6 Best Pat Green Drum Carders For Budget For First-Year Success

You’ve got your first fleece, a greasy, promising pile straight from the shearer. Now comes the real work of turning that raw potential into something you can spin. A drum carder is the single biggest investment you’ll make in this process, and getting it right the first time saves a world of frustration and money.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Why a Pat Green Carder is a Smart First Choice

When you’re starting out, you need equipment that just works. You don’t want to fight with a flimsy machine or wonder if a problem is your technique or the tool. Pat Green carders have built a reputation on being straightforward, durable, and reliable. They’re the kind of tool you buy once and use for decades.

This isn’t about fancy features; it’s about solid construction. The frames are robust, the drums are balanced, and the adjustments are simple. For a first-year fiber artist, this means you can focus on learning how to handle wool, not on troubleshooting a complicated piece of machinery. It’s a workhorse, not a show pony, and that’s exactly what you need when you have a mountain of fleece to process.

The value proposition is also hard to beat. While not the absolute cheapest on the market, they hit a sweet spot of affordability and quality that prevents you from having to buy a second, better carder a year later. Think of it as investing in your own success. A reliable carder produces beautiful, lofty batts, which in turn makes for easier, more enjoyable spinning.

The Pat Green Workhorse: All-Purpose Carding

If you could only have one carder, the Workhorse with a 72 TPI (Teeth Per Inch) cloth would be it. This is the jack-of-all-trades in the lineup. It’s designed to handle the medium-grade wools you’re most likely to encounter from local farms—think Romney, Corriedale, or your classic Shetland fleece.

The 72 TPI is coarse enough to power through fleece that might have a bit of vegetable matter (VM) without getting hopelessly clogged. It opens up the locks efficiently, creating a respectable, airy batt ready for spinning. This is your go-to for spinning sturdy yarn for sweaters, hats, and mittens.

Don’t expect it to perform miracles on ultra-fine fibers like Merino or Angora. The coarser teeth can be a bit aggressive, causing some breakage and not fully separating every delicate fiber. But for the vast majority of wool that a hobby farmer will raise or buy, the Workhorse is the most practical and forgiving starting point. It gets the job done without demanding perfectly clean, premium fleece.

Pat Green’s Finer Fleece for Delicate Fibers

Once you start working with finer wools, you’ll notice the limitations of a standard carding cloth. That’s where a model like the Finer Fleece, typically equipped with a 120 TPI cloth, comes in. The much denser teeth are designed to gently tease apart delicate fibers like fine Merino, alpaca, and Cormo.

The result is a smoother, more homogenous batt with fewer neps (tiny knots of fiber). This is crucial when you’re aiming for a smooth, worsted-style yarn. The 120 TPI cloth excels at blending different fine fibers or colors, creating subtle, beautiful heathers that a coarser cloth just can’t achieve.

The tradeoff is preparation. You cannot feed dirty, VM-heavy fleece into a 120 TPI carder and expect good results. It will clog quickly and be a nightmare to clean. This carder demands well-skirted and thoroughly washed wool. It’s the right choice if you know your primary interest lies with fine wools and you’re willing to do the prep work.

The Compact Cadet: Pat Green’s Space-Saver

Not everyone has a dedicated fiber studio. For many of us, our workspace is a corner of the living room or a small spare bedroom. The Compact Cadet is Pat Green’s answer to this reality. It offers the same build quality in a smaller, more manageable footprint.

The primary benefit is obvious: it’s easy to store and doesn’t dominate a multi-use space. It’s also lighter, making it more portable if you want to take it to a guild meeting or a friend’s house. The lower price point is also a significant advantage for those on a tight first-year budget.

The compromise is in the size of the batt. The narrower drum means you’ll produce smaller batts, requiring you to doff (remove the fiber) more often to process the same amount of wool. This can slow down your workflow if you’re tackling a whole fleece. But for smaller projects or for spinners who prefer to work with smaller quantities at a time, the Cadet is a brilliant, space-conscious solution.

Deb’s Delicate: The Ultimate Fine Fiber Carder

For the spinner who is truly dedicated to the finest, most luxurious fibers, there is a step beyond the standard fine-fleece models. "Deb’s Delicate" represents the top-tier of manual carders, often featuring an ultra-high 190 TPI cloth and a chain drive for incredibly smooth operation. This is a specialty tool for a specific purpose.

This carder is made for fibers like angora rabbit, cashmere, and silk blends. The incredibly fine, densely packed teeth can handle these slippery, short-stapled fibers without creating static or losing them in the mechanism. It produces a batt that is less like a cloud and more like a fine, smooth sheet, perfect for spinning gossamer-thin lace yarns.

This is not a beginner’s carder. It is unforgiving of poor preparation and will be utterly useless for medium or coarse wools. It’s an investment you make when you know, without a doubt, that your fiber journey is focused exclusively on the most delicate and challenging materials. For that specific artist, it is an indispensable tool.

The Power-Carder: Pat Green’s Motorized Pick

Processing an entire fleece by hand is a serious physical commitment. For those with physical limitations or those planning to process fiber on a larger scale, the Power-Carder, Pat Green’s motorized option, is a game-changer. It turns hours of cranking into a much faster, less strenuous task.

The main benefit is speed and efficiency. A motor allows you to feed fiber with both hands, giving you better control over the batt’s consistency while dramatically increasing your output. If you plan to sell your batts or yarn, the time savings can directly translate into profit.

However, the downsides for a beginner are significant. The cost is substantially higher, and you lose the tactile feedback of hand-cranking, which can make it easier to overload the drum and damage the carding cloth. There’s also a steeper learning curve and a greater safety risk. For most first-year spinners, a manual carder is the better choice for learning the fundamentals of fiber prep.

The 90 TPI Standard for Medium Wool Batts

Sitting perfectly between the all-purpose 72 TPI and the specialized 120 TPI is the often-overlooked 90 TPI cloth. This option offers a fantastic balance of versatility and performance, making it a strong contender for the best all-around choice for a first carder.

The 90 TPI is fine enough to handle medium-fine wools like Targhee or a nice Polypay without being overly aggressive. It also does a better job of blending colors than a 72 TPI cloth. Yet, it’s still robust enough to process a standard Romney fleece without constant clogging, as long as it’s reasonably clean.

This is the carder for the spinner who wants to do a little bit of everything. If your flock has a mix of breeds, or you love to buy a variety of fleeces from local shepherds, the 90 TPI provides the flexibility to handle most of them well. It produces a wonderfully soft and lofty batt from a wide range of medium-grade wools.

Matching Carding Cloth TPI to Your Fiber Type

The single most important decision when buying a drum carder is choosing the right Teeth Per Inch (TPI) for the fiber you plan to process most often. TPI refers to the density of the wire pins on the carding cloth. A lower number means coarser, more widely spaced teeth, while a higher number means finer, denser teeth.

Getting this wrong is a source of constant frustration. Using a high TPI carder on coarse, dirty wool will lead to clogged drums and damaged fiber. Using a low TPI carder on ultra-fine alpaca will be inefficient and create a lumpy, neppy batt. The goal is to match the tool to the job.

Here is a simple guide to get you started:

• Coarse Fibers (e.g., Lincoln, Cotswold, very dirty fleece): 54-72 TPI. These teeth are robust and spaced far apart, allowing them to power through strong fibers and flick out debris.
• Medium Fibers (e.g., Romney, Corriedale, Shetland, most down breeds): 72-90 TPI. This is the sweet spot for versatility. It can handle a wide range of common wools effectively. If in doubt, start here.
• Fine Fibers (e.g., Merino, Cormo, Alpaca, Rambouillet): 120 TPI. The finer teeth gently open these delicate locks without causing breakage, creating a smooth preparation for spinning fine yarn.
• Ultra-Fine or Slippery Fibers (e.g., Angora, Cashmere, Silk): 190+ TPI. This is a specialized cloth for luxury fibers that require the most delicate handling.

Think honestly about the fleece you have access to and the yarn you want to spin. Your answer will point you directly to the right TPI and, ultimately, the right Pat Green carder for your first year of success.

Choosing your first drum carder feels like a monumental decision, but it doesn’t have to be. By focusing on the type of fiber you’ll actually be using, you can select a durable, effective tool like a Pat Green that will serve you well for years. Start with the right tool, and you’ll be on the fast track to creating the yarn you’ve been dreaming of.