7 Chicken Vs Duck Eggs For Sale That Old-Time Farmers Swear By

That sign at the end of your driveway says "Farm Fresh Eggs," but turning a few extra eggs into a reliable side hustle requires a plan. The breeds you choose are the foundation of that plan, determining your product, your market, and your daily chores. This isn’t just about chickens versus ducks; it’s about matching the right bird to your specific goals for profitability.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing Breeds for a Profitable Egg Business

Profitability in a small-scale egg business isn’t just about counting eggs at the end of the day. It’s about the cost to produce each of those eggs. Feed conversion is king here—how much feed does it take for a hen or duck to produce one dozen eggs? A highly efficient breed keeps your biggest expense in check.

The chicken versus duck debate comes down to your market and your setup. Chickens are the familiar, reliable standard, and their eggs are an easy sell to almost anyone. Ducks, on the other hand, offer a niche product that attracts foodies and bakers, often at a premium price. They are hardier, better foragers, and lay well through winter, but they require water and can make a muddy mess of a small run.

Ultimately, you’re not just choosing a bird; you’re choosing your customer. Are you aiming for volume sales to families who want a classic brown egg for breakfast? Or are you targeting a high-end market with specialty eggs for pastry chefs? Your flock should be a direct reflection of your business strategy.

Leghorn: The Ultimate White Egg Production Hen

When you need a staggering number of eggs for the lowest possible feed cost, the Leghorn is your bird. These are not pets; they are single-minded, egg-laying machines. A good Leghorn will lay 280-320 large white eggs a year, and they do it on less feed than almost any other breed.

Their temperament is flighty and nervous, which makes them less suited for a small backyard with kids, but perfect for a free-range setup where their foraging instincts shine. They are savvy survivors, adept at avoiding predators and finding their own food, which further cuts down on your feed bill. This efficiency is their core business advantage.

The main challenge with Leghorns is marketing. Some customers associate white eggs with industrial farms, so you have to sell them on freshness and quality. However, for supplying a local cafe or a buyer who just wants a lot of fresh, high-quality eggs without fuss, the Leghorn’s unmatched production volume makes them a smart financial choice.

Rhode Island Red: Dependable Brown Egg Layers

The Rhode Island Red is the classic, all-around workhorse of the farm flock. They are the definition of dependable, consistently laying 200-280 large brown eggs a year with very little drama. They are hardy birds that tolerate both heat and cold well, continuing to lay when other breeds might slow down.

Unlike the flighty Leghorn, RIRs have a calm and steady temperament. This makes them far easier to manage in a smaller space and a better fit for a multi-purpose farm. While developed as a dual-purpose breed, their modern strains are heavily selected for egg production, making them a top choice for a profitable brown egg business.

The market for farm-fresh brown eggs is always strong. It’s what most people picture when they think of buying eggs directly from a farm. The Rhode Island Red’s greatest asset is its reliability. You can build a business around the predictable, steady supply of quality brown eggs they provide week after week.

Ameraucana: Capitalizing on Colorful Blue Eggs

Blue eggs sell themselves. When a customer sees a carton of beautiful, sky-blue eggs at a farmers’ market, they stop and look. This novelty factor is a powerful marketing tool that allows you to command a premium price.

Choosing a blue-egg layer like an Ameraucana or even a hybrid Easter Egger is a strategic business decision. While they may lay slightly fewer eggs than a production red or white hen—typically around 180-200 per year—the higher price per dozen more than compensates. A mixed carton featuring blue, green, and brown eggs is one of the most effective products you can offer, creating instant visual appeal.

It’s important to understand the difference between true Ameraucanas, which breed true for blue eggs and have beards and muffs, and the more common Easter Eggers. Easter Eggers are mixed-breed chickens that carry the blue-egg gene and can lay a variety of green, blue, or even pinkish eggs. For a small farm stand, the colorful variety from Easter Eggers can be just as profitable and they are often hardier and easier to find.

Marans: The Premium Dark Chocolate Egg Niche

Marans are for the farmer who wants to sell a luxury product, not a commodity. These birds lay a stunningly deep, chocolate-brown egg that looks like a piece of art. This is not a volume game; it’s about creating a high-value niche.

These hens are generally calm and easy to handle, but they are not production powerhouses, laying around 150-200 eggs annually. The coveted dark color is also darkest at the beginning of their laying cycle and can lighten as the season progresses. Managing a flock of Marans is about cultivating quality over quantity.

Your customer for these eggs is a foodie, a home gourmet, or someone looking for a unique culinary gift. You sell Marans eggs by the half-dozen at a significant premium. The story is part of the product—the French heritage, the unique bloom, the rich-tasting yolk. It’s a specialized market, but for the right farmer, it can be the most profitable one.

Khaki Campbell: High-Volume Duck Egg Champion

If you want to get into duck eggs for production, the Khaki Campbell is your starting point. These ducks are the Leghorns of the waterfowl world, bred specifically for one thing: laying a massive number of eggs. A healthy Khaki can lay over 300 large, white-shelled eggs a year, often outproducing the best chickens.

Khakis are lightweight, active, and incredible foragers. They will tirelessly patrol your property for slugs, snails, and insects, turning pests into profits. This foraging ability can significantly reduce your feed costs. The tradeoff is their need for water—not a pond, but at least a kiddie pool they can splash in—and their tendency to create muddy areas.

The market for duck eggs centers on two main groups: bakers and people with chicken egg allergies. The higher fat and protein content in duck eggs creates richer, moister baked goods. Your job is to educate your customers on these benefits. Once a baker tries them in a cake or custard, they often become a loyal, repeat buyer.

Pekin Duck: Large, Rich Eggs for Baking Sales

The Pekin is the quintessential white farm duck, and while many raise them for meat, their eggs are a fantastic and often overlooked product. They don’t lay with the intensity of a Khaki Campbell, but they produce a consistently large, white-shelled egg that is perfect for a specific market.

Pekins are heavier and have a much calmer, more docile temperament than Khakis, making them easier to manage in a smaller space. Their egg production is respectable, often around 150-200 eggs per year. The key advantage is the consistent, extra-large size of those eggs, which is highly appealing to bakers who value uniformity for their recipes.

Focus your marketing on this strength. Don’t just sell "duck eggs"; sell "Jumbo Baking Eggs." A sign that reads "The Secret to Richer Cakes" will attract the right kind of customer. You are selling a solution, not just a product, and the Pekin’s large, rich egg is the perfect ingredient for that pitch.

Cayuga Duck: Novelty Dark Eggs for Top Dollar

Cayuga ducks offer a unique, high-end novelty product that can be the star of your farm stand. At the beginning of their laying season, they lay eggs that are coated in a stunning black or dark grey pigment. This is a showstopper that immediately justifies a top-dollar price.

This is a pure niche play. Cayugas are modest layers, producing 100-150 eggs a year, and the dramatic black color fades to grey, green, and eventually white as the season wears on. You aren’t selling volume; you are selling a rare and beautiful experience. Their calm nature and beautiful, iridescent green-black plumage also make them a stunning addition to the farm.

Market these eggs as a culinary event. They are for the adventurous chef, the food blogger, or the customer looking for something truly unique. Sell the first dark eggs by the half-dozen and make it clear they are a limited, seasonal specialty. The changing color becomes part of the story, creating a reason for customers to keep coming back to see what the ducks are laying this week.

The right breed is the one that aligns with your land, your time, and the specific customer you want to attract. Don’t just raise birds—curate a flock that produces a product you are excited to sell. Success comes from matching the unique strengths of each breed to a clear market purpose.