6 Goat Milk Yogurts From A2/A2 Herds That Preserve Traditions

You’ve probably seen "A2" popping up on milk cartons, but when it comes to goat milk, the story is a little different. Unlike cow’s milk, which can have A1 or A2 beta-casein proteins, goat milk is naturally A2/A2, just as it has been for millennia. Choosing a yogurt from an A2/A2 goat herd isn’t about a new trend; it’s about connecting with a food that’s fundamentally unchanged and supporting farms that honor that heritage.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

The Heritage of A2/A2 Goat Milk Yogurt

The whole A1 vs. A2 conversation boils down to a single protein: beta-casein. The A2 version is the original, ancient form found in heritage breeds of cows, sheep, and all goats. The A1 protein is a relatively recent genetic mutation that appeared in some European cattle breeds. For many people, the A1 protein is harder to digest, leading to discomfort they might mistake for lactose intolerance.

Goat milk sidesteps this issue entirely. It is naturally and exclusively A2/A2. This is a key reason why so many people who struggle with cow’s milk find goat milk products to be a gentle, nourishing alternative. It’s not a modern invention; it’s the original blueprint.

When you buy yogurt from a farm that emphasizes its A2/A2 herd, you’re not just buying a digestive aid. You are supporting a system that values the inherent qualities of the animal. These producers aren’t trying to engineer a better product; they are focused on preserving the integrity of the milk through careful husbandry, diet, and traditional processing. It’s a commitment to the animal’s natural state.

Redwood Hill Farm: Cream-Top Plain Goat Yogurt

Redwood Hill Farm is a name many recognize, and for good reason. Their cream-top plain yogurt is a testament to letting simple, high-quality ingredients speak for themselves. The "cream-top" isn’t a gimmick; it’s a sign of minimal processing. The yogurt isn’t homogenized, so the rich cream naturally rises to the surface, just like it would in a farmhouse kitchen.

This yogurt has a classic, assertive tang that stands up well in savory dishes. Think of it as your go-to for making a traditional tzatziki that won’t get watery or for adding a creamy, acidic balance to a hearty stew. The texture is luscious and full-bodied without being overly thick, making it incredibly versatile.

What you’re getting here is consistency and a deep respect for the craft. Redwood Hill has been at this for a long time, focusing on humane animal care and organic practices. Their yogurt is a reliable, accessible way to experience the pure, unadulterated flavor of traditional goat milk.

Little Hillstead: Small-Batch European Style

Little Hillstead represents the other end of the spectrum: the hyper-local, small-batch artisan. Their European-style yogurt is often thinner than what you find in most American grocery stores. It’s closer to a traditional cultured milk product, with a delicate tang and a silky, pourable consistency.

The magic of a small-batch yogurt like this is its connection to the land. The flavor can subtly shift with the seasons, reflecting changes in the goats’ pasture. This isn’t a flaw; it’s a feature. It’s a direct taste of the farm’s terroir, a concept we usually reserve for wine but that absolutely applies to milk.

Because it’s less processed and not thickened with additives, this style is perfect for drinking straight, pouring over granola, or using as a base for smoothies. It’s a simple, elegant expression of goat milk, where the culturing process enhances the milk’s natural character rather than transforming it into something else entirely. Finding it might take a trip to a farmers market or a specialty shop, but the effort is rewarded.

Old World Dairy: Probiotic-Rich Greek Yogurt

When you need thickness and protein, a true Greek yogurt is the answer. Old World Dairy focuses on exactly that, using traditional straining methods to create a product that is exceptionally dense and creamy. They don’t use thickeners like pectin or starches; the texture comes from removing liquid whey, which concentrates the protein and fat.

This process results in a yogurt that is rich enough to feel like a dessert but packed with enough protein to be a meal. The flavor is less sharp than some other goat yogurts, with a mellow, cheesy note that comes from the concentration process. It’s a fantastic substitute for sour cream or crème fraîche on tacos or baked potatoes.

Beyond texture, Old World emphasizes the living cultures in their yogurt. By using a diverse blend of probiotics and allowing for a slow fermentation, they create a product that is not only delicious but also deeply beneficial for gut health. This is a functional food rooted in ancient preservation techniques.

Shepherd’s Song: Grass-Fed A2/A2 Kefir Yogurt

Shepherd’s Song bridges the gap between yogurt and kefir. While technically a kefir, its thicker, spoonable texture puts it in the yogurt category for many. Kefir is fermented with a wider array of bacteria and beneficial yeasts than standard yogurt, giving it a unique, slightly effervescent tang.

The "grass-fed" distinction is crucial here. Goats on pasture produce milk with a more complex flavor profile and a healthier balance of fatty acids, including more omega-3s. You can taste this difference—a subtle, earthy note that’s missing from milk produced by grain-fed animals. This is husbandry at its best, where the health of the land, the animal, and the consumer are all linked.

This kefir yogurt is a powerhouse of probiotics. If you’re looking to actively support your digestive system, the diversity of cultures in kefir is hard to beat. It’s an acquired taste for some, but its powerful health benefits and connection to pasture-based farming make it a compelling choice.

Belle Chèvre: French-Style Cultured Goat Milk

Belle Chèvre brings a touch of French sensibility to the yogurt aisle. Their cultured goat milk is what’s often called "pot-set" or "cup-set." The milk is poured into its final container with the cultures and allowed to ferment right there, resulting in a delicate, almost custard-like texture that is completely unstirred until you dip your spoon in.

The flavor is clean, bright, and tangy, with the characteristic citrusy notes of fresh chèvre. This isn’t a thick, heavy yogurt designed to weigh you down. It’s light and refreshing, perfect for a simple breakfast with a drizzle of honey and fresh berries, where its subtle flavor won’t be overwhelmed.

This style reflects the French tradition of treating goat milk with a light touch, honoring its natural elegance. It’s a reminder that not all yogurts need to be thick and dense. Sometimes, a more delicate approach yields the most delicious results.

St. Benoit Creamery: Vat-Cultured Full-Fat

St. Benoit Creamery is all about honoring the integrity of the main ingredient: full-fat milk. They reject the low-fat trend, understanding that fat is what carries flavor and provides a satisfying, creamy mouthfeel. Their commitment to tradition is also evident in their process and packaging.

"Vat-cultured" means they ferment the milk slowly in small vats before packaging, which allows for deep flavor development. More importantly, they often package their yogurt in reusable glass or ceramic pots. This isn’t just for aesthetics; it speaks to a philosophy of sustainability and quality, reducing plastic waste and protecting the flavor of the product.

The resulting yogurt is incredibly rich and satisfying. It’s the kind of food that feels both simple and luxurious. Choosing a full-fat, vat-cultured yogurt is a deliberate decision to prioritize flavor and traditional methods over calorie counts and modern shortcuts.

Choosing Your Traditional A2/A2 Goat Yogurt

With so many excellent options, the right choice depends entirely on what you’re looking for. There is no single "best" yogurt; there’s only the best yogurt for a specific purpose.

Think about your needs:

• For cooking and versatility: A classic, tangy cream-top like Redwood Hill Farm is a workhorse.
• For a high-protein meal: The strained Greek style from Old World Dairy offers the most density and staying power.
• For maximum probiotic diversity: The tangy, grass-fed kefir yogurt from Shepherd’s Song is unmatched.
• For a light, delicate breakfast: The French-style from Belle Chèvre or the pourable Little Hillstead are perfect.
• For a rich, decadent treat: The full-fat, vat-cultured yogurt from St. Benoit Creamery delivers pure, creamy satisfaction.

The best approach is to try several. Pay attention to the subtle differences in flavor and texture. You’ll start to notice the impact of the goats’ diet, the specific cultures used, and the fermentation style. Each one tells a story about the farm it came from.

Ultimately, choosing one of these yogurts is about more than just what’s for breakfast. It’s a vote for small-scale agriculture, humane animal husbandry, and the preservation of time-honored food traditions. By supporting these producers, you’re helping ensure that these authentic, nourishing foods remain available for generations to come.