6 Best Edging Trowels for Transplanting

You’ve spent weeks nurturing seedlings, watching them unfurl their first true leaves under grow lights or in the cold frame. Now comes the critical moment: transplanting them into the garden. One wrong move with a flimsy, narrow trowel can tear the delicate root ball apart, setting your plants back weeks or killing them outright. A good transplanting trowel isn’t a luxury; it’s insurance for all your hard work.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why a Wide Blade Protects Delicate Seedling Roots

A wide, slightly dished trowel blade acts like a spatula for your plants. Its primary job is to lift the entire soil plug—seedling, roots, and surrounding soil—in one intact piece. This minimizes disturbance to the fine root hairs responsible for absorbing water and nutrients.

Think of it this way: a narrow trowel slices into the soil, often cutting right through the developing root system. This is the definition of transplant shock. The plant has to expend precious energy regrowing those severed roots instead of establishing itself in its new home.

A wider blade, by contrast, gets underneath the entire root mass. You’re not just digging a hole; you’re moving a self-contained ecosystem. This simple mechanical advantage means your seedlings transition almost seamlessly, resuming growth faster and requiring less babying in the crucial first few days.

DeWit Forged Transplant Trowel: Dutch Durability

When you pick up a DeWit trowel, you feel the difference immediately. It’s not stamped from a thin sheet of metal; it’s forged from high-carbon boron steel. This means it has the heft and strength to slice into compacted clay soil without a hint of flex.

The blade is typically long, sharp, and just wide enough to lift a perfect plug from a 4-inch pot or a dense nursery flat. This isn’t a delicate tool. It’s a workhorse designed to handle real-world soil conditions, including hidden rocks and stubborn perennial roots. The traditional hardwood handle is comfortable, but it’s the blade’s unyielding performance that makes it a lifetime investment.

The tradeoff for this durability is weight. After transplanting a few hundred onions, you’ll notice the extra ounces. But for its intended purpose—making clean, deep cuts and levering out plants with their root systems fully intact—its strength is an asset, not a liability.

Nisaku Hori Hori Knife: Precision and Versatility

The Hori Hori is the multitool of the garden, and it earns its place here for its incredible versatility. Its concave, Japanese stainless steel blade is excellent for scooping soil, while one edge is serrated and the other is a sharp knife. This combination is what makes it so useful for transplanting.

When you encounter a patch of sod or a web of competing roots where you want to plant a tomato seedling, the Hori Hori shines. You can use the serrated edge to saw a clean opening, then use the dished blade to excavate the hole. The depth markings engraved on the blade are a genuinely useful feature for getting consistent planting depth, which is critical for things like brassicas and corn.

However, it’s not a specialized transplanting trowel. The blade is narrower than a dedicated model from DeWit or Sneeboer. Its strength is precision and problem-solving, not lifting the largest possible soil plug. It’s the perfect tool for transplanting into less-than-perfect conditions or for gardeners who value having one tool that does many jobs well.

Wilcox All-Pro 202S Trowel: Indestructible Design

If you are notoriously hard on tools, the Wilcox All-Pro is your answer. Forged from a single piece of American stainless steel, there are no welds to snap or wooden handles to rot and break off. You can use it to pry out rocks, chop through tough roots, and leave it in the mud for a week—it will be fine.

Its long, narrow design with a sharp point is fantastic for penetrating hard, sun-baked, or rocky ground. While not as wide as other transplanting trowels, its sheer toughness allows you to use it as a lever, prying up a larger section of soil around the seedling. The blade is also etched with depth markings, a simple but effective feature.

The primary consideration is comfort. The "handle" is simply the squared-off end of the steel bar, often with a vinyl grip. It’s functional, not ergonomic. For planting a few dozen seedlings, it’s perfect. For a full day of transplanting, you might prefer something with a more forgiving grip.

Radius Garden Pro-Lite Trowel: Ergonomic Handling

The most striking feature of the Radius Garden trowel is its patented, circular handle. This isn’t a gimmick. The design provides more leverage from your wrist and forearm, significantly reducing stress and fatigue during repetitive tasks like transplanting. For anyone with arthritis, carpal tunnel, or simply a lot of plants to get in the ground, this ergonomic advantage is a game-changer.

The blade itself is typically made from a lightweight aluminum-magnesium alloy, making the whole tool surprisingly light. It’s wide and dished, perfectly shaped for scooping and moving soil without spilling. It excels at its job: moving soil and transplanting from prepared beds or containers.

This tool is a specialist. It’s not a pry bar for rocks or a chopper for roots. Its lightweight construction means you should pair it with another tool for heavy-duty tasks. But for the specific job of moving dozens or hundreds of seedlings into well-worked soil, its combination of low weight and ergonomic design makes it one of the most comfortable and efficient options available.

A.M. Leonard Deluxe Soil Knife: A Pro’s Go-To Tool

Take the versatility of a Hori Hori and refine it for professional use, and you get the A.M. Leonard Deluxe Soil Knife. Landscape pros and nursery workers love this tool for a reason: it’s built for speed and efficiency. The blade is wider and more "dished" than a traditional Hori Hori, making it a much better scooper.

It retains all the best features of a soil knife: a razor-sharp edge for slicing open bags of soil amendments, a serrated edge for cutting through roots, and a handy twine-cutting notch. The bright orange handle is nearly impossible to lose in the field—a small but significant detail when you’re moving quickly down a row.

This is the tool for someone who needs to do more than just transplant. You can weed, cultivate, divide perennials, and plant bulbs all with the same tool in your belt. It strikes an excellent balance between the specialized scooping power of a wide trowel and the all-purpose utility of a soil knife.

Sneeboer Transplanting Trowel: Heirloom Quality

Sneeboer tools are in a class of their own. Hand-forged in the Netherlands from stainless steel, they represent the pinnacle of garden tool craftsmanship. The transplanting trowel is long, narrow, and perfectly balanced, designed to slide into the soil with minimal effort and lift out a deep, clean plug.

Using a Sneeboer is about more than just function; it’s about the experience. The sharpness of the blade, the smooth finish of the ash or cherry wood handle, and the perfect balance make work feel less like a chore. It is exceptionally strong and will last for generations if cared for properly.

Of course, this level of quality comes at a premium price. A Sneeboer is an investment. It’s not the tool you buy when you’re just starting out, but it might be the last trowel you ever buy. For the dedicated farmer who finds joy in using beautifully made, highly effective tools, it is unmatched.

Choosing Your Trowel: Blade Shape and Handle Grip

There is no single "best" trowel, only the best tool for your specific soil, tasks, and body. The decision comes down to two key factors: the blade and the handle.

For the blade, consider your primary need:

• Wide & Dished: Best for scooping loose soil and lifting large, intact plugs from trays. Think DeWit or Radius.
• Long & Pointed: Best for penetrating compacted or rocky soil. Think Wilcox.
• Multi-Function (Serrated/Knife Edge): Best for versatility and dealing with roots, sod, or twine. Think Nisaku Hori Hori or A.M. Leonard.

For the handle, think about your work sessions:

• Ergonomic: If you have hand or wrist pain, or face long hours of planting, the Radius handle is a clear winner.
• Indestructible: If you are rough on tools and value durability above all, the one-piece metal design of the Wilcox is your best bet.
• Traditional Wood: For a classic feel, excellent durability, and a connection to the tool, DeWit and Sneeboer are top choices.

Ultimately, your trowel should feel like an extension of your hand. The right one makes a demanding job easier, protects your precious seedlings, and connects you more deeply to the work of growing food.

Choosing the right trowel is a small decision that has a big impact on the health of your transplants and the comfort of your own body. By matching the tool’s design to your soil and your workflow, you’re not just buying a piece of steel; you’re investing in a more successful and enjoyable season. A good tool makes good work possible.