6 Best Automatic Headgates For Dairy Goats That Keep Your Does Calm
Discover the top 6 automatic headgates designed to reduce stress in dairy goats. Our guide helps you choose the best for calmer, more efficient milking.
The most important part of your milking routine happens before a single drop of milk hits the pail. It’s the moment your doe walks onto the stand and puts her head in the headgate. A calm, willing entry sets the tone for everything that follows, while a clanging, scary headgate can turn a simple chore into a daily rodeo.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Why a Calm Headgate Matters for Your Dairy Herd
A headgate is more than just a piece of hardware for restraining a goat. It’s the primary point of physical interaction you have with your does every single day. A well-designed headgate communicates safety and routine, while a poorly designed one teaches fear and resistance. That stress directly impacts milk let-down, as a tense doe won’t give you all her milk.
This isn’t just about one milking. A doe that dreads the headgate is a doe that’s chronically stressed, which can lead to health issues and a shorter productive life. The goal is a headgate that closes securely and quietly, making the milking stand a place she wants to go. It transforms the experience from a struggle into a partnership, which is exactly what small-scale dairying should be about.
Sydell Deluxe Headgate: A Top Choice for Safety
The Sydell Deluxe is a favorite for a good reason: its design prioritizes the goat’s comfort and safety. Instead of a simple scissor-action close, it features a V-shape that narrows as it locks. This provides a gentle but firm hold on the doe’s neck without any risk of choking, which is a major concern with simpler designs.
What makes it so practical is its incredible adjustability. You can fine-tune the locking width to fit everyone from a small first-freshener to your biggest, most mature doe. This is crucial if you have a mixed herd of different sizes or ages. The positive-locking mechanism is solid, meaning you don’t have to worry about a strong doe pushing her way out mid-milking.
Weaver Self-Catch Headgate: Simple and Reliable
If you value straightforward, bombproof equipment, the Weaver Self-Catch is your answer. There are no ropes to pull or levers to flip. The goat does the work for you by pushing her head through the opening to reach the grain, which triggers the gate to swing shut behind her neck.
The beauty of this system is its simplicity. Fewer moving parts mean fewer things to break, rust, or jam up over years of use. The main tradeoff is that it requires a confident goat; a timid doe might be hesitant to push through it at first. But once they learn the routine, it becomes an incredibly efficient, hands-free system that speeds up your milking line.
Premier 1 Headgate: A Versatile, Portable Pick
Not everyone has a permanent, dedicated milking parlor. The Premier 1 headgate shines for its portability and adaptability. It’s typically lighter than its all-steel counterparts and is designed to be easily mounted on a simple milking stand, a sturdy fence panel, or even the side of a small barn.
This makes it an excellent choice for homesteaders who need a multi-purpose tool. You can use it for milking in the morning and then easily move it to a different location for hoof trimming or health checks in the afternoon. While it may not have the sheer heft of a Tarter, its flexibility is a massive advantage for small farms where every piece of equipment needs to earn its keep in more than one way.
Lakeline LLC Headgate: Built for Horned Breeds
Milking a horned doe presents a unique challenge that many standard headgates simply can’t handle. Trying to force horns through a narrow opening is dangerous for the goat and frustrating for you. Lakeline LLC specifically addresses this problem with headgates designed with a wider, taller opening and a safe closing mechanism.
The design allows a doe to comfortably put her head through without catching or damaging her horns. This is non-negotiable if you keep breeds that are traditionally horned, like Spanish goats or certain lines of Nigerian Dwarfs. Choosing a headgate made for horns isn’t a luxury; it’s a fundamental safety requirement for keeping these animals calm and preventing injury.
Homesteader’s Supply Co. Gate: Quiet Operation
Never underestimate the impact of noise on a prey animal. A loud, metallic CLANG every time the headgate closes can be incredibly jarring for a sensitive doe. Homesteader’s Supply Co. often offers headgates that prioritize quiet operation, sometimes incorporating poly materials or rubber bumpers to dampen sound.
This small detail makes a huge difference in the atmosphere of your milking parlor. A quiet-closing gate helps keep a doe relaxed, which is especially important for first-fresheners who are already nervous about the new routine. It reinforces the idea that the milking stand is a calm, safe place, which is exactly the message you want to send.
Tarter Goat Headgate: A Durable, Long-Lasting Buy
When you want to buy it once and be done, you look at a Tarter. These headgates are built like tanks, typically constructed from heavy-gauge steel with a corrosion-resistant finish. This is the kind of equipment you install permanently and expect to hand down to the next generation.
This isn’t the right choice for someone needing portability, but for a dedicated milking setup, its durability is unmatched. It can easily withstand the pressure of a large, pushy doe without flexing or failing. The initial cost might be higher, but you’re paying for peace of mind and a piece of equipment that will reliably serve your herd for decades.
Matching the Headgate to Your Herd and Milking Stand
There is no single "best" headgate for every farm. The right choice is a careful balance of your specific needs. Before you buy, ask yourself a few key questions:
- Horned or Dehorned? This is the most critical question. A wrong choice here is unsafe.
- What Size Are My Goats? A headgate needs to be adjustable if you have a mix of breeds or ages.
- Is My Setup Permanent or Portable? Your milking stand and location will dictate whether you need a heavy-duty or lightweight gate.
- What’s My Priority? Is it quiet operation for skittish does, or simple, self-catching speed for an efficient routine?
Think of the headgate as an investment in your herd’s well-being and your own sanity. A doe who walks calmly onto the stand and secures herself makes the entire chore faster, safer, and more pleasant. By matching the headgate’s features to your herd’s unique character, you’re not just buying equipment—you’re building a foundation for a better milking partnership.
Ultimately, the best headgate is the one your does willingly use every day. By prioritizing safety, quiet operation, and a proper fit for your animals, you invest in a calmer herd and a more rewarding homesteading experience. It’s a small piece of equipment that pays huge dividends in milk, and in peace.
