6 Best Blacksmith Forges For Hobby Farmers On a Homestead Budget

That gate hinge you bought last year just snapped again, and the custom-sized bracket you need for the new chicken tractor doesn’t seem to exist. On a homestead, problems like these aren’t just annoying; they stop work in its tracks. A small blacksmith forge transforms you from someone who buys solutions to someone who creates them, turning scrap steel into custom parts and broken tools into functional assets.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Propane vs. Coal: Fueling Your Farm Forge

Choosing your fuel is the first real decision, and it dictates your entire workflow. Propane is the king of convenience. You hook up a standard BBQ tank, turn a valve, light it, and you have forging heat in minutes. When you’re done, you shut it off. This on-demand nature is perfect for a busy homestead, letting you squeeze in a quick repair between morning and evening chores without a lengthy setup or cleanup.

Coal, on the other hand, is a commitment. It’s a craft within a craft. You have to build and manage the fire, learning to turn coal into coke for a clean, hot burn. It gets incredibly hot, often hotter than propane, which can be useful for forge welding. But it’s messy, produces more smoke, and requires a dedicated space where soot and ash aren’t a problem. Sourcing good quality blacksmithing coal can also be a regional challenge.

Ultimately, the choice comes down to your primary goal. If you need a tool to quickly and efficiently heat metal for repairs and small projects, propane is the practical answer for 90% of hobby farmers. If you are drawn to the traditional art of blacksmithing itself and enjoy the process as much as the result, the skill and ritual of a coal fire have a powerful appeal.

Mr. Volcano Hero: A Top Single-Burner Forge

The Mr. Volcano Hero is a fantastic starting point for a reason. It’s simple, well-built, and does exactly what it promises without a hefty price tag. For the homesteader just dipping their toes into blacksmithing, this single-burner forge provides enough heat to tackle a huge range of common farm tasks.

Think of it as your go-to for small-scale work. You can easily forge new S-hooks for hanging tools, heat-treat a dull mower blade to restore its edge, or hammer out custom nails for a rustic woodworking project. Its compact size and efficient single burner mean you’re not wasting a ton of propane to heat a small piece of metal. It gets hot fast and is perfect for focused, quick jobs.

The limitation, of course, is its size. The hot spot is concentrated, so working on long pieces of steel or very thick stock is challenging. You won’t be forging a full-sized broadfork or a massive gate hinge in one go. But for the vast majority of repairs and toolmaking a hobby farm demands, the Mr. Volcano is more than capable.

Hell’s Forge HF2 for Versatile Farm Projects

When you know you’ll be tackling more than just small hooks and brackets, the Hell’s Forge HF2 is a logical step up. Its dual-burner design is the key feature, giving you a much larger and more evenly heated chamber. This opens up a whole new category of projects that are frustrating or impossible with a single burner.

This is the forge you want for heating the middle of a long bar to create a perfect bend for a custom tool handle. It’s what you need to get a larger piece, like a small hatchet head or a heavy-duty latch, to an even forging temperature. The ability to get more of the metal hot at once is crucial for bigger, more ambitious work. It provides the power needed to reliably reach welding heat for joining two pieces of steel.

The main tradeoff is fuel consumption; two burners drink more propane than one. However, most dual-burner forges like the HF2 allow you to run just a single burner. This gives you the best of both worlds: the efficiency of a small forge for small jobs and the power of a large one when a project demands it. This versatility makes it a true homestead workhorse.

Vevor Propane Forge for Maximum Affordability

Let’s be direct: sometimes the budget dictates the purchase. Vevor and other similar import brands have made blacksmithing accessible to almost anyone by offering functional forges at an incredibly low price point. If you need the capability of a forge but have very little capital to invest, this is how you get in the game.

You are, however, trading cost for convenience and polish. The instructions might be sparse, the fittings may require some extra attention with thread tape, and the refractory cement that protects the forge body will need careful application and curing. Think of it as a "kit" in a functional sense—you provide the final bit of fit and finish to get it running perfectly.

Is it a good choice? Absolutely, if you go in with the right expectations. If you’re a hands-on person who is comfortable tinkering with tools, you can get a Vevor forge running just as hot as a model costing twice as much. For the homesteader who needs to turn a piece of rebar into a new stake puller today without breaking the bank, its value is undeniable.

Whitlox Wood-Fired Forge: A DIY Homestead Kit

For the homesteader focused on self-sufficiency, the Whitlox forge presents a fascinating alternative. Instead of relying on a bottle of propane, this forge is designed to run on wood chunks or charcoal—fuel you can potentially produce right on your own property. It taps directly into the homesteading ethos of using what you have.

The design is brilliantly simple: an insulated steel box designed to hold a fire, fed with air from a hand-cranked or electric blower. It’s less of a high-tech appliance and more of a carefully designed fire pit. This makes it robust and easy to repair. There are no jets to clog or complex regulators to fail.

The experience is completely different from a gas forge. Managing a wood fire for consistent heat is a skill that takes practice, and it’s certainly messier. But the payoff is a forge that’s untethered from the supply chain. If you can make charcoal and have a source of electricity (or elbow grease for the crank), you can heat steel. It’s a compelling option for those who value resilience above all else.

Atlas Graham Forge for Precision Knife & Tool Work

Not all forges are created equal, and some are built with a specific purpose in mind. The Atlas Graham forge is a prime example of a unit designed for the bladesmith and toolmaker. While it can handle general forging, its real strength lies in creating a clean, controlled, and highly efficient heating environment.

The key is in the design. These forges typically feature a smaller, more heavily insulated chamber and a very efficient burner. This combination minimizes the amount of oxygen that gets to the steel, which dramatically reduces the formation of "scale"—the flaky black oxide layer that forms on hot metal. Less scale means a cleaner finish on your final product and makes precision work, like forge welding the layers of a Damascus steel billet, much more successful.

If your main goal is to make high-quality knives for the kitchen, chisels for the workshop, or other fine tools, investing in a specialized forge like this is a smart move. The control and clean heat it provides will save you immense time and frustration during the grinding and finishing stages. For simply bending rebar, it’s overkill, but for detailed work, it’s the right tool for the job.

Simond Store Double Burner for Larger Stock

Sometimes, farm repairs require serious heat and size. When you’re working with thick axle shafts, heavy angle iron, or pieces of old leaf spring, you need a forge that can pump out the BTUs and accommodate larger material. The forges from Simond Store and similar brands often feature larger bodies and powerful burners designed for exactly this kind of heavy lifting.

This is the forge you’ll be glad to have when you need to straighten a bent tractor implement or forge a massive staple to pin two landscape timbers together. The larger interior volume and dual burners ensure that a thick piece of steel heats all the way to its core, not just on the surface. Trying to do this kind of work in a small forge is a slow, frustrating process that often fails.

Of course, a bigger forge uses more fuel and takes longer to come up to temperature. You wouldn’t fire it up to make a simple J-hook. But having the capacity to handle heavy stock means fewer limitations on what you can build or repair. It’s about having the right tool when a big problem arises.

Essential Safety Gear for Your New Forge Setup

Working with a forge is incredibly rewarding, but it is fundamentally dangerous. There are no shortcuts with safety. The heat, the flying sparks, and the hot metal demand your full respect and proper personal protective equipment (PPE). This is not optional.

Your absolute minimum safety kit must include:

• Full-coverage safety glasses: Not sunglasses. You need protection from sparks and flying bits of hot scale.
• Leather gloves: Good for handling material around the forge, but never use them to hold the hot end of steel in place of tongs.
• Natural fiber clothing: Wear cotton, denim, or wool. Synthetic fabrics like polyester or nylon can melt and stick to your skin, causing horrific burns.
• A leather apron: This provides a critical barrier of protection for your torso against both heat and hot metal.
• A rated fire extinguisher: Keep an ABC-class fire extinguisher within arm’s reach of your forge at all times.

Beyond personal gear, your setup is critical. Proper ventilation is non-negotiable. A propane forge consumes oxygen and produces carbon monoxide. It must be used outdoors or in a very well-ventilated space like an open barn or a shop with large bay doors. Keep the area clear of any flammable materials—hay, wood shavings, dry leaves, and paper are all fuel waiting for a stray spark.

A forge is more than just a tool for heating metal; it’s a gateway to self-reliance. It empowers you to fix what’s broken, create what’s needed, and deepen your connection to the materials on your homestead. Choose the right one for your budget and goals, prioritize safety, and start turning problems into solutions.