8 best canning strainers to process tomatoes

That moment arrives every year when the kitchen counter disappears under a mountain of ripe tomatoes, a testament to a successful season. The pride of a full harvest quickly gives way to the pressure of processing it all before it spoils. A good tomato strainer is the essential bridge between that beautiful, overwhelming pile and jars of rich, seedless sauce lining your pantry shelves.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Choosing the Right Tomato Canning Strainer

Deciding on the right strainer isn’t about finding the "best" one, but the best one for your scale and style of farming. The first major decision is manual versus electric. A manual strainer is simple, affordable, and perfectly capable for someone processing the yield from a dozen or so plants. An electric model, however, is a game-changer when you’re facing down bushels of tomatoes from multiple long rows, turning a full-day marathon into a manageable afternoon task.

Next, consider the type of tool: a dedicated tomato strainer versus a multi-purpose food mill. A dedicated strainer, like the classic Victorio or Weston models, is designed to do one thing exceptionally well: separate pulp from seeds and skins with an auger-and-screen system. A food mill, on the other hand, uses a crank to press food through a perforated plate and is wonderfully versatile for applesauce, mashed potatoes, or jams. If you need a kitchen workhorse for many tasks, a food mill is a smart investment; if your primary goal is processing large volumes of tomatoes for sauce, a dedicated strainer is far more efficient.

Finally, think about your batch size and materials. A small, simple food mill is fine for a few quarts, but processing 50 pounds of Romas with it will test your patience. Look at the hopper size and overall construction. Stainless steel is the premium choice for durability and because it won’t react with the acid in tomatoes, but quality plastic and aluminum models can offer great value. Your choice should directly reflect the size of your tomato patch and how much time you’re willing to spend at the counter.

Victorio VKP250: The Classic Manual Strainer

The Victorio VKP250 is the quintessential manual tomato strainer for a reason—it’s a reliable workhorse that has earned its place in countless homestead kitchens. Its design is straightforward: a hand crank turns an auger that pushes tomatoes against a screen, separating the smooth pulp from the skins and seeds. The clamp-on base attaches securely to most countertops, providing the stability you need when you’re cranking through a big box of fruit.

This strainer hits the sweet spot for the serious hobby farmer. It can handle 20 to 50 pounds of tomatoes without issue, making it ideal for those with a dedicated patch but not a commercial-level operation. While it requires manual effort, the process is surprisingly efficient, and running the discarded skins through a second time extracts nearly every last drop of pulp. It’s a tool built for a purpose, and it executes that purpose flawlessly.

If you process a respectable harvest each year and value simplicity and reliability over speed, the Victorio VKP250 is your tool. It’s an affordable, durable investment that will turn your tomatoes into sauce for decades. This is the standard-bearer for manual strainers and the right choice for most small-scale growers.

Weston Deluxe Electric Strainer: For Big Batches

When your tomato harvest is measured in bushels, not pounds, elbow grease alone won’t cut it. The Weston Deluxe Electric Strainer is designed for exactly this scenario, taking the manual labor out of processing large quantities of tomatoes, berries, and other soft fruits. Its powerful motor pushes produce through the strainer quickly and consistently, letting you focus on feeding the hopper and managing the output.

The key advantage here is time and energy. What might take half a day with a manual crank can be accomplished in an hour or two, a critical difference when you have other farm chores piling up. The Weston comes with multiple screen sizes, giving you versatility for making everything from smooth tomato juice to chunkier apple or pumpkin puree. It’s a well-built machine designed for volume.

This is the strainer for the grower who consistently has more tomatoes than time. If you plant 50 or more tomato plants and the thought of hand-cranking fills you with dread, the Weston is a worthy investment. It’s a significant step up from a manual model, built for people who are serious about preserving their large harvest efficiently.

OXO Good Grips Food Mill: A Versatile Kitchen Tool

The OXO Good Grips Food Mill isn’t a specialized tomato-only machine; it’s a versatile kitchen MVP. With its sturdy stainless steel bowl and interchangeable discs for fine, medium, and coarse textures, it can handle everything from silky smooth tomato puree to rustic mashed potatoes or seedless raspberry jam. The non-slip legs fold out to sit securely over bowls and pots, making it a stable and user-friendly tool.

The tradeoff for this versatility is efficiency at scale. While it works beautifully for small to medium batches of tomatoes, processing several bushels would be a slow, laborious process of scraping and turning. Its strength lies in its adaptability. For the hobby farmer who wants one tool that can help preserve a little bit of everything from the garden—not just a massive tomato crop—this food mill makes a lot of sense.

Buy the OXO Food Mill if you want a single, high-quality tool for a wide variety of kitchen tasks. It’s perfect for the diversified gardener who processes a few quarts of tomato sauce one day and a batch of applesauce the next. If you value versatility over single-purpose speed, this is an excellent choice.

KitchenAid Strainer Set: For Stand Mixer Owners

For those who already have a KitchenAid stand mixer, the Fruit & Vegetable Strainer Set attachment is a no-brainer. It cleverly transforms a powerful motor you already own into an efficient food processing machine. The attachment grinds and strains simultaneously, separating pulp from skins and seeds with impressive speed. You simply feed quartered tomatoes into the hopper and let the mixer do all the work.

This attachment shines for its convenience and space-saving design. You aren’t buying another large, single-use appliance, but rather a compact accessory that leverages your existing investment. It’s more than capable of handling the harvest from a typical large garden, turning dozens of pounds of tomatoes into smooth puree without breaking a sweat. The process is fast, hands-free, and yields a consistently great product.

If you own a KitchenAid mixer and process more than a handful of tomatoes, this attachment is an absolute must-have. It offers the power of an electric model without the cost or counter space of a standalone unit. Don’t buy a mixer just for this, but if you have one, this is the smartest way to process your harvest.

LEM Big Bite Electric Strainer: Heavy-Duty Power

The LEM Big Bite Electric Strainer is a piece of equipment for the homesteader who operates on another level. This is not a casual kitchen gadget; it’s a powerful, commercial-grade machine designed for processing huge volumes with relentless efficiency. With a heavy-duty motor and all-metal gears, it’s built to chew through hundreds of pounds of produce without overheating or bogging down.

This strainer is defined by its sheer power and throughput. The large hopper and fast-moving auger mean you can process a massive harvest in a fraction of the time it would take with smaller, consumer-grade models. It’s an investment in productivity, ideal for those who grow for a small market, participate in a CSA, or simply have an enormous garden and a passion for preservation.

The LEM Big Bite is for the serious producer, not the casual gardener. If you measure your harvest by the truck bed and need a machine that will keep up all day long, this is your answer. It’s overkill for most hobby farms, but for those pushing the boundaries of small-scale production, it’s an invaluable, time-saving powerhouse.

Norpro 1951 Sauce Master: A Dependable Manual Mill

The Norpro 1951 Sauce Master is a direct and worthy competitor to the classic Victorio, offering a similar manual, auger-style design that gets the job done reliably. It excels at separating tomato pulp from the unwanted bits, featuring a large hopper and a secure suction base that holds tight to smooth countertops. For those without a convenient counter edge for a clamp, this suction base can be a significant advantage.

Like other manual models, the Norpro requires a bit of effort but rewards you with excellent control over the process. It comes with multiple screens, making it adaptable for different fruits and desired textures. It’s a solid, well-regarded tool that has proven its worth in preserving season after preserving season. The choice between this and another similar manual strainer often comes down to small preferences in handle design or mounting style.

Choose the Norpro Sauce Master if you want a proven, effective manual strainer and prefer a suction base to a clamp. It’s a fantastic, no-frills option for the hobbyist with a moderately sized garden who needs a dependable tool for turning out beautiful, seedless sauces and purees.

Mirro Foley Food Mill: A Simple, Timeless Design

The Mirro Foley Food Mill is the definition of a classic. This simple, tin-plated steel or stainless steel tool has been a staple in kitchens for generations, long before electric gadgets were common. It operates on a basic principle: a crank turns a blade that sweeps and presses food through a perforated bottom plate. There are no complex parts, no clamps, and no motor—just pure, simple mechanical efficiency.

This tool is best suited for small batches. While you could process a large harvest with it, its smaller capacity makes it a slow-going task. It’s perfect for making a few jars of sauce from a basket of tomatoes, a small batch of applesauce, or for mashing potatoes for dinner. Its simplicity is its greatest strength; it’s easy to use, easy to clean, and will last forever with basic care.

The Mirro Foley Food Mill is for the traditionalist, the minimalist, or the small-scale gardener. If you process just a few pounds of tomatoes at a time and appreciate simple, bomb-proof tools that do their job without fuss, this timeless classic is an excellent and incredibly affordable choice.

RSVP Endurance Food Mill: Durable Stainless Steel

For the "buy it for life" crowd, the RSVP Endurance Food Mill stands out. Made entirely of heavy-gauge stainless steel, this tool is built to last and withstand the rigors of acidic foods like tomatoes without any risk of staining or reactivity. It comes with three interchangeable milling discs, allowing you to control the texture of your final product from a fine puree to a coarser mash.

The all-steel construction not only ensures longevity but also makes for easy cleanup, as the entire unit is dishwasher safe. Like other food mills, it’s a versatile performer, ready for whatever your garden produces. Its sturdy build and quality materials place it a step above many other food mills on the market, appealing to those who prioritize durability and food-safe materials above all else.

If you want a versatile food mill and are willing to pay a premium for top-tier, all-stainless-steel construction, the RSVP Endurance is the one for you. It’s a beautiful, functional, and incredibly durable tool that will serve your kitchen and preserving needs for many years to come.

Tips for Using and Cleaning Your Tomato Strainer

Getting the most out of your strainer starts before you even turn the crank. For best results, briefly cook your tomatoes first—just enough to soften them. This helps break down the fruit and makes the separation of pulp and skin much easier, resulting in a higher yield and less strain on your equipment (and your arm). You don’t need to peel or core them; just quarter them and let the strainer do the work.

One of the most important tricks for maximizing your harvest is to run the waste through a second time. The discarded pile of skins and seeds that comes out of the chute still contains a surprising amount of valuable pulp. Collecting this "waste" and processing it again can increase your final yield by 10-15%, a significant amount when you’ve worked all season to grow those tomatoes.

Finally, clean your strainer immediately after use. Tomato pulp and seeds dry like concrete and can be incredibly difficult to remove from the fine mesh of the screen once they’ve set. Rinse all parts immediately with hot water and use a stiff brush to clear the screen holes completely. Proper, prompt cleaning is the single best thing you can do to ensure your strainer works perfectly for years to come.

Ultimately, the right tomato strainer is the one that makes the vital task of preservation feel less like a chore and more like the satisfying culmination of your season’s hard work. By matching the tool to the scale of your garden, you ensure that every bit of your harvest can be enjoyed long after the vines have withered. This choice is a direct investment in your time, your food, and the self-sufficient rhythm of your farm.