5 Best Frost Proof Fence Heaters For Cattle to Prevent Frozen Troughs

There’s a specific sound to a frozen water trough—a dull thud as your axe fails to make a dent. It’s a sound that means your cattle aren’t drinking, and you’re in for a long, cold morning of manual labor. Ensuring consistent, ice-free water is one of the most critical winter chores, directly impacting herd health and your own sanity.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

The Importance of Frost-Proof Water Systems

Dehydration is a bigger threat in winter than many realize. Cattle need massive amounts of water to digest dry hay and maintain their body temperature. When their only water source is frozen solid, they stop drinking, which quickly leads to them eating less, losing condition, and becoming more susceptible to illness.

The daily chore of breaking ice is not just exhausting; it’s often a losing battle. You can spend an hour clearing a trough only to have it skim over again in the wind. A reliable de-icer or heater automates this task, providing a constant supply of accessible water. It transforms a reactive, labor-intensive problem into a proactive, hands-off solution.

This isn’t just about convenience. It’s an investment in animal welfare and productivity. Well-hydrated cattle are healthier, maintain their weight better through the winter, and experience far less stress. That peace of mind, knowing your animals have what they need even when the temperature plummets, is invaluable.

API 1500W Submersible De-Icer for Large Tanks

When you’re dealing with a large stock tank, you need serious power. The API 1500W submersible de-icer is built for exactly that. It’s designed to keep 100 to 300-gallon tanks completely ice-free, even in the harshest winter climates.

This unit sits at the bottom of the tank, heating the water from the ground up for maximum efficiency. It includes a built-in thermostat that only turns the heater on when water temperatures approach freezing, which helps manage electricity costs. A sturdy metal guard protects the heating element from being damaged by curious noses or hooves.

The primary consideration here is scale. Using a 1500W heater in a 50-gallon trough is overkill. It will waste electricity and may heat the water more than necessary. But for a large herd relying on a single, high-capacity water source, this kind of power is not a luxury; it’s a necessity.

Farm Innovators H-419 for Easy Installation

Not everyone needs a high-powered submersible unit. For smaller setups, like a 15 or 30-gallon trough, simplicity is key. The Farm Innovators H-419 is a drain plug de-icer, but its most common application involves its simple, over-the-side clamp. You just attach it to the lip of the trough, plug it in, and you’re done.

At 250 watts, it’s a low-power, energy-efficient option. It’s designed to keep a small area of water open rather than heating the entire tank, which is all that’s needed. The thermostat is preset to turn on at 35°F and off at 45°F, so it only runs when absolutely necessary.

This heater is perfect for those smaller, isolated waterers in a rotational grazing system or for a small hobby herd. Its ease of installation and removal makes it incredibly practical for part-time farmers who need effective solutions without a complicated setup. It’s a workhorse for the small-scale operation.

K&H Ultimate Floating Deicer for Safety

Floating deicers offer a different approach, and they are often the best choice for plastic or rubber stock tanks. A submersible heater can, in rare cases, create a hot spot that damages the bottom of a plastic tank. The K&H Ultimate Floating Deicer avoids this risk entirely by floating on the surface.

This design is also quite energy-efficient. Instead of trying to heat the entire body of water, it focuses its energy on maintaining an ice-free hole at the surface. It’s MET listed for safety, and its internal thermostat ensures it only operates when needed.

The main tradeoff with any floating heater is its position. In a very large tank on a windy day, it can get blown to one side, leaving the far side to freeze over. However, for most standard-sized troughs, it stays put and does its job reliably, making it a top choice for anyone prioritizing safety with non-metal tanks.

Behlen Country Super Trough-O-Matic Heater

Sometimes the problem isn’t the trough itself, but the plumbing that feeds it. The Behlen Country Super Trough-O-Matic Heater is a specialized tool designed to solve this exact issue. It doesn’t heat the tank; it heats the automatic float valve and the immediate supply line.

This unit is made to integrate directly with Behlen’s Trough-O-Matic line of float valves. It’s a 250-watt heater that wraps around the valve assembly, preventing the mechanism and the incoming water from freezing up. This ensures your automatic waterer can actually deliver water to the trough.

This is not a standalone solution for keeping a large tank ice-free. It’s a crucial component of a complete frost-proof system. You would use this in addition to a tank de-icer. For anyone running an automatic waterer, preventing a frozen valve is just as important as preventing a frozen trough.

Ice-Chaser Multi-Use De-Icer for Versatility

If you have a mix of different tanks or just want one heater that can handle multiple jobs, a multi-use de-icer is a smart move. The Allied Precision Ice-Chaser series is a great example. These units are built to function as either a floating or a submersible de-icer.

They typically come in several wattages (500W, 1000W, 1500W), so you can pick the power level that matches your largest tank. With a solid cast aluminum body, they are durable and built to last. You can drop it to the bottom of a big metal tank or let it float in a smaller plastic one.

This versatility is its greatest strength. You might use it as a submersible in your main 150-gallon pasture tank, then move it to float in a 50-gallon trough near the barn as needed. While a dedicated unit might be slightly more optimized for one specific task, the flexibility offered by a multi-use de-icer is a huge advantage for a dynamic farm operation.

Choosing Your Heater: Wattage, Type, and Safety

Making the right choice comes down to a few key factors. Don’t just buy the most powerful heater available; match the tool to your specific needs.

• Wattage: This is your starting point. A small, 50-gallon trough in a milder climate might only need 250-500 watts. A 300-gallon tank in a place where sub-zero temperatures are common will require 1500 watts. Over-sizing wastes money on electricity, while under-sizing results in a frozen trough.
• Type: The material of your trough is a major consideration. For plastic or rubber tanks, a floating de-icer is the safest bet to prevent damage. For large metal tanks, a submersible heater is often the most efficient. Clamp-on or drain-plug models are excellent for their ease of installation in smaller tanks.
• Safety: Always choose a heater that is UL or MET listed. This certification ensures it has been tested for safety in agricultural use. If your cattle are particularly playful, look for a model with a sturdy, anti-chew cord and a protective cage around the heating element.

Safe Installation and Power Cord Management

A de-icer is only as safe as its installation. The first rule is to always plug it into a GFCI-protected outlet. This is non-negotiable. A GFCI will cut the power instantly if it detects a fault, preventing electric shock to you or your animals.

Cattle are curious and destructive. They will chew, step on, and rub against an exposed power cord. The best practice is to protect the cord by running it through a sturdy PVC or metal conduit. You can also run the cord overhead along a fence line, well out of their reach.

Before winter truly sets in, do a full inspection. Make sure the cord has no nicks or frays. Ensure the heater is sitting properly in the trough and that the cord isn’t a tripping hazard. A few minutes of prevention can save you from a failed heater or, worse, a dangerous electrical situation.

Ultimately, keeping water from freezing is about having a reliable system in place before you need it. By matching your heater’s wattage and type to your specific trough and climate, you can eliminate one of winter’s most demanding chores. A little planning now ensures your herd stays healthy and hydrated, and you stay warm inside.