5 Best Blacksmith Propane Forges For Beginners For First-Year Success

That gate hinge you welded last year just snapped again, and the custom bracket you need for the new water trough is a special order with a three-week lead time. This is where a forge transforms from a novelty into a core workshop tool on a farm. Having the ability to heat and shape your own steel isn’t just a hobby; it’s a direct path to self-sufficiency, saving you time, money, and trips to town. Choosing the right first forge is the most critical step to making that happen without a year of frustration.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing Your First Forge for Farm & Workshop

A forge is more than just a hot box; it’s a tool that has to fit your space, your budget, and the jobs you actually need to do. Before you buy anything, think about whether you’ll be making small S-hooks and nails or trying to straighten a bent cultivator tine. The scale of your ambition dictates the tool you need.

The biggest decision is between a single and a dual burner. A single burner is fantastic for fuel efficiency and is all you need for small projects like tool handles, brackets, and small knives. A dual burner forge gets hotter, faster, and heats a larger area, which is essential for working with thicker stock or attempting forge welding. Don’t pay for two burners if you only plan to make tent stakes.

Also, consider the completeness of the kit. Some forges arrive ready to go, with the regulator and hose included. Others are just the insulated box, leaving you to source the critical components. For a first-timer, a complete kit removes a major variable and gets you hammering metal within an hour of unboxing.

Mr. Volcano Hero: The Complete Beginner’s Kit

The Mr. Volcano Hero is built for the person who wants to start forging, not start a research project on gas fittings. It’s a complete kit in a box. You get the forge, the burner (or burners), the hose, and the high-pressure regulator—everything you need to connect to a standard propane tank.

This forge is designed to eliminate the common beginner headaches. The oval shape is surprisingly versatile, accommodating oddly shaped pieces of metal better than a simple cylinder. Because it’s a proven, popular design, you can be confident it will reach working temperature without a lot of fiddling with the burner or air choke.

You are paying a small premium for the convenience, but it’s worth it. By removing the guesswork from the setup, you can focus entirely on learning heat control and hammer work. It’s a reliable, effective tool that will serve you well for making everything from simple hardware to your first knife.

Hell’s Forge HF2: Dual Burner Power & Value

When you know you’ll be working with heavier steel—like re-bar for custom gate latches or old leaf springs for making hardy tools—you need more power. The Hell’s Forge HF2 is a workhorse that provides that power without a massive price tag. Its dual burners deliver serious, even heat across a larger area.

The key feature here is the ability to reach forge-welding temperatures reliably. This opens up a whole new world of projects, like making your own Damascus steel or forge-welding a high-carbon steel edge onto a milder steel axe body. The rectangular shape is also ideal for flat stock, giving you consistent heat for bladesmithing.

Many dual burner forges like this one allow you to run the burners independently. This gives you the best of both worlds. Fire up one burner for small, fuel-efficient jobs, and ignite the second when you need maximum heat for a big project. It’s a versatile forge that you can grow into rather than out of.

VEVOR Propane Forge: Simple, Efficient Heating

Sometimes you just need a tool that does its job without any fuss, and that’s the VEVOR forge. This is often the most budget-friendly option, delivering a simple, no-frills heating machine. It’s a basic, well-insulated cylinder that gets hot and stays hot, which is the fundamental purpose of a forge.

The tradeoff for the lower price is that you might have to do a little more of the final assembly yourself. This usually involves coating the ceramic fiber insulation with the included refractory cement—a simple but necessary step to protect the fibers and maximize heat retention. The fittings and build quality are functional, but may not feel as polished as more expensive brands.

For the farmer who is comfortable with basic mechanical assembly and just needs to heat metal for bending, shaping, and tempering, this forge is an incredible value. It proves you don’t need to spend a fortune to get a tool capable of handling 90% of the blacksmithing tasks on a small farm. It’s a work tool, not a showpiece.

NC Tool Knifemaker Forge for Bladesmithing

If your primary reason for getting into blacksmithing is to make knives, then get a forge designed for making knives. The NC Tool Knifemaker forge is a specialized piece of equipment. Its long, narrow chamber with openings on both ends is built for one job: heating long, thin pieces of steel efficiently and evenly.

This design is far more efficient for bladesmithing than a general-purpose oval or round forge. You can pass a blade through the forge, heating only the section you’re working on, which gives you incredible control. This is crucial for precision work like forging bevels and especially for the final heat treatment, where an even heat is non-negotiable.

While you can make a knife in any of the other forges, this one makes it easier and gives you better results. However, its specialized shape makes it less ideal for bulky, odd-shaped items. This is the right choice for the aspiring bladesmith, but a less versatile option for general farm repairs.

Simond Store Single Burner: Compact & Portable

Not every workshop has space for a permanent forging station. The Simond Store single burner forge is the answer for those with limited space or who need a portable heat source. It’s small enough to sit on a sturdy workbench and light enough to be stored on a shelf when not in use.

This forge is perfect for small-scale work. It gets hot quickly and is very fuel-efficient for making things like nails, hooks, small brackets, and decorative hardware. It’s also an excellent choice for taking on the road to help a neighbor with a quick repair on-site.

You have to respect its limits, of course. It will struggle to heat large, heavy stock, and reaching forge-welding temperatures can be a challenge. But for the vast majority of small projects and repairs, it provides more than enough heat in a compact, convenient, and affordable package.

Safe Forge Setup: Ventilation & Fire Prevention

A propane forge is an incredibly useful tool, but it demands respect. Your first priority is ventilation. These forges produce carbon monoxide (CO), an invisible, odorless gas that can be lethal. Never operate a forge in an enclosed space like a basement or a garage with the door closed. The absolute minimum is an open-sided shed or a garage with multiple large doors wide open for cross-ventilation.

Next, establish a "hot zone" around your forge. Keep a 10-foot radius clear of anything flammable—hay, sawdust, oily rags, fuel cans, and dry leaves. A concrete, dirt, or gravel floor is ideal. Always have multiple lines of fire defense within arm’s reach:

• A rated ABC fire extinguisher
• A 5-gallon bucket of water
• A bucket of sand for smothering small fires

Finally, protect yourself. Wear safety glasses or, even better, full-seal goggles to protect from flying scale. Leather welding gloves are a must for handling hot metal and adjusting the forge. Wear clothes made from natural fibers like cotton, denim, or wool; synthetic fabrics like polyester or nylon can melt and stick to your skin if hit by a hot spark.

First-Year Care: Refractory & Burner Upkeep

Your forge is a piece of equipment, and like any good tool, it requires a little maintenance to perform its best. The most important component is the refractory lining—the white ceramic insulation coated with cement. With heating and cooling, small cracks will inevitably appear in the cement. This is normal.

About once a season, inspect the lining. If you see significant cracks or crumbling, patch them with a high-temperature refractory mortar (like Satanite or Plistix). This simple step takes just a few minutes but dramatically improves your forge’s heating efficiency and extends the life of the insulation and the steel shell. A well-maintained lining means less fuel burned and higher temperatures.

The burner is the engine of your forge. Occasionally, debris like scale, dust, or even a spider’s web can clog the nozzle or air intake. If your forge sputters or burns with a lazy, yellow flame instead of a crisp blue cone, a blockage is the likely culprit. Disconnect the propane, and use compressed air to blow out the burner tube and nozzle. A clean burner is a hot, efficient burner.

Your first forge isn’t just a purchase; it’s an investment in capability. It’s the tool that lets you repair what’s broken, improve what you have, and create what you need from scratch. By choosing a forge that matches your real-world needs and respecting the simple rules of safety and maintenance, you set yourself up for a successful first year of turning raw steel into functional solutions for your farm and workshop.