6 Best Sheepdog Trainings for Working Farm Dogs

There’s a certain magic in watching a good dog work livestock, a silent conversation of pressure and release that moves animals with quiet efficiency. For a small farmer, a well-trained herding dog isn’t a luxury; it’s a force multiplier, turning a two-person job into a one-person task. But that seamless partnership isn’t born, it’s built through dedicated, intelligent training.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing a Herding Breed for Your Small Farm

Before you even think about training, you have to select the right partner. While Border Collies are the undisputed masters of sheep work, their intensity can be overwhelming for a small flock or an inexperienced handler. They possess a strong "eye"—an intense, intimidating stare they use to control stock—which is perfect for stubborn sheep but can be too much for flighty poultry or sensitive animals.

Consider the scale and type of your operation. An Australian Shepherd or an English Shepherd might be a better all-around choice for a diversified hobby farm, bringing herding instinct alongside a more general-purpose farmhand temperament. For smaller stock like ducks or a very small flock of sheep, even breeds like the Pembroke Welsh Corgi have a long history as capable, low-to-the-ground heelers. The most important factor isn’t the breed, but the breeding. Always seek out a dog from proven working lines, not show lines, as the instinct to work is what you’re truly after.

Essential Obedience Before Herding Training

Herding is not a replacement for basic obedience; it’s an advanced application of it. Taking a dog with poor impulse control and no recall into a field of livestock is a recipe for chaos and potential injury to your animals. Before a dog ever sees a sheep, it must have a rock-solid foundation in a few key commands, practiced to the point of being reflexive even amidst distractions.

The non-negotiables are a perfect recall (‘Come’ or ‘Here’), a reliable ‘Stay’, and a ‘Leave It’ command. A dog that won’t immediately abandon what it’s doing and return to you is a liability. This isn’t about convenience; it’s about safety. You must be able to call your dog off the stock at any moment, whether it’s getting over-excited or a gate was left open unexpectedly. This foundational control is your emergency brake, and it must be installed and tested long before you hit the pasture.

First Stock Introduction: The Round Pen Method

A dog’s first encounter with livestock should be a controlled, positive experience designed to awaken instinct, not overwhelm it. The round pen is the ideal classroom for this. Using a small, 40- to 60-foot diameter pen with a few "dog-broke" (calm and accustomed to dogs) sheep, you create a safe space where the dog can learn without being able to get into too much trouble.

The goal here is simple: let the dog figure it out. Initially, you’ll stay quiet and simply let the dog in with the stock. You’re watching for it to "turn on"—to show interest and start moving around the animals. The dog will naturally discover the "balance point," the invisible line around the flock where its presence influences their movement. Your job is to observe, keeping the situation calm and ending the session on a positive note before the dog gets tired or over-stimulated.

Mastering Flank Commands: ‘Come-Bye’ & ‘Away’

Once a dog understands how to balance on the stock, it’s time to give that movement direction. Flanking commands are the steering wheel, allowing you to position the dog anywhere around the flock. The two primary commands are ‘Come-bye’ (move clockwise around the stock) and ‘Away to me’ or simply ‘Away’ (move counter-clockwise).

Teaching this often starts in the round pen. As the dog circles the stock, step toward its shoulder to block it from continuing in one direction, gently pushing it the other way while giving the appropriate command. Repetition builds the association. These commands are the essence of gathering. Need to bring the flock in from the far corner of the pasture? You’ll send the dog on a wide ‘Away’ flank to get behind them without scattering the group.

The ‘Lie Down’: Your Most Important Stop Command

If flanking commands are the steering wheel, the ‘Lie Down’ is the brake, and it’s the single most important command in herding. It does more than just stop the dog’s feet; it stops the pressure on the livestock. When a dog lies down, it instantly releases its "eye" and physical presence, allowing the stock to calm down and the handler to assess the situation and give the next command.

A working ‘Lie Down’ must be instantaneous and absolute, whether the dog is ten feet away or two hundred. It’s taught away from stock first, making it a conditioned reflex. Then, it’s introduced into training sessions. When the dog is moving too fast or getting pushy, a sharp ‘Lie Down’ command stops the action, resets the dog’s brain, and reinforces your control. Without a reliable stop, you cannot do precise work like penning or sorting.

Teaching the ‘Walk On’ for Driving Livestock

While flanking is for gathering and maneuvering, driving is for moving stock in a straight line away from you. The command for this is typically ‘Walk On’ or ‘Walk Up’. This tells the dog to stop circling and move directly toward the back of the flock, applying steady, forward pressure to push them down a lane, through a gate, or toward a barn.

To teach this, you position yourself behind the dog, with the stock in front. By walking toward the dog and giving the ‘Walk On’ command, you encourage it to move forward into the stock’s flight zone. This is a different skill from flanking; it requires the dog to ignore its instinct to run to the head of the group. A dog that has mastered the ‘Walk On’ can calmly and steadily move animals across a property without stressing them.

Advanced Skills: Shedding, Penning, and Sorting

Once your dog has mastered the fundamentals of gathering, stopping, and driving, you can move on to the fine-detail work that truly makes a farm dog invaluable. These advanced skills require a deep partnership between dog and handler and an immense amount of control from the dog.

• Shedding: This is the act of splitting a group of animals. The dog is asked to walk into the middle of the flock and use precise pressure and "eye" to cut one or more animals away from the main group.
• Penning: Pushing livestock into a confined space like a trailer or a small holding pen is a test of patience. The dog must learn to apply just enough pressure to move the animals in, but not so much that they panic and try to bolt past the entrance.
• Sorting: This is the most complex task, often involving shedding a single animal from the flock for inspection or treatment. It requires the dog to focus on a specific animal while ignoring the others, responding instantly to the handler’s directions.

‘That’ll Do’: The Critical Off-Switch Command

Just as important as a command to start working is a command to stop. ‘That’ll Do’ is the universal signal that the job is finished. When the dog hears this, it should immediately disengage from the livestock, stop working, and return to the handler. This command is crucial for the dog’s mental well-being and for safety on the farm.

A high-drive working dog without an off-switch can become obsessive, running itself to exhaustion or harassing stock when it’s not supposed to be working. Teaching ‘That’ll Do’ involves calling the dog out of the work with the phrase, rewarding it enthusiastically for coming, and then immediately moving on to a different activity or putting it away. It clearly defines the boundary between work time and rest time, which is essential for a balanced and reliable farm partner.

Correcting Common Issues: Gripping and Circling

Even with the best training, problems will arise. Two of the most common are gripping and frantic circling. Gripping, or biting the stock, must be corrected immediately. While a strategic nip on the heel of a stubborn ewe can be acceptable, biting wool or causing injury is not. A sharp verbal correction or a quick shake of a shaker can is often enough to communicate that this behavior is wrong.

Obsessive circling occurs when a dog gets "stuck" running flanks without purpose, often out of anxiety or excitement. The handler must interrupt this pattern. A firm ‘Lie Down’ command can break the dog’s focus, or you may need to physically walk into its path to block the circle. These issues are almost always a sign that the dog is confused or over-stimulated, meaning you’ve likely pushed it too far, too fast. The solution is to go back a step and rebuild the dog’s confidence on simpler tasks.

Consistent Practice for a Reliable Farm Partner

A well-trained sheepdog is not the product of a weekend seminar; it’s the result of hundreds of small, consistent training sessions. Five to ten minutes of focused practice every day is far more effective than a frustrating hour-long session once a week. Every time you move the flock to a new pasture, it’s an opportunity to reinforce the ‘Come-bye’, ‘Away’, and ‘Walk On’.

The ultimate goal is to build a partnership where the dog not only follows commands but begins to anticipate the needs of the stock and the handler. This level of trust and understanding comes only from time and shared experience. The work you put in will be returned tenfold in the form of a capable, reliable partner that makes managing your small farm safer, more efficient, and infinitely more enjoyable.

Training a working dog is a journey that demands patience, consistency, and a deep respect for the animal’s natural instincts. The result is more than just a tool; it’s a thinking, breathing asset that becomes an integral part of your farm’s ecosystem. A good dog makes good stock, and a good handler makes a great dog.