6 Best Low-Profile Hay Feeders For Cattle That Reduce Hay Waste

Watching a perfectly good round bale get trampled into the mud is one of the most frustrating sights on a small farm. It feels like watching dollar bills dissolve in the rain. The right hay feeder isn’t just a piece of equipment; it’s a tool that directly impacts your bottom line and the health of your herd.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Low-Profile Feeders Cut Your Hay Costs

The biggest enemy of your hay budget is waste. Cattle are notorious for pulling hay from a feeder, dropping it, and then using it for bedding or a latrine. An open-ring feeder might keep them from walking all over the bale, but it does little to stop them from dragging hay out onto the ground.

This is where low-profile, skirted feeders make a huge difference. A solid panel or "skirt" around the bottom of the feeder acts as a catch basin. When a cow pulls a mouthful of hay and some falls, it lands inside the feeder, not in the mud. They are forced to clean up what they drop, dramatically reducing the amount of hay that gets trampled and soiled.

Studies have shown that waste can be as high as 40% when feeding on the ground, and still significant with a basic ring. A well-designed feeder can cut that waste to under 10%. When you do the math on how many bales you feed a year, that savings adds up fast—often paying for the feeder in a single season.

Tarter Hay Saver: A Classic Feeder Design

The Tarter Hay Saver is a familiar sight for a reason. It takes the simple, effective design of a round bale ring and adds a crucial feature: a 17-inch tall solid metal skirt at the bottom. This single addition is the key to its effectiveness.

This feeder works by creating a barrier that contains dropped hay. Cattle can still reach over the top to eat, but anything they spill is kept within the feeder’s perimeter. It’s a straightforward design that is both durable and proven to work. The heavy-duty steel construction means it can stand up to the daily pushing and shoving of a small herd.

The primary tradeoff is its weight and rigid, one-piece design. Moving it requires a tractor with a front-end loader, and it’s built specifically for round bales. However, for a simple, set-it-and-forget-it solution that provides a great balance of cost and performance, it’s a solid choice.

Behlen Country Cone Feeder for Maximum Savings

If your absolute top priority is minimizing waste, the cone feeder is the gold standard. The Behlen Country model combines a solid outer ring with an inner metal cone that suspends the bale off the ground. This design forces cattle to pull hay down and inward, making it nearly impossible for them to sling it outside the feeder.

The cone insert keeps the bale centered and elevated, which also promotes better airflow and reduces spoilage at the bottom of the bale. The combination of the cone and the outer skirt means virtually every stem of hay is consumed. This design consistently ranks as one of the most efficient, often reducing waste to 5% or less.

The biggest considerations are cost and loading. Cone feeders are among the more expensive options, representing a significant upfront investment. They also absolutely require a tractor with a bale spear to lift the round bale up and over the side to drop it into the cone. For those with the right equipment, the long-term hay savings can easily justify the initial expense.

Sioux Steel Cradle Feeder for Easy Loading

Not everyone has a tractor with a front-end loader, and that’s where the cradle feeder shines. Its low-slung, V-shaped design makes it one of the easiest feeders to load by hand. You can either roll a round bale into it or easily stack small square bales inside.

This convenience is a game-changer for many small operations. The ability to place a feeder without starting up heavy machinery saves time and hassle. The cradle also keeps the hay off the ground, preventing the moisture-wicking and spoilage that happens when feeding directly on the pasture.

While it’s a massive improvement over ground feeding, a cradle feeder doesn’t offer the same level of waste reduction as a skirted ring or cone feeder. Cattle can still pull hay out over the sides. It represents a trade-off: you gain supreme loading convenience at the cost of some hay-saving efficiency. It’s an excellent choice for those feeding square bales or managing their herd without a large tractor.

Hutchison Bull-Tuff Feeder for Herd Durability

Cattle are not gentle on their surroundings. They lean, push, and rub on everything, and a flimsy hay feeder won’t last a single season. The Hutchison Bull-Tuff line is built with this reality in mind, prioritizing heavy-gauge steel and rugged construction above all else.

These feeders are an investment in longevity. While the design might be a simple skirted ring, the materials are thicker and the welds are stronger than many budget-friendly alternatives. This is the kind of feeder you buy when you’re tired of replacing bent and broken equipment every few years. It’s designed to handle the pressure of larger animals like bulls or a group of competitive steers.

The downside is predictable: weight and cost. A heavier build means it’s more difficult to move and carries a higher price tag. But if you view a feeder as a long-term farm asset, the durability can make it the most economical choice over a decade of use.

Century Poly Feeder: A Lightweight Option

Steel isn’t the only option. The Century Poly Feeder, made from tough, molded polyethylene, offers a unique set of advantages. Its most obvious benefit is its weight. It’s light enough for one person to easily roll and move around the pasture, which is perfect for rotational grazing systems.

Poly feeders are also rust-proof and have smoother, more rounded edges, which can be safer for animals, reducing the risk of cuts or scrapes. The single-piece construction is surprisingly durable and can flex under pressure where a steel feeder might dent or bend permanently.

The main consideration is its performance in extreme conditions. In deep-freeze temperatures, the poly can become brittle and may crack under a significant impact. It’s also more susceptible to being pushed around by a very determined herd. For smaller herds in moderate climates, however, its portability and safety are major selling points.

Applegate Steel Skirted Ring for Simplicity

Sometimes, you just need a simple tool that does its job without any fuss. The Applegate Steel Skirted Ring is exactly that. It’s a no-frills, multi-piece ring feeder with a solid metal skirt, offering a significant upgrade from a basic open ring at an accessible price point.

The multi-piece design is a key feature. It means you can set a round bale on the ground and then assemble the feeder around it, which is a workable solution if you don’t have a front-end loader to lift the bale. It delivers the core benefit of a skirted feeder—catching dropped hay—in a practical and affordable package.

This feeder isn’t the heaviest-duty option, nor is it the most efficient design available. But it hits a sweet spot of affordability, practicality, and effectiveness. For a hobby farmer looking to take the first and most important step in reducing hay waste, a simple skirted ring like this is often the perfect place to start.

Key Factors in Choosing Your Cattle Hay Feeder

The "best" feeder is the one that best fits your specific farm. Don’t just look at waste-reduction percentages; consider the whole picture of your operation.

Think through these key factors before you buy:

• Your Equipment: This is the most important question. If you don’t have a tractor with a bale spear, your choices are limited to cradle feeders or multi-piece rings that can be assembled on-site.
• Your Bale Type: Are you feeding large round bales, small squares, or a mix? Cradle feeders excel with squares, while rings and cone feeders are built for rounds.
• Your Herd: A few gentle dairy cows have different needs than a dozen rowdy steers. For aggressive herds or bulls, prioritize heavy-duty construction. If you have calves, ensure they can easily reach the hay.
• Your Budget: An expensive cone feeder might save the most hay, but it doesn’t help if you can’t afford it. It’s better to have a good, affordable skirted ring in the pasture than a perfect, expensive one in a catalog.

Ultimately, choosing a feeder is about balancing efficiency, cost, durability, and convenience. Analyze your daily chores and your herd’s behavior, and pick the feeder that solves your biggest problems.

Investing in a quality hay feeder is one of the quickest ways to see a return on your farm. It turns a major expense into a manageable cost, all while keeping your cattle healthier. The right choice saves you money, time, and the frustration of watching good hay go to waste.