6 Best Grub Mattocks For Removing Tree Roots Old-Timers Swear By
Learn which 6 grub mattocks old-timers trust for tough tree root removal. Our guide covers the top picks for leverage, blade design, and lasting durability.
You’ve found the perfect spot for a new garden bed, but ten minutes in, your shovel hits something solid with a dull thud. It’s not a rock; it’s a thick, stubborn tree root snaking right through your future tomato patch. This is where you separate the pros from the frustrated beginners, and it all comes down to having the right tool for the job.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!
Why a Grub Mattock Beats an Axe for Roots
Reaching for an axe to deal with underground roots is a classic mistake. An axe is designed for chopping wood above ground, where you have a clear swing. Below ground, it will bounce off compacted dirt, get wedged, and dull its blade on rocks and grit.
A grub mattock, on the other hand, is a purpose-built excavation tool. It combines the physics of a hoe and an axe into one powerful head. The wide, hoe-like blade (the adze) is for digging, scraping, and prying soil away from the root. This step is critical; you can’t cut what you can’t see.
Once the root is exposed, the other side of the head—either a vertical axe blade (a cutter mattock) or a sharp pick (a pick mattock)—can be used to deliver a focused, powerful blow. The weight of the head and the leverage of the handle drive the cutting edge through the root with far more efficiency and safety than a flailing axe. It’s a surgical tool for a dirty job.
Council Tool Grub Hoe: Forged for Tough Clay
When you’re dealing with soil that feels more like concrete than dirt, you need a tool that won’t give up. The Council Tool Grub Hoe is that tool. Forged from high-carbon U.S. steel and fitted with a stout American hickory handle, it’s built on a century of tradition for one purpose: breaking new ground.
This isn’t a lightweight, fancy tool. It’s a heavy, brutish instrument designed to bite into compacted, rocky, and clay-ridden soil without bending, chipping, or complaining. The head weight does much of the work for you, sinking deep with each swing. It’s the kind of tool you buy once and pass down to the next generation.
The trade-off for this raw power is weight and a lack of modern comforts. There’s no shock absorption, just the natural give of the hickory handle. But for those who believe in the simple effectiveness of a well-made, heavy-duty tool, the Council Tool is the undisputed old-timer’s standard.
Fiskars Pro IsoCore Mattock: Reduces Shock
Swinging a mattock for an hour can leave your hands, elbows, and shoulders buzzing. Fiskars tackled this problem head-on with their IsoCore Shock Control System, which they claim reduces strike shock and vibration by up to 50%. For anyone with aging joints or a long day of clearing ahead, this feature is a game-changer.
The design is a departure from tradition. A forged steel head is riveted onto a composite handle that will never rot or splinter like wood. This makes it exceptionally durable in wet, muddy conditions where a wooden handle might loosen over time. The handle is also shaped ergonomically, providing a more secure grip.
Some traditionalists might miss the feel and balance of a hickory handle, but the practical benefits are hard to argue with. If you prioritize personal comfort and long-term joint health over classic design, the Fiskars mattock is an intelligent choice. It proves that modern engineering can improve even the most basic of farm tools.
Truper Cutter Mattock: A Versatile Workhorse
Not every job requires the most expensive, specialized tool. Sometimes you just need a reliable workhorse that gets the job done without breaking the bank. The Truper Cutter Mattock is exactly that—a versatile and affordable tool that’s perfect for the hobby farmer’s shed.
With a 5-pound head featuring both a cutting axe blade and a digging adze, it’s a true multi-purpose tool. You can use it to trench for irrigation lines, break up compacted soil in a new plot, and, of course, chop through stubborn roots. The fiberglass handle is a common feature at this price point, offering good durability and weather resistance.
Is it as tough as a Council Tool or as comfortable as a Fiskars? No, but it doesn’t need to be. It’s a fantastic value that provides more than enough power and durability for most tasks around a small farm. For someone buying their first mattock, the Truper is an excellent, low-risk starting point.
Bully Tools Grub Hoe: Unbeatable Durability
If your primary concern is breaking your tools, look no further than Bully Tools. Their entire brand is built around extreme, almost excessive, durability. The Bully Tools Grub Hoe is a prime example, featuring a heavy-gauge, all-steel construction that feels practically indestructible.
Unlike tools with a separate head and handle, many Bully Tools products are welded into a single, solid unit, eliminating the most common point of failure. Paired with a thick fiberglass handle, this is a tool you can pry with, slam against rocks, and leave out in the rain without a second thought. It’s pure, unapologetic utility.
This toughness comes with a significant amount of weight. It’s a heavy tool, and swinging it all day is a serious workout. But that weight also helps it blast through tough ground with authority. For clearing heavily rooted areas or prying out large rocks where other tools might fail, the sheer brute force of a Bully Tool is exactly what you need.
A.M. Leonard Mattock: Lighter but Powerful
Sometimes, brute force isn’t the answer. Accuracy, balance, and endurance often matter more, especially when working around existing plants or for extended periods. A.M. Leonard, a long-time supplier to landscaping and horticulture professionals, makes a mattock that perfectly balances power with user-friendliness.
Often featuring a slightly lighter head (around 4 pounds) and a well-shaped handle, the A.M. Leonard mattock is easier to control than its heavier counterparts. This allows for more precise swings, which is crucial when you’re trying to sever one root without damaging another. The build quality is professional-grade, designed to withstand daily use.
Don’t mistake "lighter" for "weaker." This tool has more than enough heft to slice through 2-3 inch roots with ease. It’s an ideal choice for someone who needs a serious tool but finds a 5- or 6-pound head to be fatiguing. It represents a smart compromise between raw power and sustainable, all-day performance.
Prohoe Rogue Hoe Mattock: A Farmer’s Favorite
The Rogue Hoe is a bit of a cult classic among small-scale farmers and serious gardeners, and for good reason. These tools are often crafted from recycled agricultural disc blades, a type of high-carbon steel that is incredibly tough and holds a wicked edge. This isn’t a blunt instrument; it’s a sharp cutting tool.
The design of a Rogue Hoe Mattock is focused on efficiency. The blade is often thinner and sharper than on a standard mattock, allowing it to slice through roots rather than bludgeoning them. This requires less effort per swing and results in cleaner cuts. The adze end is equally effective for cultivating and weeding.
Because of its unique construction, a Rogue Hoe often feels more agile and "alive" in your hands. It’s not the heaviest hitter on the list, but it might be the most effective cutter. For those who appreciate the elegance of a sharp, well-honed tool over sheer mass, the Rogue Hoe is in a class of its own.
Mattock Safety and Proper Root-Cutting Technique
A mattock is an incredibly effective tool, but its power demands respect. The single most important rule is to never swing a mattock towards your feet or shins. Always position yourself so your swing path is parallel to your body, striking the ground in front of you or to your side. Sturdy leather boots are not optional.
Proper technique makes the work safer and easier. Don’t just start hacking away at the ground.
- Expose the Target: Use the wide adze blade to pull and scrape soil away from the root. You need a clear view and a clean space to swing.
- Take a Stable Stance: Plant your feet firmly, shoulder-width apart. A stable base is essential for a powerful, controlled swing.
- Strike at an Angle: Hit the root at a 45-degree angle, not straight down. This allows the axe blade to bite in and sever the fibers, rather than just bouncing off.
- Use Your Body, Not Just Your Arms: The power should come from your core and legs, letting the weight of the tool head do the work. An arm-only swing is tiring and less effective.
Remember that roots are often under tension. When you cut one, it can spring back unexpectedly. Always wear eye protection to guard against flying dirt, rocks, and wood chips. Working smart is just as important as working hard.
Choosing the right grub mattock comes down to your soil, your body, and your philosophy on tools. Whether you opt for a traditional forged head or a modern shock-absorbing design, the right mattock will transform one of the toughest farm chores into a deeply satisfying task. It’s the key to unlocking new ground and turning stubborn land into a productive plot.
