6 Making Salami From Scratch Guides Grandparents Used to Know

You can still picture it: a dark, cool cellar with thick, dusty salamis hanging from the rafters like sleeping bats. Your grandparents didn’t use fancy equipment or complicated recipes, yet their cured meats had a depth of flavor you just can’t find in a store. Reclaiming that tradition isn’t about nostalgia; it’s about understanding the simple, powerful principles of preservation they mastered.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Selecting the Right Pork and Fat for Flavor

The final salami is decided the moment you choose your meat. Supermarket pork, bred for leanness, simply won’t do. You need pork from a more mature animal, one that has had time to develop intramuscular fat and deep flavor, which is why heritage breeds like Berkshire or Mangalitsa are so prized for this work.

The fat is just as important, if not more so. You are looking for hard back fat, the firm, white layer from along the pig’s back. It dices cleanly and won’t smear during grinding, which is crucial for the salami’s final texture. Soft belly fat or leaf lard will turn to a greasy paste, ruining the particle definition that separates great salami from a mediocre sausage.

Your target ratio is the foundation of the entire project. Most traditional recipes call for about 75% lean meat to 25% hard fat by weight. Leaning too heavily on the meat will create a dry, tough final product, while too much fat can lead to a greasy texture and curing problems. Get this ratio right, and you’ve won half the battle before you even start grinding.

Mastering the Coarse Grind for Perfect Texture

Texture is the silent partner to flavor in any great salami. The characteristic chew and clear separation between fat and lean meat comes from a coarse grind. A fine grind, like one for emulsified sausages, creates a uniform, pasty texture that is entirely wrong for a dried, cured product.

The single most important rule here is to keep everything ice cold. The meat, the fat, and all the metal parts of your grinder should be chilled in the freezer until they are stiff. Warm fat smears, coating the lean meat and preventing proper drying and bonding. This smearing is the number one cause of failed texture in homemade salami.

For the best results, cube your meat and fat separately, then spread them on a sheet pan and partially freeze them for about 30-45 minutes. Grind the lean and fat through a coarse plate (8mm to 10mm is a good starting point), working quickly to prevent everything from warming up. This simple step ensures you get the distinct, jewel-like flecks of fat that are the hallmark of a well-made salami.

Balancing Salt, Spices, and Wine for the Cure

This is where the science of preservation meets the art of flavor. Salt is not just for taste; it’s the primary agent that draws out moisture and makes the meat inhospitable to spoilage bacteria. You must measure it by weight, not volume. A standard starting point is 2.5% to 3% of the total meat and fat weight. A digital kitchen scale is non-negotiable here.

Along with regular salt, you need a curing salt containing sodium nitrite and nitrate, often sold as Prague Powder #2 or Instacure #2. This is your insurance policy against botulism, a deadly risk in any anaerobic (oxygen-free) environment like a curing sausage. Follow the usage rates on the package precisely; a tiny amount is required, but its role is absolutely critical for safety.

Spices should be simple and high-quality. Toasted and freshly ground black pepper, a bit of fresh garlic, and perhaps some fennel seed are classic choices. A dry red wine is also a traditional addition, not just for flavor but because its acidity helps lower the pH, giving the beneficial bacteria a head start in the fermentation process.

The Slow Ferment in a Cool, Dark Place

Before salami can dry, it must first ferment. This is a controlled souring process where beneficial bacteria (either from an added starter culture or the environment) consume sugars and produce lactic acid. This acid drops the meat’s pH, creating the characteristic tangy flavor and adding another layer of protection against spoilage microbes.

The ideal environment for this short but vital phase is warmer and more humid than the final drying chamber. You’re aiming for a temperature around 70-75°F (21-24°C) with high humidity for about 24 to 72 hours. For a small-scale setup, this can be as simple as hanging the freshly stuffed sausages in a small, enclosed space like a turned-off oven with a pan of hot water placed at the bottom to create humidity.

You’ll know the fermentation is working when the salami "blooms" with a deeper red color and develops a faint, pleasant tangy aroma. It will also feel slightly firmer to the touch. This step kickstarts the entire preservation process and is essential for both safety and flavor development.

The Proper Way to Prepare and Stuff Casings

The casing is more than just a wrapper; it’s a semi-permeable membrane that regulates how the salami loses moisture during the long drying phase. Your choice of casing has a real impact on the final product.

• Natural Casings: Hog or beef casings are traditional. They breathe well and shrink with the meat, but they can be irregular in size and require careful preparation.
• Collagen Casings: These are uniform, easy to use, and a great choice for beginners. They are edible and perform reliably.

If you’re using natural casings, they must be thoroughly rinsed of salt and soaked in warm water for at least an hour, or even overnight in the fridge. This makes them pliable and elastic. Before stuffing, run water through them one last time to ensure they are clean and open.

When stuffing, the goal is to create a tightly packed sausage with zero air pockets. Air pockets are where bad mold can grow and spoilage can begin. Use a dedicated sausage stuffer for the best results, packing the meat firmly. After tying off the ends, inspect the salami closely and use a sterilized pin or needle to prick any visible air bubbles through the casing.

Hanging to Dry: The Ideal Cellar Conditions

The long, slow drying period is where the magic truly happens. The ideal environment mimics an old-world cellar: cool, dark, and humid. The target numbers are a temperature of 55-60°F (12-15°C) and a relative humidity of 70-75%. Consistency is key.

Most of us don’t have a perfect stone cellar, but we can create a functional equivalent. An old refrigerator or chest freezer hooked up to an external temperature and humidity controller is a popular and effective solution. A small humidifier and dehumidifier inside, managed by the controller, will maintain the precise conditions needed for a slow, even cure.

The balance of temperature and humidity is a delicate dance.

• Too Dry: The outside of the casing will dry too quickly, forming a hard, impenetrable shell. This is called "case hardening," and it traps moisture inside, leading to spoilage from the center out.
• Too Humid: You’ll invite the wrong kinds of mold—green, black, or fuzzy—and the salami may never dry properly, leading to a mushy texture.

Judging Readiness by Weight, Firmness, and Mold

Time is only a rough guide; salami is ready when it tells you it is. The most reliable indicator of doneness is weight loss. Before you hang your salami to dry, you must weigh it and record that "green weight." The salami is fully cured when it has lost between 30% and 40% of its original weight.

Firmness is your next clue. Gently squeeze the salami. It should feel firm throughout, with no soft or squishy spots, especially in the very center. This uniform firmness indicates that it has dried evenly. This is a skill that develops with experience, so trust your scale first and your hands second.

Finally, learn to read the mold. A dusting of fine, white, powdery mold (a type of Penicillium) is not only normal but beneficial. It helps regulate drying and can even contribute to the flavor. However, be vigilant for any splotches of green, blue, black, or fuzzy-looking mold. These are bad actors and should be wiped away immediately with a cloth dipped in vinegar.

Storing Cured Salami for Year-Round Enjoyment

Once your salami has reached its target weight loss, the work isn’t quite done. Proper storage ensures you can enjoy the fruits of your labor for months to come. The primary goal is to halt or dramatically slow the drying process so it doesn’t become as hard as a rock.

Vacuum sealing is the most effective method for long-term preservation. By removing the air, you stop moisture loss and lock in the texture and flavor at its peak. A vacuum-sealed salami will keep for many months in the refrigerator.

For shorter-term storage or if you plan to eat it within a few weeks, simply wrap the salami in butcher paper. This allows it to breathe slightly without drying out too quickly. Store it in the least humid part of your refrigerator, like a vegetable drawer. Once you cut into a salami, the exposed face will dry out, so it’s best to slice only what you need and press plastic wrap against the cut end before re-wrapping.

Making salami this way is a slow dance with time, temperature, and biology. It’s a process of observation and patience, far removed from the instant gratification of modern cooking. But when you slice into that first piece, you’re not just tasting pork and spices—you’re tasting a tradition of self-sufficiency that is well worth preserving.