6 Best Sheepdog Trainings for First-Time Handlers

Watching a skilled sheepdog work a flock is like witnessing magic, a silent language of instinct and command flowing between handler and dog. But when you’re the one holding the crook for the first time, with an eager pup and a dozen skeptical ewes, that magic can feel frustratingly out of reach. The key isn’t a secret whistle or an ancient bloodline; it’s a solid foundation built on understanding your dog and mastering a few essential skills.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Thank you!

Understanding Herding Instinct Before You Start

Before you even think about commands, you need to understand what’s driving your dog. Herding instinct isn’t a desire to be helpful; it’s a modified predatory sequence. The stalk, the chase, and the grip have been refined over generations into the "eye" (the intense stare), the outrun, and the controlled movement of stock. Your job as a handler is not to create this instinct, but to shape and control it.

A core concept to grasp is the balance point, an imaginary line usually at the shoulder of the livestock. A dog naturally wants to get to the head of the stock to turn it back to you. When the dog is on one side of that balance point, the sheep move away; when it’s on the other, they turn. All your flanking commands are simply ways of telling the dog which side of that line to be on to steer the flock. Recognizing this natural tendency is the first step from fighting your dog’s nature to working with it.

Mastering Basic Obedience as a Prerequisite

Many new handlers are so eager to get to the "real" work that they skip the most critical step: rock-solid basic obedience. A herding dog that doesn’t have a reliable recall or a solid "stay" is not a tool; it’s a liability. You must be able to call your dog off the stock under any circumstance, for the safety of your sheep, your dog, and yourself.

Think of obedience as the essential grammar of your communication. The dog needs to understand "stop," "come here," and "wait" with absolute certainty before you can start teaching it the more complex language of herding. These commands form the foundation for herding-specific cues like ‘Lie Down’ and ‘That’ll Do’. Rushing this phase is the single most common reason new handlers and their dogs fail.

Teaching Flanking: ‘Come-Bye’ and ‘Away to Me’

Flanking is the heart of herding, allowing you to steer your flock with precision. The two essential commands are ‘Come-Bye’ for a clockwise movement around the stock and ‘Away to Me’ for a counter-clockwise movement. The goal is to teach the dog to circle the sheep at a distance, influencing their direction without panicking them. Think of it as using a remote control to guide the flock.

Start without any stock. In a field, have the dog circle you or a stationary object like a bucket. As the dog circles one way, say ‘Come-Bye, Come-Bye’ in a calm, encouraging tone. When you want it to change direction, use a clear ‘Away to Me’. The objective here is to connect the words to the action of circling in a specific direction. Keep sessions short and positive, rewarding the dog for wide, calm circles, not for speed.

The ‘Lie Down’ Command for Essential Control

The ‘Lie Down’ is your emergency brake, and it’s non-negotiable. This isn’t the casual "down" you ask for in the living room; it’s an instant, muscle-locked drop to the ground, regardless of distance or distraction. Its purpose is to immediately take all pressure off the stock, giving both the sheep and you a moment to reset. A dog that won’t lie down when told is a dog that can’t be fully controlled.

When a dog is "on," its instinct to chase can quickly overwhelm it, leading to split-up flocks or stressed animals. The ‘Lie Down’ breaks that focus. It allows you to pause the action, assess the situation, and give your next command from a place of calm. This single command is the most important tool for preventing a situation from escalating out of control. It must be practiced until it is an automatic reflex for the dog.

Using a Round Pen for Safe Stock Introduction

Your first few sessions with live animals should be in a controlled environment, and nothing beats a round pen or a small, secure square pen (about 50-60 feet across). This setup has two major benefits. First, it limits the sheep’s ability to bolt and scatter across a large pasture, which can quickly overwhelm a young dog. Second, it keeps you close to the action, allowing you to guide, correct, and praise your dog effectively.

The round pen is a training arena, not a permanent solution. It allows the dog to learn how its presence affects the stock in a low-stakes environment. The dog will naturally circle the sheep along the fence, giving you the perfect opportunity to overlay your ‘Come-Bye’ and ‘Away to Me’ commands onto its natural movement. This is where the dog begins to understand that its job is to control the stock, not just chase it.

The ‘Walk Up’ Command to Drive Your Flock

While flanking steers the sheep, the ‘Walk Up’ command is your gas pedal. It tells the dog to move straight in towards the flock from behind, applying gentle pressure to encourage them forward. Without this command, you have a dog that can only circle, which is great for gathering but useless for moving animals from one pasture to another.

A good ‘Walk Up’ is a calm, steady advance, not a frantic rush. A dog that charges in will either scatter the flock or cause them to bolt. You want to teach your dog to read the stock’s pace and apply just enough pressure to keep them moving. This command is often taught after the dog has a reliable ‘Lie Down’, as you’ll need to stop the dog’s forward momentum frequently to keep the movement controlled.

Gathering Strays with the ‘Look Back’ Command

On a small farm, it’s common for a single ewe or lamb to get left behind when moving the flock. The ‘Look Back’ command is your tool for solving this. It directs your dog to leave the main group of sheep it’s currently working and go back for the one that was missed. This is a more advanced command that builds on the dog’s confidence and understanding of its job.

To teach this, you’ll need to set up the scenario. While the dog is moving a small group, have a helper hold one sheep back. Once the dog has moved the main group a short distance, stop the dog and use a command like ‘Look Back’ while pointing toward the lone sheep. This teaches the dog to broaden its focus from the immediate bunch to the entire flock, ensuring no animal is left behind.

The ‘That’ll Do’ Command to End a Session

Just as important as starting a job is knowing how to end it. ‘That’ll Do’ is the universal command to tell a herding dog that the work is finished. When the dog hears this, it should immediately disengage from the stock, release its focus, and often return to your side. This command is crucial for the dog’s mental well-being.

Without a clear end signal, a high-drive dog can become obsessive, continuing to "work" the sheep from the other side of the fence long after you’ve put them away. This creates unnecessary stress on both the dog and the livestock. ‘That’ll Do’ draws a firm line between work time and rest time, reinforcing your role as the leader who decides when the job begins and, more importantly, when it ends.

Combining Commands for a Smooth Herding Flow

Once your dog understands the individual commands, the next step is to string them together into a fluid sequence. This is where the training comes to life. A simple task like moving sheep from a paddock into a barn for the night becomes a conversation between you and your dog, not a series of disconnected actions.

Imagine the scenario: you send the dog with a ‘Come-Bye’ to gather the flock at the far end of the field. Once they’re bunched, you use a steady ‘Walk Up’ to move them towards the gate. If they start moving too fast, a quick ‘Lie Down’ pauses the action. A little ‘Away to Me’ can steer them through the gate, and once they’re in, a firm ‘That’ll Do’ signals the job is complete. This seamless flow is the ultimate goal of your training.

Avoiding Common Pitfalls for New Handlers

The most common mistakes in sheepdog training have less to do with the dog and more to do with the handler. The number one error is working for too long. A young dog’s brain is like a sponge, but it gets saturated quickly. Five to ten minutes of focused, successful training is far more valuable than a frustrating hour-long session. Always end on a positive note, even if it means stopping after a single good flank.

Another pitfall is excessive talking or making too many noises. Your commands should be clear, crisp, and distinct from your praise. Constant chatter just becomes white noise to the dog. Finally, manage your own frustration. The dog can sense it, and it will shut down or become anxious. If you feel yourself getting angry, put the dog away and try again tomorrow. This is a partnership, and your patience is the most important ingredient.

Training a sheepdog is a journey of patience, observation, and building a profound partnership with an incredible animal. Start with the basics, keep your sessions short, and celebrate the small victories along the way. The reward is not just a more efficient farm, but one of the most fulfilling working relationships you’ll ever experience.