7 Best Horse Fly Repellents For Sensitive Skin Horses Old-Timers Swear By
Protect sensitive-skinned horses with 7 time-tested fly repellents. This guide explores the gentle, classic formulas that old-timers swear by for relief.
There’s nothing more frustrating than watching a horse with sensitive skin get eaten alive by flies. You spray them down with the "extra strength" stuff, and an hour later they’re covered in welts—not from the bites, but from the repellent itself. For these horses, the cure can feel worse than the disease, leaving you stuck between a rock and a hard place. Finding a solution that repels pests without causing hives, hair loss, or irritation is one of the most common summer challenges on any small farm.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Why Old-Timer Remedies Work for Sensitive Skin
Old-timer approaches, whether they’re commercial formulas that have stood the test of time or simple homemade rinses, often work because they were developed with simpler ingredients. They pre-date the complex synthetic chemicals that can be harsh on a horse’s system. The focus was less on creating a long-lasting chemical shield and more on making the horse an unappealing target for pests.
This philosophy often means the ingredients do double duty. Many traditional recipes include things like aloe, lanolin, or vinegar, which not only deter flies but also actively soothe the skin and condition the coat. They work with the horse’s body, not just on it.
The main tradeoff is longevity. A homemade vinegar rinse won’t last through a sweaty afternoon workout the way a heavy-duty chemical spray will. But for a sensitive-skinned horse, the need for more frequent, gentle application is a small price to pay for a comfortable, welt-free summer. It’s about management, not just a one-and-done solution.
Absorbine UltraShield Green: A Gentle Classic
This is the bottle you grab when you need something that works right now but don’t want to risk an allergic reaction. Absorbine UltraShield Green has become a modern classic for a reason. It’s a commercial, ready-to-use spray that ditches the harsh stuff.
Its power comes from a blend of essential oils like geraniol and cedarwood. Most importantly, it’s free of pyrethrins and pyrethroids, the common culprits behind skin reactions in sensitive horses. The water-based formula is non-greasy, so it doesn’t attract dust and grime to an already irritated coat.
Think of this as the reliable middle ground. It’s more potent and longer-lasting than a simple homemade spray but far gentler than the heavy-duty chemical options. For a horse with mild to moderate skin sensitivity, this is often the perfect balance of effectiveness and safety.
Espree Aloe Herbal Spray for Soothing Protection
If your horse’s skin is already red, itchy, or irritated, the Espree Aloe Herbal spray is a fantastic choice. Its primary purpose feels like it’s to soothe the skin first and repel flies second. The high concentration of aloe vera helps calm inflammation on contact.
The repellency comes from a gentle blend of citronella, cedarwood, and eucalyptus oils. It’s not the strongest repellent on the shelf, so it might not be enough for a horse living in a swampy, high-fly-pressure area. But for general pasture use or for horses whose skin is too raw for anything else, it provides welcome relief.
This product also doubles as an excellent grooming spray and coat conditioner. You can use it after a bath or for daily touch-ups to add shine and moisture. For the hobby farmer, a multi-purpose product that’s gentle and effective is a huge win.
The Homesteader’s Apple Cider Vinegar Rinse
This is as old-school as it gets, and it works. A simple mixture of raw apple cider vinegar (ACV) and water, usually in a 1-to-1 or 1-to-2 ratio, makes an excellent rinse or spray. The key is using raw, unpasteurized ACV that contains "the mother," as it’s packed with beneficial enzymes for skin health.
The acidity of the vinegar makes the horse’s coat less appealing to flies and gnats. It doesn’t kill them, it just encourages them to find a more palatable target. As a bonus, it’s fantastic for the skin, helping to balance pH, soothe itchiness, and give the coat a brilliant shine.
Be realistic about its limitations. This is not a long-lasting solution. Sweat and rain will wash it away quickly. The best way to use it is as a final rinse after hosing a horse off or sponged on right before a short turnout. It’s cheap, safe, and effective for short-term relief.
Ecovet Fly Repellent: A Unique Fatty-Acid Shield
Ecovet takes a completely different approach to fly control. Instead of using pesticides or fragrant essential oils, it uses a proprietary blend of food-grade fatty acids. It works by creating a zone of scent confusion around the horse, effectively making them "invisible" to a fly’s sensory receptors.
This is a game-changer for horses who react to everything, because the ingredients are so unique. It doesn’t fit into the typical "natural" or "chemical" categories. It’s a third path that can work when nothing else does.
There are two things to know before you buy. First, the smell is very distinct—some describe it as smoky or like bacon. You might love it or hate it. Second, it can leave the coat feeling a bit oily, so it’s not ideal right before a show. But for a pasture horse suffering from severe sweet itch or fly allergies, Ecovet can be a miracle worker.
Kensington SureFit Sheet: A Non-Chemical Barrier
Sometimes the best repellent isn’t a liquid at all. For the truly hypersensitive horse, a physical barrier is the only guaranteed way to prevent both bites and skin reactions. A high-quality fly sheet, like one from Kensington’s SureFit line, is an investment in your horse’s comfort.
Look for a sheet that offers more than just a mesh covering. Key features for sensitive skin include:
- Breathable material to prevent overheating and sweat buildup.
- UV protection to shield sun-bleached coats and pink skin.
- A contoured fit with shoulder gussets and a shaped wither to prevent rubbing and sores.
A good sheet isn’t cheap, but it can save you money and stress in the long run. You’ll spend less on sprays, and your horse will be spared the constant misery of stomping, tail-swishing, and hiding in the run-in shed all day. It’s a proactive management tool, not just a piece of apparel.
Fiebing’s Flys-Off Salve for Targeted Relief
Sprays and sheets are great for broad coverage, but they can’t protect every nook and cranny. That’s where a good salve comes in. Fiebing’s Flys-Off is a thick, ointment-like product designed for targeted application on sensitive areas.
It’s perfect for places where flies congregate and where you don’t want to spray chemicals, like around the eyes, inside the ears, on the muzzle, and along the sheath or udder. The thick, greasy consistency creates a physical barrier that stays put far longer than a spray, even on a sweaty horse.
Think of this as a crucial part of a multi-pronged defense. You might use a gentle body spray or a fly sheet for overall protection, then apply this salve to the delicate spots for complete coverage. A single tub will last a long time, making it a cost-effective addition to your grooming kit.
Farnam Repel-X Lotion: A Time-Tested Formula
For the horse that despises the sound and feel of a spray bottle, a lotion is the answer. Farnam’s Repel-X has been around for decades, and the lotion version offers a quiet, gentle way to apply repellent. You simply wipe it on with a soft cloth.
This method gives you total control. You can apply it exactly where it’s needed while easily avoiding cuts, scrapes, or other irritated patches of skin. The lanolin in the formula also helps condition the coat and keeps the product adhered for longer-lasting protection.
While it contains pyrethrins, applying it as a lotion rather than an aerosolized spray can reduce the risk of respiratory or skin irritation for some horses. It’s an old-fashioned method that remains incredibly practical, especially for face and leg application on a spooky horse.
Ultimately, protecting a sensitive-skinned horse is about building a system, not finding a single magic bullet. The best approach often involves combining two or more of these methods—a fly sheet for turnout, a gentle spray for riding, and a salve for the face. Pay close attention to your horse and their environment, and don’t be afraid to experiment until you find the combination that brings them peaceful, itch-free relief.
