6 Best Cheese Press Kits For Mozzarella for Beginners

So you’ve mastered the stretch and pull of a perfect mozzarella, and the fresh, milky flavor is a regular feature in your kitchen. You’re probably looking at your cheesemaking supplies and wondering, "What’s next?" The answer lies in a simple, powerful tool that opens up a whole new world of aged, flavorful cheeses: the cheese press.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why Press Cheese? A Guide for Mozzarella Makers

Let’s get one thing straight right away: you don’t press mozzarella. Mozzarella is a pasta filata or "stretched-curd" cheese, and its unique texture comes from heating and stretching, not from pressing. The title of this article is for you, the mozzarella maker, who is ready to take the next logical step into the world of hard cheeses.

A cheese press serves one primary function: to expel the remaining whey from the curds after they’ve been drained. This process knits the curds together into a solid, uniform wheel of cheese. The amount of pressure and the duration of pressing determine the final moisture content, which in turn dictates the cheese’s texture and how well it will age.

Think of it as the gateway from fresh, quick cheeses to the complex, aged varieties like cheddar, gouda, and parmesan. While your mozzarella is ready in an hour, a pressed cheese is an investment in future flavor. The press is the essential tool that makes that transformation possible.

New England Cheesemaking Basic Press: Simple Start

If you’re just dipping your toes into pressed cheeses, this is often the place to start. The New England Cheesemaking press is a straightforward, no-frills screw press, usually made of durable hardwood. Assembly is minimal, and its operation is intuitive: you turn the crank to apply pressure.

This press is perfect for making two to five-pound wheels of cheese, which is a great size for a hobby farmer. It’s affordable and doesn’t require a lot of specialized knowledge to get good results on your first farmhouse cheddar or colby. The main tradeoff is precision; you’re applying pressure by "feel" or by using a bathroom scale underneath, rather than with calibrated weights. For a beginner, this is rarely a problem.

The CheeseMaker Dutch Press: For Even Pressure

The Dutch press looks different, operating with a long lever arm and weights. This design has a significant advantage: it delivers consistent and even pressure across the entire surface of the cheese. You calculate the pressure based on the weight you hang and where you place it on the lever, making your results highly repeatable.

This style of press is for the cheesemaker who wants to eliminate variables. If you’ve made a few pressed cheeses and found they have an uneven texture or pockets of moisture, uneven pressure is a likely culprit. The Dutch press solves that problem beautifully. The downside is its footprint; it takes up more counter space than a compact screw press and requires you to supply your own weights, though a gallon jug of water (which weighs about 8.3 pounds) works perfectly.

Roaring Brook Hardwood Press: A Sturdy Option

When you see a Roaring Brook press, you see craftsmanship. These are typically built from beautiful, solid hardwoods like maple, and they are designed to be both functional tools and kitchen showpieces. They are incredibly sturdy, which is more important than it sounds.

A flimsy press can bow or flex under the high pressure required for very hard cheeses like Parmesan, leading to an uneven press. The robust frame of a Roaring Brook model ensures all the force you apply goes directly and evenly into the cheese. This is a "buy it for life" tool for the artisan who appreciates quality and plans on making cheese for many years to come. It’s an investment, but one that pays off in consistency and durability.

Lehman’s Stainless Steel Press: Built to Last

For the cheesemaker who prioritizes sanitation and ease of cleaning above all else, a stainless steel press is the top choice. Unlike wood, which is porous and requires careful cleaning and oiling to prevent bacteria from taking hold, stainless steel is non-porous. You can wash it, sanitize it, and be completely confident it’s clean for your next batch.

This is a huge advantage, especially if you plan on aging your cheeses for months. Any unwanted bacteria introduced during pressing can multiply in the cheese cave and ruin your hard work. While these presses lack the traditional aesthetic of wood, their practicality is unmatched. They are rugged, will never crack or warp, and represent the ultimate in food-safe design for the home dairy.

Homestead T-Handle Press: Compact & Affordable

Not everyone has a dedicated cheese-making room or endless counter space. The Homestead T-Handle press is built for the practicalities of a smaller kitchen. It’s typically a very simple, compact screw press that’s easy to store in a cabinet when you’re done.

This press is ideal for making smaller, one or two-pound cheeses. It won’t generate the immense pressure needed for a dry, long-aged Parmesan, but it has more than enough power for a wonderful Tomme, Caerphilly, or a small cheddar. Its affordability and small size make it a fantastic, low-risk entry point for someone who is curious about pressed cheese but not yet ready to commit to a larger, more expensive piece of equipment.

Country Trading Co. Kit: All-in-One for Artisans

Sometimes the biggest hurdle isn’t the technique but sourcing all the different supplies. The Country Trading Co. kits are designed to solve that problem by bundling everything you need to get started. These kits often include a well-made wooden press, a variety of cheese molds, cultures, rennet, cheesecloth, and detailed recipes.

The primary benefit here is convenience. It takes the guesswork out of the equation and ensures you have compatible components right out of the box. This is an excellent option for a gift or for the beginner who feels overwhelmed by choice and just wants a clear path to making their first pressed cheese. You might pay a small premium for the curated package, but you save a lot of time and potential frustration.

Choosing Your First Press: Key Factors to Consider

The "best" press is the one that fits your space, budget, and cheesemaking ambitions. Don’t get caught up in finding a single perfect answer. Instead, think through these key factors to find the right tool for you.

Consider your real-world situation. A beautiful, large Dutch press is useless if you have nowhere to put it. A small, affordable press that you use every month is a far better investment than an expensive one that gathers dust.

Here’s a simple framework to guide your decision:

• Budget: Are you looking for a low-cost entry point (Homestead, New England Basic) or a long-term investment (Roaring Brook, Lehman’s)?
• Space: Do you have ample counter space for a lever-style press (Dutch) or do you need something compact that can be stored away (T-Handle)?
• Goals: Are you experimenting with small batches of semi-hard cheese, or are you aiming to make large wheels of very hard, long-aged cheeses? The sturdier presses handle higher pressures better.
• Material & Maintenance: Do you prefer the traditional feel of wood and are you willing to maintain it, or do you prioritize the simple, bulletproof sanitation of stainless steel?

Moving from mozzarella to a pressed cheddar is a major step in your cheesemaking journey. A good press is simply a tool, but it’s the tool that unlocks dozens of new recipes and the deep satisfaction of aging your own cheese. Choose the one that makes sense for your farmstead, and get ready to discover a whole new world of flavor.