6 Best Tractor Stump Pullers for Homestead Clearing

That old pasture you want to reclaim has a dozen stubborn stumps dotting the landscape like granite tombstones. You can’t mow it, you can’t till it, and every time you look at it, you see a full day of back-breaking labor. For homesteaders and small farmers, turning that forgotten patch of ground into productive land starts with solving the stump problem.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Clearing Land: The Stump Removal Challenge

Stumps are more than just an inconvenience; they’re a full stop to progress. They prevent you from establishing new garden beds, creating smooth pastures, or even just running a brush hog without risking a broken shear pin. Letting them rot can take a decade, and chemical dissolvers or burning come with their own set of problems and environmental concerns.

For anyone with a tractor, the game changes. Your machine is a power plant on wheels, capable of applying incredible force to a stubborn problem. The challenge isn’t a lack of power, but how to apply it safely and effectively. Simply hooking a chain and yanking is a recipe for a flipped tractor or a snapped chain whipping through the air.

The right attachment or method channels your tractor’s power into focused, productive force. It turns a dangerous gamble into a repeatable process. The key is matching the tool not just to the stump, but to your tractor’s size, your soil type, and the scale of your land-clearing project.

The Simple Power of a Grade 100 Chain and Hook

Before any fancy attachments existed, there was the chain. This is the old-timer’s method, relying on brute force, a low center of gravity, and a healthy dose of caution. The concept is simple: dig out the main roots on one side, wrap a heavy-duty chain around the base of the stump, and use the tractor’s pulling power to tear it from the ground.

The critical detail here is the chain itself. Do not use a standard Grade 70 transport chain. Those are designed for tying things down, not for the shock loads of pulling. You need a Grade 100 or Grade 120 alloy lifting chain with properly rated hooks. It costs more, but it’s the difference between a successful pull and a potentially lethal accident.

This method has its place for smaller stumps or in sandy soil where roots give way easily. But it remains the most dangerous option on this list. Always pull from the tractor’s drawbar, never from the 3-point hitch or axle, to prevent the tractor from flipping over backward. Pull slowly, steadily, and be prepared to stop immediately if things don’t feel right.

CountyLine 3-Point Hitch Stump Puller Leverage

A 3-point hitch stump puller is a simple, elegant piece of engineering that transforms pulling force into powerful vertical leverage. Sold at places like Tractor Supply under the CountyLine brand, this V-shaped steel implement is designed to bite into a stump and use the tractor’s hydraulic lift to pry it upward. It’s a specialized tool that does one job extremely well.

The process is straightforward. You back the implement up to the stump, lowering it so the sharpened point digs under the root ball. As you engage the 3-point hitch lift, the long frame provides leverage, concentrating all the lifting force of your tractor onto a single point. This vertical prying action is often far more effective than a straight pull, especially for tap-rooted trees like pine or hickory.

This is an excellent choice for compact tractors that may not have a front-end loader or lack the sheer weight for heavy chain pulling. It’s a safer method because the force is directed vertically, reducing the risk of flipping the tractor. The main tradeoff is its specificity; it’s not a multi-purpose tool. But if your primary goal is removing dozens of small to medium-sized stumps, it’s a remarkably effective and affordable solution.

Titan Attachments Stump Bucket for Loader Work

If your tractor has a front-end loader, a stump bucket is one of the most versatile land-clearing tools you can own. It’s not just a narrow bucket; it’s a purpose-built pry bar for your machine. A good stump bucket, like those from Titan Attachments, is made from thick, reinforced steel and features a serrated leading edge or aggressive teeth designed for ripping through roots.

Using one is an active process. You use the bucket’s teeth to dig around the stump, severing the lateral roots one by one. Then, you wedge the bucket under the main root ball and use the loader’s curl and lift functions to pry the stump out of the ground, rocking it back and forth to break it free. The power comes from the hydraulic cylinders, not from ramming the stump with the tractor.

The real beauty of a stump bucket is what you can do after the stump is out. You can use it to carry the stump to a burn pile, dig a trench, move large rocks, or grade the disturbed soil. This multi-functionality makes it a favorite for homesteaders who need every dollar and every attachment to pull double or triple duty.

The BXpanded Piranha Tooth Bar for Grubbing

Sometimes the problem isn’t a few massive stumps, but a whole field of small ones, brush, and overgrown root systems. For this "grubbing" work, a tooth bar is a game-changer. The BXpanded Piranha Tooth Bar is a popular example that bolts directly onto the leading edge of your existing front-end loader bucket, instantly transforming it into a much more aggressive digging tool.

The sharp, serrated teeth allow your bucket to penetrate hard ground and slice through smaller roots that a standard smooth edge would just skim over. Instead of prying out one stump at a time, you can use the tooth bar to systematically clear an entire area. You can scrape away layers of roots, pop out saplings, and prepare rough ground for a final grading with a box blade.

This isn’t the tool for a two-foot-diameter oak stump. It excels at clearing land that’s been fallow for years, overgrown with sumac, briars, and small trees. It’s an affordable upgrade that massively increases the capability of an attachment you already own, making it a perfect fit for the homesteader’s mindset of maximizing utility.

Worksaver GR-48 Grapple for Uprooting Stumps

For sheer, brute-force effectiveness, nothing on a homestead tractor beats a good grapple. While primarily designed for moving logs and brush, a well-built grapple like the Worksaver GR-48 has the clamping power and structural integrity to make short work of stubborn stumps. This method is less about finesse and more about overwhelming the stump with force.

The technique involves using the grapple’s powerful hydraulic jaws to get a firm grip on what’s left of the trunk. Once clamped on, you use a combination of the loader’s lift, curl, and the tractor’s driving force to rock, twist, and tear the stump from the earth. The ability to grab and manipulate the stump from different angles is a significant advantage over static pullers or buckets.

This is the most capable, but also the most demanding, option. It requires a tractor with a robust front-end loader and third-function hydraulics to operate the grapple’s clamp. Grapples are also a significant investment. However, no other attachment offers the same level of versatility for a homestead—it can clear stumps, move logs for firewood, stack brush piles, and handle countless other material-handling chores.

The Stumpster: A Compact Tractor Specialist

Many homesteaders work with sub-compact or small compact tractors, machines that are big on utility but limited in raw power and weight. For these tractors, traditional stump pulling can be frustrating or downright dangerous. The Stumpster is a brilliantly designed implement made specifically to multiply the power of these smaller machines.

It works on the principle of focused leverage. The system uses a heavy-duty, serrated T-post that you drive into the center of the stump with a sledgehammer. A lever arm, which attaches to the tractor’s 3-point hitch, then connects to the post. As you lift the 3-point hitch, the arm pivots and applies an incredible amount of vertical force, effectively "popping" the stump out of the ground like a cork.

The Stumpster allows a 25-horsepower tractor to remove stumps that would otherwise require a much larger machine. It’s a highly specialized tool, meaning it only does this one job. But for the small-tractor owner facing a field of stumps, it’s a revolutionary solution that makes an impossible task manageable and safe.

Stump Pulling Safety and Choosing Your Method

Let’s be clear: removing stumps with a tractor is one of the most hazardous jobs you can do. The forces involved are immense, and a mistake can lead to a catastrophic failure, from a snapped chain to a rolled tractor. Always know your tractor’s limits, inspect your equipment before every use, and never rush the process.

Choosing the right method comes down to a few key questions:

• What is your tractor’s capability? No loader means you’re looking at a 3-point hitch puller or a chain. A small tractor is a perfect candidate for The Stumpster. A big tractor with a loader and hydraulics opens up bucket and grapple options.
• What is your primary task? If you need to remove just a few stumps, a dedicated 3-point puller is efficient. If you’re clearing an entire acre of brush and small trees, a tooth bar or grapple offers better versatility.
• What is your budget? A chain is the cheapest entry point (if you respect the risks). A tooth bar is an affordable upgrade. A grapple is a major investment that pays dividends in its multi-purpose utility.

Ultimately, the best tool is the one that matches your machine and your project. Trying to pull a massive stump with an underpowered setup is a recipe for broken equipment and a dangerous situation. It’s far better to choose the right tool for the job, work slowly and deliberately, and turn that stump-filled field into productive ground, one root at a time.

Clearing land is a foundational act of homesteading, and the right stump puller transforms a monumental obstacle into a manageable task. By matching the tool to your tractor and the job at hand, you can work safely and efficiently, finally unlocking the full potential of your property.