6 Best Tow Behind Tillers For Small Farms Old Farmers Swear By

Breaking new ground for a market garden feels like a monumental task when you’re staring at it from the seat of a tractor. The difference between a season of fighting compacted soil and a season of planting in a perfectly prepared seedbed often comes down to one tool: the tiller. Choosing the right one isn’t just about turning dirt; it’s about saving your time, your back, and your sanity. For a small farm, the right tow-behind tiller is one of the most important investments you’ll make.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing a Tiller for Your Small Farm Plot

The first question is always the same: what are you pulling it with? A subcompact tractor with a three-point hitch and a Power Take-Off (PTO) opens up a world of heavy-duty, gear-driven implements. If you’re working with an ATV, UTV, or a beefy garden tractor, you’ll be looking at tillers with their own onboard engines. This is the most critical fork in the road, and it dictates every other choice you’ll make.

Your soil type is the next major factor. Heavy, red clay requires a tiller with significant weight and power to bite in and do its job. A lightweight tiller will just bounce across the surface, frustrating you and getting nothing done. For loamy or sandy soil, you have more flexibility, but even then, a well-built machine makes for faster, cleaner work.

Don’t oversize your implement. It’s tempting to buy the biggest tiller you can afford, but that’s a mistake. A 5-foot tiller behind a 20-horsepower tractor will put immense strain on the tractor’s hydraulics, PTO clutch, and transmission. It’s far better to make two passes with a properly sized 4-foot tiller than to break your tractor with one pass from a 5-footer. Match the tiller’s recommended horsepower range to your tractor’s PTO horsepower, not its engine horsepower.

Finally, think about your primary use. Are you breaking new sod once, then maintaining established beds? Or are you tilling in thick cover crops every spring and fall? Breaking new ground demands a heavier, more robust tiller. For yearly garden prep in soil that’s already been worked, a standard-duty model from a reputable brand will serve you well for years.

King Kutter XB Tiller: A Reliable Workhorse

When you see a faded red tiller still working perfectly after twenty years, there’s a good chance it’s a King Kutter. This brand has built a reputation on simple, overbuilt, and reliable PTO-driven implements. They aren’t fancy, but they are designed to work, be repaired, and keep on working.

The "XB" series is specifically designed for the subcompact tractors that are so common on small farms and homesteads. They match the power output and lifting capacity of tractors in the 15-25 HP range, ensuring you get maximum performance without overpowering your machine. Most models are gear-driven, which is a significant step up in durability from the chain-driven systems found on many budget tillers. A gear drive provides more consistent power transfer and has fewer wear parts to worry about over the long haul.

What you’re getting with a King Kutter is peace of mind. The steel is thick, the welds are solid, and parts are easy to find. It’s the kind of tool you buy with the expectation of passing it down, not throwing it away. For a small farmer who depends on their equipment to function without drama, that reliability is worth its weight in gold.

CountyLine 48-Inch Tiller: Value and Access

CountyLine is the house brand for Tractor Supply Company, and its biggest advantage is accessibility. You can walk into a store, see the tiller, and bring it home the same day. If you break a shear pin or need a new set of tines, your local store is likely to have them in stock. That convenience can’t be overstated when you’re in the middle of spring planting and can’t afford a week of downtime.

These tillers are a solid value proposition. For annual cultivation of existing garden plots, they perform admirably. The 48-inch model is a great all-around size for a half-acre to two-acre operation, wide enough to cover ground quickly but nimble enough to maneuver. It will turn soil, chop up leftover vegetation, and prepare a decent seedbed without breaking the bank.

The tradeoff for the lower price point is often in the construction. Many CountyLine models are chain-driven, which can require more maintenance and adjustment over time compared to a gear-driven system. They may not be the absolute best choice for breaking hard, virgin ground year after year, but for the majority of small farm tasks, they represent a smart, practical balance of cost, performance, and parts availability.

Tarter Rotary Tiller: Built for Tough Ground

If your property is more rock than soil, or if you’re reclaiming an old pasture compacted by years of neglect, Tarter is a name you should know. Tarter implements are known for being heavy and tough. Their rotary tillers are built with the expectation that they will encounter resistance, and they are designed to win that fight.

The key is weight and construction. Tarter tillers often feature a heavier frame and a stronger A-frame hitch, which helps the tiller stay planted in the ground instead of bouncing over hard spots. They typically use heavy-duty, gear-driven transmissions and a cast-iron gearbox, components designed to handle the shock and torque of hitting hidden rocks or dense root masses. This isn’t a finesse tool; it’s a machine for aggressive primary tillage.

This toughness comes at a cost, both in price and in the demands it places on your tractor. You’ll need a tractor with sufficient horsepower and lift capacity to handle a Tarter tiller safely. But if you’ve ever bent the tines on a lighter-duty tiller or spent a day fighting to get it to dig in, you understand the value of bringing the right tool for a tough job.

Agri-Fab Tow Tiller: ATV & UTV Powerhouse

For those without a PTO tractor, the game changes completely. This is where engine-driven, tow-behind tillers shine, and the Agri-Fab SmartLINK system is a popular and versatile option. This is a self-contained unit with its own Briggs & Stratton engine that powers the tines. Your ATV, UTV, or lawn tractor simply provides the forward motion.

This setup offers incredible flexibility. You can till remote food plots for wildlife that a tractor could never reach. You can navigate tight corners in a market garden or maneuver between established orchard rows with ease. The engine provides plenty of power for cultivating soil that has been worked before, making it ideal for annual garden preparation.

However, it’s important to understand the limitations. An engine-driven tiller lacks the significant downward pressure provided by a heavy tractor and a three-point hitch. Because of this, it can struggle to break truly new, compacted ground. It’s a fantastic tool for maintaining and preparing existing plots, but it’s not a direct replacement for a PTO tiller when it comes to the heaviest-duty tasks.

Titan 4-Foot Tiller: Heavy-Duty on a Budget

Titan Attachments has carved out a niche by selling heavy-duty implements directly to consumers online. This business model cuts out the dealer markup, often delivering a tiller with impressive specifications for a surprisingly low price. If you’re comfortable with online ordering and maybe a little final assembly, Titan is a compelling option.

Many of their tillers boast features typically found on more expensive brands, such as gear-driven side transmissions and heavy-gauge steel construction. A 4-foot Titan tiller can often match the weight and specs of a King Kutter or Tarter, making it a serious contender for farmers on a tight budget who still need a machine that can handle tough conditions.

The compromise is in the purchasing experience and support. You won’t have a local dealer to ask questions or handle warranty claims. While the quality is generally solid for the price, the fit and finish might not be as polished as a premium brand. For the self-reliant farmer who can turn a wrench and troubleshoot minor issues, the value is undeniable.

Brinly-Hardy Disc Harrow: Old-School Tillage

Sometimes the best tool isn’t a tiller at all. Before rototillers became common, the disc harrow was the primary tool for preparing soil, and for good reason. A disc harrow doesn’t pulverize the soil; it slices and rolls it, which is far gentler on the soil’s delicate structure and the beneficial organisms that live within it. Many old-timers swear by them for building healthy, living soil over the long term.

A tow-behind disc harrow, pulled by an ATV or small tractor, is perfect for breaking up sod, incorporating cover crops, and knocking down weeds. It works by cutting into the ground with a series of angled, concave discs. You can adjust the angle of the discs to change how aggressively they dig. It won’t give you a fluffy, powder-fine seedbed in one pass like a tiller, but that’s often a good thing for preventing soil compaction and erosion.

Using a disc requires a different approach. It often takes multiple passes in different directions to achieve the desired result. But the tool itself is incredibly simple, with few moving parts to break. For the farmer focused on conservation tillage or simply wanting a durable, low-maintenance alternative, a disc harrow is a timeless and effective choice.

PTO vs. Engine-Driven: Final Considerations

The final decision really boils down to the machine you already own. If you have a compact tractor with a three-point hitch and PTO, a PTO-driven tiller is the superior choice for power, durability, and effectiveness. The tractor’s weight helps the tiller dig deep, and the direct power transfer from the engine is incredibly efficient. Your only job is to match the tiller’s size and weight to your tractor’s capabilities.

Engine-driven tillers, however, are brilliant problem-solvers. They grant tillage capabilities to a whole range of vehicles, from powerful UTVs to simple lawn tractors. They democratize soil preparation for those who don’t have or need a full-blown tractor. The trade-off is the added complexity of maintaining a second small engine and a general lack of downward pressure for breaking truly hard ground.

Ultimately, the goal is to create a good seedbed with the least amount of time, effort, and stress on your equipment. A PTO tiller on a subcompact tractor is a purpose-built system for doing just that. An engine-driven tiller is a versatile and clever adaptation. Knowing which system fits your farm is the key to making a wise investment that will pay dividends every single spring.

The right tiller feels like a partner in the field, an extension of your will to turn soil and grow food. Whether it’s a heavy, gear-driven PTO unit or a nimble engine-powered tow-behind, the best machine is the one that reliably shows up for work. Choose wisely, match the tool to the task, and you’ll spend less time fixing and more time farming.