6 Best Pasture Seeders For Overseeding Existing Grasslands Old Farmers Use
Revitalize aging grasslands with farmer-approved tools. We review the 6 best pasture seeders for overseeding, from drills to broadcasters, for lush growth.
You walk your pasture in late summer and see the signs. Bare patches are widening where the horses were a little too hard on it, and the stand of fescue looks thin and tired. You know that simply throwing down some seed is mostly a donation to the local bird population, but buying a new piece of equipment feels like a huge leap. Choosing the right seeder is one of the most important decisions for maintaining a productive and resilient grassland, and the old-timers knew which tools got the job done without breaking the bank or the soil.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Why Overseeding Your Pasture Is So Important
Overseeding is the simple act of adding new grass seed to your existing pasture without first tilling everything under. Think of it as reinforcing your current stand, not starting over from scratch. The goal is to fill in bare spots, increase forage density, and introduce new, improved grass or legume varieties.
This isn’t just about making the field look greener. A thick, healthy pasture outcompetes weeds, reducing your need for herbicides. Introducing legumes like clover can fix nitrogen in the soil, naturally fertilizing your grasses and boosting protein content for your livestock. It’s a proactive strategy that builds soil health, improves grazing quality, and ultimately saves you money on feed and inputs.
For a hobby farmer, this is crucial. You don’t have time for a full pasture renovation every few years. Consistent overseeding maintains the resource you already have, making it more resilient to drought, overgrazing, and other stresses. It’s the difference between a pasture that slowly degrades and one that improves year after year.
Brillion Sure-Stand: The Gold Standard Seeder
When you talk to farmers who have been at this for decades, one name comes up again and again: Brillion. The Brillion Sure-Stand is a cultipacker seeder, and its design is brilliantly simple and effective. It’s not a drill, and that’s a key distinction.
The process is straightforward. A set of front rollers pulverizes soil clumps and creates a firm, dimpled seedbed. The seed is then dropped evenly onto this prepared surface. A second set of rollers follows behind, offset from the first, to gently press the seed into the soil, ensuring perfect seed-to-soil contact. This contact is everything when it comes to germination.
The main tradeoff with a Brillion is that it requires a prepared seedbed. It’s not a no-till tool. You typically need to lightly disc or harrow the pasture first to expose some soil, which means an extra pass with another implement. They are also heavy and can be pricey, even on the used market, but their build quality is legendary. For establishing a flawless stand of alfalfa or a new grass mix, many still consider it the best tool for the job.
Great Plains 3P606NT for No-Till Precision
For those who want to preserve their soil structure and avoid tillage, a no-till drill is the answer, and the Great Plains 3P606NT is a modern classic for smaller operations. This isn’t about just dropping seed on top; it’s about surgically placing it right where it needs to grow with minimal disturbance.
This type of drill works in a sequence. First, a sharp coulter disc slices through the existing sod and thatch, opening a narrow slit in the soil. Behind the coulter, a double-disc opener widens the slit just enough to drop the seed at a precise, controlled depth. Finally, a press wheel closes the furrow, firmly packing soil around the seed. This process protects soil moisture, prevents weed seeds from germinating, and gives your new seed a huge competitive advantage.
The Great Plains 3-point hitch model is designed for compact and utility tractors, making it accessible to many hobby farmers. It’s a significant investment, no doubt. But if your primary goal is to improve existing pastures year after year while building soil organic matter, the efficiency and high germination rates of a no-till drill are hard to beat. It’s a tool for serious, long-term pasture management.
Plotmaster Hunter 400 for ATV Overseeding
Not every hobby farmer has a tractor, or the space to maneuver one. For those with an ATV or UTV, an all-in-one system like the Plotmaster is a game-changer. It combines several functions into one compact, pull-behind unit, making it perfect for renovating smaller paddocks, seeding food plots, or accessing remote areas.
The Plotmaster typically features a set of discs in the front that can be adjusted to lightly break up the soil and cut through thatch. Following the discs is a seed hopper that drops the seed, and at the rear, a drag or small cultipacker helps cover it. This one-pass system saves an incredible amount of time and effort. It provides a level of soil preparation and seed coverage that you simply can’t get from a simple broadcast spreader.
While it’s not as precise as a heavy-duty no-till drill, the Plotmaster is a massive leap in effectiveness over broadcasting alone. It’s the ideal middle ground, offering a practical solution for landowners working with a few acres. It empowers you to do proper seeding work without needing a 40-horsepower tractor to get it done.
Earthway 2150: A Reliable Broadcast Spreader
Sometimes, the simplest tool is the right one for the situation. The Earthway 2150 is a classic push-style broadcast spreader, and while it seems basic, it has its place. For very small areas or for frost seeding clover in late winter, it’s an affordable and effective option.
The concept is as simple as it gets: you fill the hopper and walk, and a spinning impeller flings the seed across a wide path. The key to making this work for pasture overseeding is understanding its primary limitation: it does nothing to ensure seed-to-soil contact. You are entirely dependent on timing and follow-up.
To get decent results, you must combine broadcasting with another step. You can broadcast seed just before a gentle rain is expected, which can help wash the seed into the soil. A better method is to first graze the pasture down hard or run a chain harrow over it to expose some soil, then broadcast the seed, and follow up with another pass of the harrow to lightly cover it. Germination rates will be lower than with a drill, so you’ll need to increase your seeding rate to compensate.
Tye Pasture Pleaser: A Time-Tested Drill
If you’re scouring the used equipment market for a no-till drill, you’re bound to come across a Tye Pasture Pleaser. These things are built like tanks and have been staples on farms for decades. They offer the core benefits of no-till seeding—slicing through sod and placing seed directly in the soil—in a rugged, often more affordable package.
Like other drills, the Pasture Pleaser uses a series of coulters, openers, and press wheels. A key feature on many older Tye drills is the inclusion of multiple seed boxes. This is incredibly useful. You can put large, fluffy grass seeds (like brome or orchardgrass) in one box and small, dense seeds (like clover or alfalfa) in another. This prevents the seeds from separating due to vibration, ensuring you get an even distribution of your entire mix across the field.
Finding a used Tye drill can be a fantastic way to get into precision seeding without the high cost of a new machine. They are mechanically simple, making them relatively easy to work on. Just be sure to check the condition of the coulters and disc openers, as these are the critical wear parts that do the real work.
Kasco Versa-Drill for Compact Tractor Use
Many no-till drills are designed for large agricultural tractors, leaving compact tractor owners with few options. Kasco saw this gap and created the Versa-Drill, a heavy-duty seeder specifically engineered for the horsepower and lift capacity of smaller machines. It’s a professional-grade tool scaled for the hobby farm.
The Versa-Drill operates on the same principles as its larger cousins, using coulter blades to cut through turf and disc openers to ensure accurate seed placement. Because it’s designed for compact tractors, it’s more maneuverable in tight spaces and on varied terrain. It’s a true no-till drill, meaning you can seed directly into existing grass or even into a terminated cover crop without any prior tillage.
This seeder represents a perfect balance for the serious hobby farmer. It provides the precision and soil-saving benefits of a no-till system in a package that matches the equipment you already own. It’s an investment, but one that pays dividends in higher germination rates, healthier pastures, and less time spent on fieldwork.
Key Seeder Features: Tines, Discs, and Hoppers
When comparing seeders, it’s easy to get lost in brand names. What really matters is understanding the core components and how they work together. Focusing on these three features will help you choose the right tool for your goals.
Tines, Discs, and Coulters: These are the tools that prepare the soil. Tines, like on a chain harrow, simply scratch the surface. They are good for breaking up manure and lightly covering broadcast seed. Discs and coulters, however, are sharp, rolling blades that slice into the ground. A coulter is essential for any true no-till overseeding, as it’s the only thing that can effectively cut through thick sod to create a furrow for the seed.
Seed Hoppers: The hopper holds the seed. A simple broadcast spreader has one. Many drills, however, have multiple seed boxes. A main box is used for larger grass seeds, while a smaller "small seed" or "legume" box is used for tiny, dense seeds like clover. This is critical because it prevents the small seeds from settling to the bottom, ensuring your mix is planted evenly.
- Press Wheels and Cultipackers: This is arguably the most important part of any seeder. After the seed is dropped, something must press it firmly into the soil. On a drill, this is the job of the press wheels that follow each opener. On a Brillion, it’s the rear set of rollers. Without this step, germination rates plummet. Good seed-to-soil contact is non-negotiable for success.
Ultimately, the best seeder is the one that fits your land, your equipment, and your management style. Whether it’s a simple broadcast spreader paired with a drag harrow or a sophisticated no-till drill, the goal remains the same: getting the seed in good contact with the soil. Investing in the right tool isn’t just about planting grass; it’s about investing in the long-term health and productivity of your small farm.
