ugly; the rust can compromise the gears and the ratchet mechanism, leading to failure. A well-coated winch will operate smoothly for years longer with minimal maintenance. It’s worth the small extra investment if your tools are constantly exposed to rain, mud, and humidity.

While its high capacity is a bonus, the real reason an old-timer would choose this winch is for its longevity. It’s a "buy it once, buy it right" philosophy. You pay a little more upfront to avoid replacing a seized-up piece of equipment in three years.

Goldenrod DLB800A: Two-Speed Pulling Power

The Goldenrod DLB800A brings a game-changing feature to the table: two speeds. This winch allows you to switch between a high-speed, low-power gear and a low-speed, high-power gear. This is incredibly useful for real-world work.

Imagine you’re pulling a log. You can use the fast speed (often around a 4:1 ratio) to quickly take up the slack in the strap. Once the strap is taut and the pulling gets tough, you shift down to the powerful low gear (often 9:1 or higher) to easily crank the heavy load into place. This saves a tremendous amount of time and effort compared to a single-speed winch.

This feature is not a gimmick. It addresses the most common frustration with hand winches—the slow, tedious cranking when the load is light. For anyone who uses their cart winch frequently for a variety of loads, a two-speed model is a significant quality-of-life improvement that makes the work go much faster.

Safely Mounting & Using Your Cart Winch

A winch is only as strong as its mount. Simply bolting it through the thin sheet metal of a typical garden cart is a recipe for failure. You need to mount it to the cart’s steel frame. For many carts, this means drilling through the front rail of the frame and using high-grade bolts, nuts, and large washers to distribute the load. If the frame is thin, consider adding a steel plate on the opposite side for reinforcement.

When using the winch, always wear gloves. Steel cables can develop tiny, sharp frays that will tear up your hands. Keep the cable or strap spooled neatly on the drum to prevent binding. Never exceed the winch’s rated capacity; it’s there for a reason.

Finally, inspect your equipment regularly. Check for frays in the cable or tears in the strap. Make sure the mounting bolts are tight and the ratchet mechanism engages cleanly. A minute of prevention is far better than dealing with a snapped cable and a runaway cart on a steep hill.

Ultimately, adding a hand winch to your garden cart is about reclaiming your energy for the tasks that matter more. It’s a simple machine that solves a common problem, letting you move heavy materials safely and efficiently. Choose the right one for your specific needs, mount it securely, and you’ll wonder how you ever managed without it.